Skip to main content

Explainer

Why Your Student Loan Balance Keeps Growing

1.59 million UK graduates watched their student loan balance grow last year despite repaying every month. Here's why it happens — and when it actually matters.

By MoneyHabit Editorial Team

10 November 2026 · 16 min read

Graduate holding a student loan statement beside a rising chart, with gold coins and a seedling
In this article

Pay your student loan every month, on time, straight out of your pay packet — and watch the balance go up. That is the reality for 1.59 million graduates in England, according to a parliamentary answer published on 13 October 2026. Their Plan 2 student loan balances grew during the 2025/26 financial year even though they made regular repayments. Across all income-contingent plans, the total was 2.09 million borrowers — a record, and up 155% since 2021/22.

The numbers went viral this week after MPs called the system a "scam" on social media, and the anger is easy to understand. A loan that grows while you pay it feels broken. But the mechanics are not a glitch, and whether the rising balance actually costs you anything depends on one question: will you ever repay the loan in full? For roughly two in three Plan 2 graduates, the answer is no.

This guide explains why your balance rises, the exact maths at different salaries, when it matters, when it doesn't, and the one decision — overpaying — where getting it wrong costs real money.

The number behind the anger

The figures come from a written parliamentary question answered by the Department for Education on 13 October 2026. It counts borrowers funded by Student Finance England whose loans had become liable for repayment and who made at least four repayments in the year — yet still ended the year owing more than they started it, because the interest added exceeded what they repaid.

Financial yearPlan 2 borrowers whose balance grew despite repaying
2021/22628,000
2022/23971,000
2023/241,302,000
2024/251,538,000
2025/261,592,000

The count has risen every single year — up two and a half times in four years. Part of that is simply more graduates entering repayment. But the deeper cause is the gap between what graduates repay and what interest adds. In 2024/25, Plan 2 loans accrued £12.6 billion in interest while borrowers repaid just £2.8 billion, according to figures quoted in a Westminster Hall debate in February 2026. Interest added was more than four times the amount repaid.

Students finishing university in 2024 entered repayment with an average debt of £53,000, and around 5.8 million people have taken out Plan 2 loans since 2012. When balances that large meet interest rates of 4.1% to 6%, modest repayments simply cannot keep up.

How a student loan actually works

A UK student loan is not like a bank loan, a mortgage or a credit card. Two rules make it behave differently:

  • Your monthly payment is set by your income, not your balance. On Plan 2 you repay 9% of your earnings above £29,385 a year (about £2,448 a month) in 2026/27. Whether you owe £20,000 or £60,000, the payment is identical if your salary is the same.
  • Interest is charged on the whole balance, every year. On Plan 2 the rate runs from RPI (4.1% for 2026/27) up to RPI plus 3%, depending on income — capped at 6% for the year from 1 September 2026 to 31 August 2027.

When the interest added in a year is bigger than the repayments made in that year, the balance rises. That is the whole story. It is not a penalty, a mistake or a missed payment — it is the system working exactly as designed.

A worked example

Take a graduate earning £35,000 with a £50,000 Plan 2 balance:

  • Repayment: (£35,000 − £29,385) × 9% = £505.35 a year (about £42 a month).
  • Interest rate: 4.1% plus a slice of the extra 3%, on a sliding scale between £29,385 and £52,885 — at £35,000 that works out to about 4.82%.
  • Interest added: 4.82% of £50,000 = £2,408 a year (about £201 a month).
  • Balance change: £2,408 − £505 = £1,903 higher after a full year of repaying.

That graduate paid every month without fail and ended the year nearly £2,000 deeper in debt on paper. Multiply that across 1.59 million people and you get the viral headline.

The maths at your salary

The table below uses a £50,000 Plan 2 balance and the 2026/27 rules. All figures are our own calculations from the published thresholds and rates.

