Skip to main content

Explainer

Prediction Markets Traded $123 Billion in October

Prediction markets traded a record $123.3 billion in October. Here is how the $1 contracts work, what the fees really cost, and the legal fight still raging.

By MoneyHabit Editorial Team

6 November 2026 · 10 min read

Illustration of a split coin — half dollar coin, half ballot slip — above a market chart and a crowd of traders
In this article

In October 2026, Americans traded a record $123.3 billion on prediction markets — betting on everything from the midterm elections to the price of eggs. Kalshi, the biggest platform, handled about 80% of it. Days later, a federal judge shielded the platforms from new state taxes, and the midterm results landed almost exactly where the markets said they would. Prediction markets have gone from a niche curiosity to a mainstream money habit in about a year. Before you put a dollar in, know three things: the headline number is smaller than it looks, the fees quietly eat small trades alive, and the law still hasn't decided what these platforms are.

How a prediction market actually works

A prediction market lets you buy a contract on a yes-or-no question: Will the Fed cut rates in December? Will it rain in Chicago tomorrow? Will a given team win on Sunday? Each contract pays $1 if you're right and $0 if you're wrong. The price is the market's estimate of the chance — a contract trading at 62 cents implies roughly a 62% probability.

You can sell before the event settles, so the price moves like a stock. Buy at 35 cents, sell at 55 cents, and you've made 20 cents per contract. The platforms don't take the other side of your trade the way a bookmaker does — they run an order book, match buyers with sellers, and earn fees. Kalshi is a federally regulated exchange, overseen by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). Polymarket runs a regulated US platform alongside its older international exchange, and Robinhood routes its customers' orders to exchanges including Kalshi.

That regulatory status is the industry's proudest talking point, and it's real as far as it goes. But a CFTC-regulated exchange is not a bank and not a brokerage account. A contract that pays $1 or $0 is a binary outcome: if you're wrong, you lose 100% of what you staked on it.

The $123 billion month — and the asterisk

October 2026 was the biggest month in prediction-market history. Per Artemis data, reported in early November, total volume hit $123.3 billion, up about 54% from September's previous high, across nearly 643 million trades. Kalshi did $98.2 billion of it. Polymarket did $20.2 billion, with its regulated US platform setting its own monthly record of nearly $10 billion.

Impressive — but the number needs grading before you quote it. More than two-thirds of Kalshi's volume (67.6%) came from Combos, its parlay-style product, and most of those were long shots priced below a cent. Kalshi counts every contract at its full $1 payout value no matter what the trader actually paid, so a parlay bought for a fraction of a penny still adds a whole dollar to the headline volume. The 643 million trade count is the better signal of real growth: lots of people are trading, even if the dollar figure overstates how much money actually changed hands.

The midterms were the big test — and the odds mostly passed

Prediction markets have one claim that matters more than volume: that crowds price reality better than polls. The midterms were the first big public test of that claim since the 2024 presidential race. Election markets passed $1.4 billion by the weekend before the vote, and the Washington Post put the total at about $1.9 billion by the afternoon before Election Day, across more than 7,000 outcomes. Kalshi's House control market alone traded about $170 million, and it priced a Democratic House win at 93% and a Democratic Senate win at 74%. The Democrats went on to sweep the midterms. On the headline question, the market was right — and confident.

But "the market was right" needs the same grading as the volume figure. Two facts cut against taking any single price at face value:

  • Thin markets move easily. Researchers at the Anti-Corruption Data Collective found that a $3,500 position moves 97% of midterm election contracts by at least five cents. In thin markets, a few big traders set the price, not a wise crowd.
  • A few wallets dominate. Reuters reported that on Polymarket's international exchange, the top 1% of wallets accounted for roughly 70% of congressional election trading volume this cycle. When a handful of accounts are most of the volume, the price reflects their views — and their incentives.

Read a prediction-market price as "what traders with money on the line currently believe", not as a forecast with a margin of error. A 93% price is not a 93% certainty — it is a price, set by whoever showed up to trade.

What it actually costs you

The platforms advertise low fees, and for large trades on likely outcomes that is roughly true. For the small, cheap, long-shot trades most newcomers make, the fees are brutal — because they are charged per contract, not as a percentage of your stake. Kalshi's taker fee (for an order that fills immediately) is 0.07 × contracts × price × (1 − price), rounded up to the next cent; resting limit orders are free on most markets.

100 contracts at…Your stakeKalshi taker feeFee as % of stakeChance needed to break even
10¢$10.00$0.636.3%10.63%
35¢$35.00$1.604.6%36.60%
50¢$50.00$1.753.5%51.75%
90¢$90.00$0.630.7%90.63%

Work it through on a real trade. Buy 200 Yes contracts at 35 cents: $70 staked, $3.19 entry fee. If you hold to a win, the fee takes about 2.5% of your $130 profit. But if you trade in and out — selling at 55 cents for a $40 gross profit — the entry and exit fees total $6.66, or 16.7% of that profit. And a single contract at 5 cents pays a 1-cent fee after rounding: 20% of the stake, gone before the event even happens.

Robinhood charges more on the same trade: a commission of 10% of the same price term (5% with Gold), capped at 1 cent per contract, plus an exchange fee of up to 1 cent. On 100 contracts at 50 cents that's up to $2.00 against Kalshi's $1.75; at 10 or 90 cents it's up to $1.90 against Kalshi's $0.63. Polymarket's international exchange has historically charged no trading fees, while its regulated US platform charges a flat 0.10% taker-only fee. Card deposits on Kalshi can carry up to a 2% processing fee; bank transfers and withdrawals are free, and the minimum deposit is $10.

