Skip to main content

Explainer

Overdraft Fees: The $80M Refund That Vanished

The CFPB defended cancelling $80M in overdraft refunds — and the $5 fee cap is gone. What it means for your bank fees, and how to stop paying them.

By MoneyHabit Editorial Team

9 November 2026 · 12 min read

Debit card with a glowing $35 fee stamp blocked by an emerald shield, gold coins and a seedling
In this article

Last week, America's consumer watchdog confirmed something that will sting millions of bank customers: $80 million in overdraft refunds that were supposed to go back to Navy Federal Credit Union members will never be paid. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) defended its decision to cancel the refunds in its semiannual report to Congress, released on 27 October 2026 — and the story matters far beyond one credit union. The same year also saw the death of the rule that would have capped overdraft fees at $5. If you ever pay an overdraft fee, this reversal changes what you can expect — and what you need to do instead.

What just happened

Navy Federal is the largest credit union in the United States, with about $204 billion in assets, serving military personnel, veterans and their families. In November 2024, the CFPB ordered it to refund more than $80 million to members and pay a $15 million civil penalty, after finding it had charged improper overdraft fees between 2017 and 2022.

Then, on 1 July 2025, the CFPB terminated that consent order and waived any alleged non-compliance with it. Its October 2026 report to Congress — the first detailed explanation of the reversal — confirmed the outcome: Navy Federal paid the full $15 million penalty, but none of the roughly $80 million in consumer refunds was ever distributed.

The bureau's stated reasons were threefold. First, it said Navy Federal had disclosed the fees three times and required members to opt in to the overdraft service. Second, it argued the original enforcement relied on an overly broad reading of its power to ban unfair, deceptive or abusive practices — including 2022 guidance that was withdrawn in May 2025. Third, it argued the refunds would ultimately have been funded by the credit union's own membership. The report also noted that the bureau terminated 16 pending final orders in the year to 30 June 2026; Navy Federal was the exception in that its refunds had not been paid.

What are "authorized positive" overdraft fees?

The fees at the centre of the case have a clunky name: "authorized positive" overdraft fees. Here is how they worked.

You tap your debit card to buy groceries. At that moment, you have enough money in your account, so the bank authorizes the transaction. But debit card purchases do not always settle instantly — they can take a day or two to clear. If another payment goes out in the meantime and your balance drops below zero, the original purchase settles into a negative balance — and the bank charges you an overdraft fee, even though you had the money when you made the purchase.

Regulators under the previous CFPB leadership called this a surprise fee: the customer did everything right at the point of sale and still got charged. The current bureau disagrees, saying the fees were disclosed and the service was opt-in. Whatever your view of the legal argument, the practical result is the same: the refunds are gone, and the practice's legality is no longer being challenged by the federal regulator.

The one-sentence version: the government ordered $80 million back to customers, then cancelled the order — and the customers who paid those fees between 2017 and 2022 will not see that money.

The $5 cap that never arrived

The Navy Federal reversal is the second blow to overdraft-fee reform in the space of a year. The first was the death of the CFPB's overdraft rule itself.

DateWhat happened
December 2024The CFPB finalizes a rule capping overdraft fees at $5 — or a cost-based amount — for banks and credit unions with more than $10 billion in assets. It estimates the rule would save households about $5 billion a year, or roughly $225 a year for each household that pays overdraft fees.
March–April 2025Congress passes a joint resolution under the Congressional Review Act overturning the rule — the Senate on 27 March, the House on 9 April.
9 May 2025The President signs the repeal into law (P.L. 119-10). The rule never takes effect.
1 July 2025The CFPB terminates the Navy Federal consent order, cancelling about $80 million in refunds.
27 October 2026The CFPB's semiannual report to Congress defends the termination, confirming the $15 million penalty was paid but none of the refunds were.

The Congressional Review Act detail matters: once Congress overturns a rule this way, the agency cannot issue a substantially similar rule without fresh authorization from Congress. So the $5 cap is not delayed — it is closed. If you were waiting for it, stop waiting.