SalaryYearly repayment (9% over £29,385)Interest rateInterest on £50,000Balance after one year
£30,000£554.18%£2,090+£2,035
£35,000£5054.82%£2,408+£1,903
£40,000£9555.46%£2,728+£1,773
£50,000£1,8556.00% (capped)£3,000+£1,145
£60,000£2,7556.00% (capped)£3,000+£245
£70,000£3,6556.00% (capped)£3,000−£655

Two things stand out. First, the balance only starts falling once your salary is roughly £63,000 — and that is with a £50,000 balance. With the average £53,000 starting balance, the break-even salary is higher still. Second, the interest rate itself rises with your income, so earning more pushes both your repayment and your interest rate up at the same time. The system is designed so that only higher earners ever clear the debt.

Why the gap is widening

Four features of the current system push more borrowers into the "balance rising" group each year:

  • The repayment threshold is frozen. The Plan 2 threshold (£29,385) and the income point where the top interest rate kicks in (£52,885) will not change until at least 2030. As pay rises with inflation, more of each salary falls above the threshold — but the threshold itself stays put, so repayments creep up slowly while interest compounds on the full balance.
  • Interest starts on day one. Interest accrues from the day each loan instalment is paid to your university, not from graduation. While you are studying, Plan 2 charges the maximum rate — currently 6%. Three or four years of study at 6% on a growing balance means many graduates start repayment already owing more than they borrowed.
  • Rates track RPI, not the Bank of England base rate. Plan 2 interest is set each September from the March RPI figure (4.1% for 2026/27). The government capped it at 6% for this academic year — without the cap, the formula would have produced 7.1% for the highest earners. The cap applies to this year only.
  • Balances are bigger than they used to be. Higher tuition fees and maintenance loans mean the average debt on leaving university (£53,000 for 2024 finishers) is far larger than the balances of a decade ago, so the same interest rate adds far more pounds each year.

Watch out: the 6% cap is not permanent. It was announced in April 2026 for the 2026/27 academic year only. If RPI stays high and the cap is not renewed, Plan 2 rates for the highest earners could rise towards RPI + 3% again next September. Check the rate each autumn — it is set by the Student Loans Company every September.

All five UK plans at a glance

The "balance growing" problem is mostly a Plan 2 story, but the rules differ by plan. Find yours on your Student Loans Company statement — it is determined by when and where you started your course.

PlanWho it covers2026/27 thresholdInterest (Sep 2026–Aug 2027)Written off after
Plan 1England & Wales, started before 1 Sep 2012£26,9004.1%Age 65, or 25 years after you became liable
Plan 2England Sep 2012–Jul 2023; Wales Sep 2012 onwards£29,3854.1%–6%30 years
Plan 4Scotland£33,7954.1%30 years, or age 65 if earlier
Plan 5England, started on/after 1 Aug 2023£25,0004.1%40 years
PostgraduateMaster's & doctoral loans£21,0006% (capped)30 years

All plans charge 9% of income above the threshold, except the Postgraduate Loan at 6%. If you hold both an undergraduate and a postgraduate loan, you pay both rates — 15% in total on Plan 2 plus postgraduate income above the thresholds. Plan 5 is the cheapest on interest (RPI only) but lasts 40 years and has the lowest threshold, so more graduates repay for longer.

The uncomfortable truth: for most graduates, the balance doesn't matter

Your student loan is not a debt in the normal sense. It is a graduate tax with a 30-year expiry date — and for most people, the balance on the statement is a number they will never actually pay.

The Department for Education's latest forecast expects only around 32% of full-time undergraduates in the final Plan 2 cohort (those who started in 2022/23) to repay their loans in full. For the 2025/26 cohort of new starters, the figure is around 55% — higher, because Plan 5's lower threshold and 40-year term collect more. Either way, a large share of borrowers will have whatever remains written off at the end of their loan term, with no detriment to the borrower — the government's own words in the parliamentary answer.