The fee maths punishes exactly the behaviour the apps encourage: lots of small trades on cheap long shots. If you buy a 5-cent contract, you need the event to be more than 20% more likely than the price implies just to cover the fee. Frequent trading is where the money leaks.

The biggest risk to prediction markets isn't a bad trade — it's a court ruling. The industry's legal position is that event contracts are federally regulated derivatives, so state gambling laws don't apply. The states disagree, and both sides are litigating everywhere at once.

In early November, US District Judge Martha Pacold issued a preliminary injunction stopping Illinois from imposing licences, fees and taxes on sports event contracts — blocking a framework that would have taxed each wager at 1.75%, rising to 3.5% after five million transactions. Illinois has appealed. The CFTC has sued 10 states in 2026 alone, and nearly 30 bills targeting prediction markets have been introduced in Congress since 2025, though none has passed. After Utah brought criminal charges against Kalshi, DraftKings, FanDuel and PrizePicks pulled their event contracts back in the state, and Fanatics was reported to be stopping Utah trades on 4 November. This week the Second Circuit hears Kalshi's New York and Connecticut appeals and the First Circuit hears Robinhood's Massachusetts appeal. A preliminary injunction is not a final ruling. The rules could still change under your open positions.

The tax question nobody can answer yet

Here's the part almost nobody mentions in the app: the IRS has issued no comprehensive guidance on how prediction-market profits are taxed. An August 2026 analysis by the Bipartisan Policy Center lists three possible treatments experts are debating — gambling or wagering income, capital gains and losses, or Section 1256 contract gains and losses — and notes taxpayers cannot assume all trades get uniform treatment. The treatments differ sharply: gambling winnings are generally taxed as ordinary income, capital gains can qualify for lower rates, and Section 1256 contracts get a 60/40 long-term/short-term split. Until the IRS rules, keep every trade record and assume your winnings are taxable — and get professional advice if your winnings are material.

Five rules before you put money in

  1. Treat it as gambling with better branding. The products are regulated as derivatives, but the experience — small stakes, instant outcomes, parlays — is built to feel like a sportsbook. If you wouldn't put the money on a sports bet, don't put it on a contract.
  2. Budget it like entertainment, not investing. A fixed monthly amount you can afford to lose entirely. Never money for rent, bills or debt payments, and never borrowed money.
  3. Do the fee maths first. On cheap contracts and frequent trades, fees take a double-digit share of any profit. Resting limit orders are free on most Kalshi markets — use them instead of market orders.
  4. Don't trust a single price. Check the trade count and the spread. A 70% price on a market with a handful of traders is one person's opinion with a dollar sign on it.
  5. Remember the law can move. Courts and state regulators are still fighting over whether these contracts are legal in your state. A ruling can freeze a market or force a platform out of your state with little warning.

Frequently asked questions

Are prediction markets legal in the US?

Kalshi and Polymarket US operate as federally regulated exchanges, and courts have so far shielded them from some state restrictions — but the question is actively being litigated in multiple states, and access varies by state. It is not settled law.

How much money do I need to start?

Kalshi's minimum deposit is $10, and contracts cost as little as 1 cent each. The practical minimum is higher: fees and rounding make very small trades uneconomic, so starting with $25–$50 and a few larger positions beats dozens of 5-cent punts.

Can you actually make money on prediction markets?

Some traders do, mostly by finding mispriced markets or trading the news faster than the crowd. But most retail participants face fees, thin markets dominated by a few large wallets, and the simple maths that every contract pays $1 or $0. Treat any profit as a bonus, not a plan.

Are prediction-market winnings taxed?

Almost certainly yes, but the IRS hasn't said how — gambling income, capital gains, or Section 1256 treatment are all on the table. Keep full records and get professional advice if your winnings are material.

Key takeaways

  • Prediction markets traded a record $123.3 billion in October 2026 — but two-thirds of Kalshi's volume was sub-penny parlays counted at full $1 value, so the trade count (643 million) is the truer growth signal.
  • The midterms were a win for the "markets beat polls" claim on the headline question — Kalshi priced a Democratic House win at 93% — but thin markets move on $3,500 and the top 1% of wallets dominate volume.
  • Fees are small in dollars and large in percentage terms: up to 20% of a 5-cent stake, and 16.7% of the profit on a round-trip trade. Resting orders are free on most Kalshi markets.
  • The legal status is unsettled — Illinois lost its first round in court, Utah is prosecuting, and the CFTC is suing 10 states. Tax treatment is genuinely unresolved: keep records and get advice.

Prediction markets are the most interesting new corner of personal finance in 2026 — a live, tradeable opinion poll with real money behind it. Used carefully, they're a cheap way to test what you actually believe about the world. Used carelessly, they're a slot machine with a Bloomberg terminal's vocabulary. If you try them, start small, do the fee maths, and never stake money you need. Outside the US, access and legality vary by country — check your local rules before signing up.

Sources

Share this article

MoneyHabit Editorial Team

The MoneyHabit editorial desk researches, writes and reviews every article against our editorial policy.

More from MoneyHabit Editorial Team

The Sunday Habit

One useful money idea, every week.

A short, practical email every Sunday — no spam, no selling your address, unsubscribe anytime.

Advertisement

More in Financial Technology