Guide
Health Insurance Said No? How to Appeal a Denial
A Brooklyn mum turned a $27,000 'cosmetic' denial into full coverage. Here's the exact appeal process — and why most denied claims are never challenged.

In this article
- A denial is common — and usually unchallenged
- Step 1: Read the denial letter properly
- Step 2: File the internal appeal
- Step 3: Take it to an independent external review
- The six most common denial reasons — and the fix for each
- What to do while the bill is hanging over you
- Free help if you get stuck
- If you are in the UK
- Frequently asked questions
- Key takeaways
A Brooklyn mother spent months fighting her health insurer over a $27,000 surgery bill for her nine-year-old son — and won. Her insurer, Aetna, had called the operation "cosmetic" and refused to pay, even though her son's doctors said it was medically necessary. The family appealed, were denied again, then took the case to an independent reviewer. The reviewer sided with them, and Aetna agreed to cover the surgery in full.
The story matters because it is not rare. Insurers deny a large share of the claims they receive, and most people never challenge the decision. The appeal process exists for exactly this situation, it costs little or nothing, and the odds of winning are far better than most people assume. This guide walks through it step by step.
A denial is common — and usually unchallenged
Nadine Friedman's son Ozzie was born with Goldenhar syndrome, a rare condition that affects how the face and skull develop — roughly 1 in 3,500 to 5,000 births, according to the Cleveland Clinic. The surgery he needed would fix his ear, which caused him pain, redness and growth problems. Aetna denied coverage, saying the procedure was cosmetic. The family's doctors wrote to the insurer explaining it was medically necessary. Aetna denied the internal appeal anyway.
Denials like this are routine. Moneywise cites data showing Aetna denied 22% of in-network Affordable Care Act marketplace claims in 2023 — about one in five, just above the national average of 20%. A 2026 KFF analysis of newly published insurer data found marketplace insurers denied 18% of standard prior-authorisation requests in 2025, Medicare Advantage plans 12% and Medicaid managed-care plans 14%.
Here is the part most people miss: when denials are appealed, a large share are overturned. KFF found that 67% of appealed prior-authorisation denials were reversed in Medicare Advantage, 47% in Medicaid managed care, and 43% in ACA marketplace plans. Yet appeals remain rare. The insurer's first "no" is often treated as final — and, as Friedman put it, fighting it meant becoming "a part-time insurance lawyer".
A denial letter is not a verdict. It is the insurer's first answer — and federal law gives you the right to ask for a second one, first from the plan itself, then from an independent reviewer who does not work for them.
Step 1: Read the denial letter properly
Everything starts with the letter. Under federal rules (45 CFR 147.136), your plan must tell you in writing why it denied the claim, how to appeal, and how to request an external review once the internal appeal is over. Do not skim it. Three things in it decide your whole case:
- The stated reason. The denial will name one: not medically necessary, experimental or investigational, no prior authorisation, out of network, not a covered benefit, or a coding error. Your appeal must answer that specific reason.
- The deadline. Put the appeal deadline on your calendar before anything else. A missed internal deadline can forfeit your right to an external review later.
- The denial code. The code tells you whether the problem is clinical (the insurer disagrees with your doctor) or administrative (a wrong code, a missing form, a referral that never arrived). Administrative denials are often the easiest to fix.
If the letter is vague, call the plan and ask for the denial in writing with the specific plan language and clinical criteria it relied on — you are entitled to that information free of charge. Then ask your doctor for a letter of medical necessity that answers the plan's stated reason point by point, using the plan's own criteria as its headings. A generic "my patient needs this" letter is weak; one that walks through the insurer's own checklist is strong.
Keep a paper trail from day one. Note the date, time, name and job title of everyone you speak to, and what they said. Keep copies of everything you send and send copies, not originals. If a phone call changes anything, follow it up in writing the same day.
Step 2: File the internal appeal
The internal appeal is the plan reviewing its own decision. You file it with the insurance company, in writing, in the way the denial letter says. For marketplace and job-based health plans, HealthCare.gov states you must file within 180 days — six months — of receiving notice that your claim was denied. Medicare Advantage and Medicare Part D plans give you 65 days from the date on the denial notice, and original Medicare works to the date printed on your Medicare Summary Notice.
The plan then has to decide on a clock: within 72 hours for urgent-care cases, within 30 days if you are appealing a denial of care you have not yet received, and within 60 days for care you already received.
| Deadline | Marketplace / job-based plan | Medicare Advantage / Part D |
|---|---|---|
| File the internal appeal | Within 180 days of the denial notice | Within 65 days of the denial notice |
| Plan's decision — urgent care | Within 72 hours | Within 72 hours |
| Plan's decision — care not yet received | Within 30 days | Within 30 days |
| Plan's decision — care already received | Within 60 days | Within 60 days |
| File the external review | Within 4 months of the final internal denial | Different process — see below |
A good internal appeal letter is short, factual and organised. Put the patient's name, member ID, claim number, date of service and provider at the top, state clearly that you are requesting an internal appeal — a "full and fair review" — and then answer the reason: attach the doctor's letter of medical necessity, and if the denial says a drug or procedure is experimental, attach the clinical guideline or FDA label that says otherwise. If it says out of network, attach the referral or proof that no in-network clinician was available. If waiting for a standard decision could seriously jeopardise your health, ask for an expedited appeal — in urgent situations you may file an internal appeal and an external review request at the same time.
