Skip to main content

Guide

5-Year CDs Just Hit 5.00%: Should You Lock In?

Two banks now pay 5.00% on a five-year CD — the first in years. What locking in earns, what breaking it costs, and whether to wait for December.

By MoneyHabit Editorial Team

14 November 2026 · 9 min read

Brass bank vault door ajar with emerald light, gold coins and a seedling, with a five-step timeline
In this article

For the first time in years, a five-year certificate of deposit pays 5.00%. Two banks — Sallie Mae and Popular Direct — now offer that rate on a five-year CD, and several more pay 4.80% or above. It is the kind of number that makes savers stop scrolling: a guaranteed 5% a year, fixed for five years, with no stock-market risk. The catch is the one that has always defined CDs. Your money is locked away for the full five years, and breaking the deal early can cost you up to a year's interest. So is 5% worth five years of your money? Here is the honest maths.

What 5.00% actually pays

The top of the market moved fast this autumn. Popular Direct raised its five-year CD to 5.00% on 5 October — the first non-promotional 5.00% five-year CD in years — and Sallie Mae followed on 23 October. NerdWallet's November 2026 list puts the best five-year CD average at 4.74% APY, against a national average of just 1.41%.

Bank or credit union5-year CD rateMinimum deposit
Sallie Mae Bank5.00% APY$2,500
Popular Direct5.00% APY$10,000
CFG Bank4.82% APY$500
NASA Federal Credit Union4.80% APY$1,000
Synchrony Bank4.80% APYNo minimum
Barclays4.75% APYNo minimum
Marcus by Goldman Sachs4.60% APY$500

Rates verified 13 November 2026 via NerdWallet, Bankrate and APY Ledger. Credit unions such as NASA Federal require membership; check eligibility before applying.

The maths is where 5% gets serious. Put $10,000 into a five-year CD at 5.00% APY and it grows to $12,762.82 — $2,762.82 of interest, with the rate fixed for the whole term. The same $10,000 at the 1.41% national average grows to about $10,725. The gap between the best rate and the average rate is roughly $2,037 over five years — money that costs you nothing but a better account choice. (Own calculations, assuming annual compounding at the stated APY.)

Compare that with the best high-yield savings accounts, at around 4.40% APY. On paper they look close — $10,000 at 4.40% would reach about $12,409 after five years if the rate never moved. But it will move: savings rates float with the Fed, while a CD's rate is a contract that cannot fall. That is the whole point of locking in, and the whole risk of it.

Five per cent is not a prediction about the future. It is a contract: the bank guarantees that rate for five years, whatever the Federal Reserve does next.

The December question: lock in now or wait?

There is one good reason to hesitate. The Federal Reserve meets on 8–9 December, and another rate rise looks likely. The Fed held its benchmark at 3.75%–4.00% on 28 October in a 10–2 vote, with two officials dissenting in favour of a hike. Then October inflation came in hot — consumer prices rose 0.4% in the month, core inflation up 0.3% for the third month running — and futures markets repriced fast. After the CPI release, CME FedWatch put a quarter-point December hike at about 91%, with roughly a 9% chance of a half-point move. Fed Governor Christopher Waller had said hours earlier that he would consider a half-point rise if core inflation hit 0.3%.

If the Fed hikes in December, new CD rates will probably edge up too. So should you wait a month? Waiting means parking your money at about 4.40% instead of 5.00% — on $10,000, that month costs roughly $5 of forgone interest. The bigger risk is that the 5.00% offers are not permanent, and banks pull top rates without warning. The risk of locking in now is the opposite: rates climb to 5.25% and you spend five years watching better deals from the sidelines. A quarter-point on $10,000 is about $25 a year — neither risk is large in dollars, but only one can be managed after the fact. That is what the ladder below is for.

The catch: breaking a five-year CD is expensive

Penalties scale with the term, and five years carries the steepest ones in the industry. Federal rules set only a floor — seven days' simple interest if you withdraw within the first six days — and beyond that each bank sets its own schedule. Typical five-year penalties run from six to twelve months of interest.

Bank5-year CD early-withdrawal penalty
Ally Bank150 days' interest
Marcus by Goldman Sachs180 days' interest
Capital One6 months' interest
Chase365 days' interest
American Express540 days' interest
Discover18 months' interest

On $10,000 at 5.00%, a 12-month penalty costs about $500 and a 150-day penalty about $205 — and the penalty applies whether or not you have earned enough interest to cover it, so breaking a CD early can eat into your original deposit. Read the penalty schedule before you open the CD; it is the single most important line in the fine print.

Never lock away your emergency fund. A five-year CD is for money you are confident you will not need for five years. If there is any realistic chance you will need it — a house deposit, a career change, a baby — keep it somewhere you can reach it.