What overdrafts actually cost you now

With no federal cap, the price is whatever your bank's fee schedule says. The CFPB puts the average overdraft fee at about $35 per item. And the industry is collecting more, not less: banks and credit unions took in an estimated $12.4 billion in overdraft and non-sufficient funds (NSF) fees in 2025, with the top 20 consumer banks accounting for about $4 billion of that. In the first six months of 2026 alone, 512 banks with more than $1 billion in assets reported $2.96 billion in overdraft and NSF revenue.

CFPB research found banks cut overdraft and NSF revenue by nearly 50% between 2020 and 2023, mostly because of public pressure rather than law. But at the top 20 banks, overdraft revenue rose 6.2% in 2025 compared with 2023. The pressure, in other words, is easing — and fees are creeping back.

BankAverage overdraft revenue per account, 2025
Woodforest Bank$94
First Convenience Bank$68
Arvest Bank$45
Regions Bank$30
Citizens Bank$19
TD Bank$18
Fifth Third / Huntington$17 each
Wells Fargo$15

The gap between banks is enormous — and it is the single most useful fact in this article. Some large banks now charge no overdraft fees at all: Capital One, Citibank, American Express and Ally Bank are among them, and none of the top 20 consumer banks charges NSF fees anymore. The fee you pay depends heavily on which bank you chose, years ago, possibly by accident.

One bank's story shows how quickly things can reverse. BMO cut its overdraft fee from $36 to $15, and its overdraft revenue fell from $27 million in 2023 to $2 million in 2025. In 2026 it backtracked, raising the fee to $20 and cutting the fee-free cushion from $50 to $20.

The $5 cap is not delayed — it is closed. If you were waiting for it, stop waiting. The fee you pay now depends on your bank's policy and your own settings.

The maths that should worry you

A $35 fee sounds small until you annualize it. Take a $40 shortfall that you cover two days later. The fee is $35 — that is 87.5% of the amount borrowed, for two days. Annualized, that works out to roughly 16,000% — an illustration, not a real APR, because overdraft fees are charged as flat fees rather than interest, but it shows the scale of what a "small" fee really costs on a small, short shortfall.

The more ordinary maths is worse in aggregate. Six overdrafts in a year at $35 each is $210 — about $17.50 a month, every month, for the privilege of your bank covering a few dollars of timing gap. The CFPB estimated the $5 cap would have saved fee-paying households about $225 a year; that figure is, roughly, the money now staying with the banks. And $12.4 billion collected in 2025 works out to about $34 million a day across the industry (own calculation).

Watch for fee stacking. Some banks charge per item, per day, with daily caps. A single bad week — three small purchases settling after a bill goes out — can mean three separate $35 fees, $105 in total, for transactions that were all approved when you had the money. Check your bank's per-day cap in its fee schedule; it is often buried in the small print.

The rights you still have

The repeal and the reversal removed two protections, but they did not remove everything. Three rights still apply in the US:

  • The opt-in rule. Since 2010, under Regulation E, your bank cannot charge you an overdraft fee on an ATM withdrawal or a one-time debit card purchase unless you opted in to overdraft coverage for those transactions. If you never opted in, those fees should not appear. Check your account settings — many people opted in years ago during account opening and forgot.
  • The right to dispute errors. Regulation E also governs error reports, including unauthorized transactions. If a fee stems from a transaction you did not authorize, report it promptly; the timing of your report affects your liability.
  • Goodwill reversals. Banks can waive fees at their discretion, and many do — especially for a first fee or a long-standing customer who asks. It costs nothing to call and ask, and the success rate is far higher than most people assume.

State consumer-protection law may add further rights, and the CFPB's own site remains the place to check the current status of any rule before relying on older information.