Step 3: Take it to an independent external review
If the internal appeal fails, this is the step most families never hear about — and the one that won the Friedman family's case. An external review sends your case to an independent third party who does not work for your insurer. Under federal law, you can request one within four months of receiving the final internal denial, for any denial involving medical judgement, a denial calling care experimental or investigational, or a cancellation of coverage. Your insurer is required by law to accept the reviewer's decision. Medicare Advantage works differently: if the plan upholds its denial, it must automatically send your case to an independent review entity — you do not file a separate external review request.
A standard external review must be decided no later than 45 days after the request is received; an expedited review no later than 72 hours. The review is run by your state insurance department or, where the state has no qualifying process, by the federal HHS-administered process (requests by phone at 1-888-866-6205). The federal process is free; otherwise a fee may apply, but it cannot exceed $25 per external review.
The Friedman family filed for an external review with the state of New York, where a patient can file within four months of the plan's final internal appeal decision, the fee is $25 per appeal (capped at $75 per plan year, waived for hardship and for Medicaid and Child Health Plus enrollees), a standard appeal is decided within 30 days, and the reviewer's decision is binding. Earlier this autumn, the external reviewer agreed with the family, and Aetna agreed to cover the roughly $27,000 procedure.
That result is not unusual. Researchers at Brown University and Weill Cornell found that 52% of denials that reached external appeal in New York last year were reversed, according to CBS New York. The step people skip most often is also the step most likely to change the answer.
Do not let the internal appeal clock run out. The four-month window for external review starts from the final internal denial — so a late internal appeal can quietly close the door on the independent review that has the best odds of success.
The six most common denial reasons — and the fix for each
Most denials fall into a handful of categories, and each has a different fix. Matching your appeal to the reason is what makes it work.
| Denial reason | What it usually means | Your strongest response |
|---|---|---|
| Coding or billing error | Wrong procedure code submitted — in Ozzie's case, Aetna said the code was typically used for cosmetic procedures | Ask the provider to correct and resubmit the claim with the right code and supporting notes |
| Not medically necessary | The insurer's reviewer disagrees with your doctor | Doctor's letter of medical necessity answering the plan's own criteria, plus clinical guidelines |
| No prior authorisation | Approval was required before treatment | Proof authorisation was requested, or that the situation was urgent; ask for retroactive authorisation |
| Out of network | Provider not in the plan's network | Referral records, or proof no in-network provider was available in time |
| Experimental or investigational | Insurer classifies the treatment as unproven | FDA label, peer-reviewed evidence, or a guideline showing it is standard care for your condition |
| Not a covered benefit | Plan says the service is excluded | Check the plan documents yourself — exclusions are sometimes applied to the wrong category of care |
The coding-error row deserves emphasis, because it is the cheapest win in the whole process. Aetna told CBS that the original billing code submitted for Ozzie's surgery "is typically for coverage of a cosmetic procedure and warranted further review" — the label on the paperwork, not the surgery itself, drove the first denial. Before you write a long appeal, ask the provider's billing office to check the code. A corrected claim sometimes resolves the whole thing without an appeal at all.
What to do while the bill is hanging over you
A denial often arrives with a bill for the full amount, and the instinct is to pay it to make the problem go away. In most cases, do not pay the full balance while an appeal is pending — paying can be treated as accepting the charge, and getting money back is harder than never sending it. Instead:
- Ask for an itemised bill. Errors are common: duplicate charges, services never received, wrong quantities.
- Tell the provider you are appealing. Ask billing to put the account on hold and confirm in writing that it will not be sent to collections while the appeal runs.
- Negotiate the price. If the appeal fails, the billed amount is rarely the final price. Ask for the cash-pay rate, a prompt-payment discount, or a charity-care application — non-profit hospitals must have financial-assistance policies, and many patients who qualify never apply.
- Set up a payment plan rather than a lump sum. Interest-free plans are common, and a small monthly payment keeps the account current while you appeal. Do not ignore the bill — an unpaid medical bill can be reported to credit bureaus and sold to a collector.
Free help if you get stuck
You do not have to do this alone, and you do not have to hire a lawyer to start. Your state insurance department can explain your state's process and sometimes intervene directly — that is the office that ran the external review in the Friedman case. The Patient Advocate Foundation offers free case management for people fighting denials and medical debt, your hospital's patient advocate can help with charity-care applications, and if your plan is through an employer, the HR benefits team can sometimes get a faster answer from the insurer than you can on your own. Friedman is now campaigning for a federal bill, the Ensuring Lasting Smiles Act, which would require insurers to cover medically necessary treatments for people with congenital anomalies or birth defects.