Who should lock in — and who should not

A five-year CD at 5% suits money with a known horizon of five years or more: a house-deposit fund for a purchase you do not plan before 2031, a slice of retirement savings you want guaranteed rather than invested, or cash you have set aside and want to stop yourself spending. The rate is fixed, the return is guaranteed, and deposits are federally insured up to $250,000 per depositor, per institution (FDIC for banks, NCUA for credit unions).

It does not suit your emergency fund, money you may need within five years, or anyone who would lose sleep watching rates rise while locked in. If you are in that last group, there is a middle path: the CD ladder.

The ladder: split $10,000 into five $2,000 CDs with terms of one, two, three, four and five years. Each year one CD matures and you reinvest it into a new five-year CD at whatever the top rate is then. After five years, one-fifth of your money matures every year, you always hold the best long-term rate, and you never have more than a fifth of your cash locked away for long.

How to open a five-year CD in four steps

  1. Compare live rates. Check NerdWallet, Bankrate or APY Ledger for the current top rates, then confirm the rate on the bank's own page — rates change daily and comparison tables lag by days.
  2. Read the penalty schedule and the maturity rules. Know the early-withdrawal cost and what happens at maturity: most CDs auto-renew into a new term unless you act during a grace period of about seven to ten days.
  3. Confirm the insurance and the minimum. FDIC or NCUA coverage up to $250,000, and minimums from $0 at Synchrony to $10,000 at Popular Direct. Credit unions may require membership.
  4. Fund it, then set a maturity reminder. Put the maturity date in your calendar now — five years is long enough to forget.

One tax note: in the US, CD interest is taxed as ordinary income in the year it is earned, even if you leave it in the account. A 5.00% APY is a pre-tax return; your after-tax return depends on your bracket.

The UK version: five-year fixed bonds pay even more

British savers get an even better deal. The best five-year fixed-rate bonds pay 5.36% AER from Afin Bank and Chetwood, with GB Bank at 5.35% (Deposit Scout, 13 November 2026). Even NS&I, the government-backed provider, pays 5.17%. The Bank of England raised Bank Rate to 4% on 5 November, in an 8–1 vote, with the next decision on 17 December.

The UK twist is that you barely get paid for the extra years: Afin's two-year bond pays 5.28%, almost the same as its five-year rate, for three fewer years locked away. Compare the two-year and five-year rates side by side before committing to five. UK savings are protected up to £120,000 per person, per banking licence, by the Financial Services Compensation Scheme, and interest counts toward your Personal Savings Allowance — £1,000 a year tax-free for basic-rate taxpayers, £500 for higher-rate taxpayers.

Frequently asked questions

Is the 5% rate guaranteed for the full five years?

Yes. A standard CD's rate is fixed when you open it and cannot change during the term. The bank's side of the bargain is the guarantee; your side is leaving the money alone.

What happens when the CD matures?

Most banks give you a grace period of about seven to ten days to withdraw the money or move it elsewhere. If you do nothing, the CD usually auto-renews into a new term at whatever rate the bank is then offering — which may be lower. Set a reminder.

What if rates rise to 6% after I lock in?

You keep earning 5%. Your options are to accept it, break the CD and pay the penalty, or avoid the problem in advance with a ladder so only a fifth of your money is ever locked at the old rate.

Key takeaways

  • Two banks now pay 5.00% APY on five-year CDs — the first non-promotional 5% long-term CDs in years — with several more at 4.80% or above.
  • $10,000 at 5.00% grows to $12,762.82 in five years; at the 1.41% national average it reaches only about $10,725.
  • The Fed meets 8–9 December with markets pricing about a 91% chance of another hike — waiting a month costs roughly $5 on $10,000, but the 5% offers could be pulled first.
  • Breaking a five-year CD early typically costs six to twelve months of interest — up to about $500 on $10,000 — and can eat into your deposit.
  • Only lock away money you will not need for five years, and consider a ladder so a fifth of your cash matures every year.

The return of the 5% five-year CD is a genuine milestone for savers — the first time in years that patience has paid this well with zero market risk. Check what your savings earn today: if it is anywhere near the 1.41% national average, a five-year CD at 5% is worth a serious look. Compare the top rates, read the penalty schedule, and if the money is truly spare for five years, lock it in before the rate moves.

Sources

Share this article

MoneyHabit Editorial Team

The MoneyHabit editorial desk researches, writes and reviews every article against our editorial policy.

More from MoneyHabit Editorial Team

The Sunday Habit

One useful money idea, every week.

A short, practical email every Sunday — no spam, no selling your address, unsubscribe anytime.

Advertisement

More in Budgeting & Saving