Seven ways to stop paying overdraft fees

  1. Turn off overdraft coverage for debit and ATM transactions. With coverage off, a purchase that would overdraw you is simply declined. A declined card is embarrassing for ten seconds; a $35 fee is not. This is the single highest-impact move, and it is free.
  2. Set a low-balance alert. Most banking apps let you set an alert at, say, $100. The alert arrives before the fee does.
  3. Link a savings account as backup. Many banks offer overdraft protection that transfers money from a linked savings account, usually for a small transfer fee — or free. It is almost always cheaper than $35 per item.
  4. Keep a small buffer and treat it as zero. A $100 buffer that you mentally treat as your real zero turns a timing gap into a non-event. It is the cheapest insurance in personal finance.
  5. Ask for a refund every time. Call, be polite, cite your history, and ask for the fee to be reversed as a courtesy. If the first representative says no, ask to escalate. One successful call a year can save more than most budgeting apps ever will.
  6. Time your bills to your paydays. Overdrafts are usually a timing problem, not a money problem. Moving a direct debit by a few days — or splitting a large bill across paydays — removes the gap that creates the fee.
  7. Switch banks if yours is expensive. The per-account table above is the argument in one glance: $94 a year at the most expensive bank versus $0 at banks that charge no overdraft fees at all. Switching a current account takes under an hour in most cases, and your direct debits can usually move with it.

If you're in the UK: a different system

British readers live under a very different regime — and in this case, a stricter one. Since 6 April 2020, the Financial Conduct Authority's overdraft reforms require UK banks to price overdrafts with a single annual interest rate, with no fixed daily or monthly fees, and the same rate whether the overdraft was arranged in advance or not. Most major banks settled at around 39.9% APR, which means borrowing £100 for a whole year costs about £39.90.

That rate is high — roughly double a typical credit card APR — but the structure is transparent: you pay interest on what you borrow, for the days you borrow it, and nothing else. There are no $35-per-item surprises, and banks must contact customers who use their overdraft heavily and point them to free debt advice. The US system, by contrast, still runs on flat per-item fees with no federal ceiling at all.

Frequently asked questions

Will Navy Federal members get their $80 million after all?

No. The CFPB terminated the consent order on 1 July 2025 and waived compliance with it; its October 2026 report confirms none of the refunds were paid. A separate private class action over denied fraud claims is a different case and a different legal theory, so it does not change the overdraft outcome.

Is there any federal cap on overdraft fees now?

No. The December 2024 rule that would have capped fees at $5 for large institutions was repealed by Congress in May 2025 under the Congressional Review Act, and the CFPB cannot issue a substantially similar rule without new authorization from Congress.

Can my bank charge me an overdraft fee if I never opted in?

Not for ATM withdrawals or one-time debit card purchases — Regulation E has required your opt-in for those since 2010. Recurring payments such as direct debits and standing orders are treated differently, so check your account agreement for those.

Which banks charge no overdraft fees?

According to CFPB data, Capital One, Citibank, American Express and Ally Bank charge no overdraft fees, and none of the top 20 consumer banks charges NSF fees. Fee schedules change, so confirm your own bank's current schedule rather than relying on any list.

What should I do if I was charged an "authorized positive" fee?

First, check whether you opted in to overdraft coverage and consider turning it off. Then call your bank and ask for the fee to be reversed as a courtesy, especially if it is your first. If the fee relates to a transaction you did not authorize, report it as an error under Regulation E promptly, since reporting deadlines affect your liability.

Key takeaways

  • The CFPB cancelled about $80 million in overdraft refunds owed to Navy Federal members; the $15 million penalty was paid, the refunds were not.
  • The $5 overdraft fee cap was repealed by Congress in May 2025 and cannot return without new legislation — there is currently no federal ceiling on overdraft fees.
  • The average fee is about $35, and banks collected an estimated $12.4 billion in overdraft and NSF fees in 2025.
  • Your best defences are free: opt out of debit-card overdraft coverage, set a low-balance alert, keep a $100 buffer, and ask for every fee to be reversed.
  • Some banks charge no overdraft fees at all — if yours charges $30+ per account a year on average, switching is the highest-value move.

The Navy Federal case is a reminder of how consumer protection actually works in practice: rules can be written, then repealed; orders can be agreed, then terminated. The protection that remains is the one you set up yourself — an opt-out, an alert, a buffer, and a bank whose fee schedule you have actually read. That takes an afternoon. The fees it prevents can run to hundreds of dollars a year, every year.

Sources

Share this article

MoneyHabit Editorial Team

The MoneyHabit editorial desk researches, writes and reviews every article against our editorial policy.

More from MoneyHabit Editorial Team

The Sunday Habit

One useful money idea, every week.

A short, practical email every Sunday — no spam, no selling your address, unsubscribe anytime.

Advertisement

More in Money News & Explainers