If you are in the UK
The process above is American, but the principle travels. In the UK, most healthcare is provided by the NHS, so this applies to private medical insurance. If your private insurer refuses a claim, complain to the insurer first and ask for a formal written response — it has up to eight weeks to send a final response. If you are unhappy with it, or eight weeks pass without one, you can take the complaint to the Financial Ombudsman Service, which is free to use. You generally need to contact the Ombudsman within six months of the insurer's final response, and it can award up to £455,000 for complaints referred on or after 1 April 2026 (£445,000 for complaints referred between 1 April 2025 and 31 March 2026).
Frequently asked questions
How long do I have to appeal a denied health insurance claim?
For marketplace and job-based plans in the US, you have 180 days from the denial notice to file an internal appeal, and four months from the final internal denial to request an external review. Medicare Advantage and Part D plans give you 65 days. The exact deadline is on your denial letter — check it first, because a missed deadline can end your case.
Does appealing actually work?
Often, yes. KFF's 2026 analysis found 43% of appealed prior-authorisation denials in ACA marketplace plans were overturned, rising to 67% in Medicare Advantage, and in New York 52% of denials that reached external appeal were reversed. The catch is that very few people appeal at all.
What does an external review cost?
The federal HHS-administered process is free. State-run processes may charge a fee, but no more than $25 per review — in New York the fee is $25 per appeal, capped at $75 a year, and waived for hardship and for Medicaid and Child Health Plus enrollees.
Should I pay the bill while I appeal?
Usually not the full amount. Ask the provider to put the account on hold while the appeal runs and confirm in writing that it will not go to collections. If the appeal fails, ask for the cash-pay rate, a discount, or a charity-care application before paying anything.
What if the denial says my treatment is "cosmetic"?
Ask your doctor for a letter of medical necessity that explains, in clinical terms, why the treatment is needed for your health — pain, function, growth, or risk — and answers the insurer's own criteria. In the Friedman case the "cosmetic" label came from the billing code submitted, not the surgery itself, and an independent reviewer overturned it.
Key takeaways
- A denial is the insurer's first answer, not the last word — appeals overturn 43% to 67% of challenged denials, depending on the plan type.
- Read the denial letter first: the stated reason, the deadline and the denial code decide your whole case.
- File the internal appeal within 180 days (marketplace and job-based plans) or 65 days (Medicare Advantage and Part D), with a doctor's letter of medical necessity that answers the insurer's own criteria.
- If the internal appeal fails, request an external review within four months — an independent reviewer decides, the decision is binding, and in New York 52% of denials that reach this step are reversed.
- While you appeal, ask the provider to put the bill on hold, get an itemised bill, and do not pay the full balance or ignore the bill.
The Friedman family won because they used every step the system offers: they read the denial, appealed internally, and then asked an independent reviewer to look at it. It took months, and it took time and persistence that not every family has. But the process itself is free, the deadlines are generous if you catch them early, and the odds at the final step are genuinely good. If a letter from your insurer has just told you no, the most expensive thing you can do is nothing — check the deadline on that letter today, call your doctor's office tomorrow, and file the appeal.
Sources
- Moneywise — Mom fights Aetna’s $27K surgery denial
- KFF — Prior Authorization Metrics Provide New Insights into Insurer Practices
- Black Health — Denied by Your Health Insurer? How to Appeal, State by State
- MesoCare — Your Insurance Said No: How to Appeal a Denial (2026)
- Parent Diaries — Aetna Called Ear Surgery Cosmetic: Mom Wins Appeal
- CMS — How to appeal a decision about your health insurance
- Financial Ombudsman Service — Private medical and dental insurance
The MoneyHabit editorial desk researches, writes and reviews every article against our editorial policy.
The Sunday Habit
One useful money idea, every week.
A short, practical email every Sunday — no spam, no selling your address, unsubscribe anytime.
Advertisement
More in Financial Literacy

Financial Literacy · Guide
Renters Insurance Basics: What It Covers and Costs
Your landlord's insurance covers the building, never your belongings. Renters insurance costs about $14 a month in the US. Here's what it covers.
20 November 2026 · 12 min read

Financial Literacy · Explainer
Disability Insurance Searches Are Surging: What to Know
Disability insurance searches jumped 30x as open enrollment opens. Here is what the coverage does, what it costs, and how to decide whether you need it.
3 November 2026 · 6 min read

Financial Literacy · Guide
HSA and FSA at the Same Time? The Rule Most People Miss
A viral Reddit post exposed a costly trap: maxing an HSA while a spouse holds an FSA makes the contributions ineligible, with a 6% tax every year it sits there.
20 November 2026 · 11 min read