That changes what the rising balance means:

  • If you will not repay in full — the likely outcome for most Plan 2 borrowers — the interest rate is financially irrelevant to you. A bigger balance at write-off costs you nothing extra, because the unpaid amount is cancelled regardless of its size. Your total cost is fixed by your income over 30 years, not by the balance.
  • Your monthly payment never changes with the balance. A £50,000 balance and a £100,000 balance produce the same £42-a-month payment on a £35,000 salary.
  • It does not affect your credit score. UK student loans do not appear on your credit file, so a rising balance alone cannot hurt your credit rating or a mortgage application in the way a growing credit card balance would. Lenders will see the 9% deduction on your payslips when they assess affordability — that is the real cost, and it is the same whatever the balance says.
  • Repayments stop if your income falls. Drop below the threshold and payments pause automatically through PAYE. Interest keeps accruing, but you pay nothing until you earn above the threshold again.

When the balance DOES matter

The rising balance is a real problem in three situations:

  • You are a high earner who will repay in full. If your salary trajectory takes you well above £60,000 and keeps climbing, you are in the minority who clear the loan. For you, every pound of interest is a pound you will eventually pay — and the total can be tens of thousands more than you borrowed.
  • You are deciding whether to overpay. Voluntary overpayments only save you money if you were going to repay in full anyway. If you would not have cleared the loan, an overpayment just reduces the amount that would have been written off — money you never needed to spend.
  • You move abroad. You must tell the Student Loans Company, and repayments are set by the SLC based on the cost of living where you live, not the UK threshold. Interest still accrues, and the SLC can set a fixed monthly amount. Failing to update your details can lead to arrears and a higher rate.

Should you overpay your student loan?

This is the one decision where the viral anger can cost you real money — in both directions. Use this framework:

Your situationOverpay?Why
Salary under ~£40,000, balance £40,000+, early in your careerNoYou are very unlikely to repay in full before the 30-year write-off. Extra payments reduce the amount that would have been cancelled.
Salary £50,000–£60,000 and rising steadilyProbably not yetBorderline. Model it first: only overpay if the numbers show you clearing the loan years early.
Salary £70,000+, balance under £30,000Worth modellingYou are likely to repay in full. Overpaying now cuts total interest — compare the saving with what the same money earns in a savings account or pension.
Close to clearing the loan (under ~£10,000 left)Often yesClearing it ends the 9% deduction. Just check first that you are not about to be auto-enrolled into something better — and never use your emergency fund to do it.

Before overpaying a single pound, do the maths for your own salary, balance and interest rate — free calculators from the Student Loans Company and independent sites will project your total repayments with and without overpayments. And remember the golden rule: there is no penalty for extra repayments, but you cannot get the money back once paid. Never overpay from money you might need, and never overpay while carrying higher-interest debt like a credit card or overdraft.

Quick check: log in to your Student Loans Company account and look at three numbers — your plan, your current balance, and your interest rate. If your yearly repayments are smaller than the yearly interest, your balance is growing. That alone is not a reason to panic — it is a reason to work out which side of the 32% line you sit on.

Check your statement — the SLC got 71,000 wrong

There is one more reason to look at your statement. In October 2026 the government confirmed that two technical errors in how Plan 2 interest was calculated had affected 71,000 customers: 41,000 were not charged enough interest and 30,000 were charged too much. Accounts have now been corrected — 41,000 balances went up, 30,000 went down — and just over 3,000 customers who had already paid off their loans in full are due refunds.

Monthly payments were not affected, because payments depend on salary, not balance. But if your balance jumped unexpectedly in late 2026, this correction may be why. If anything on your statement looks wrong, contact the Student Loans Company — and keep your own record of what you borrowed and repaid.

The US contrast: a different kind of loan

American graduates face the opposite design. Federal student loans carry fixed interest rates set once a year — 6.52% for undergraduate Direct Loans first disbursed between 1 July 2026 and 30 June 2027 (up from 6.39%), 8.07% for graduate unsubsidised loans, and 9.07% for PLUS loans — and the standard plan repays the loan over ten years with a fixed monthly payment. On that plan, every payment covers that month's interest plus a slice of principal, so the balance falls from the first payment. There is no 30-year write-off on the standard plan, and no income link unless the borrower actively chooses an income-driven plan.

The trade-off is brutal in the other direction: payments do not fall if your income does, and default carries consequences the UK system does not have — damaged credit, wage garnishment and seized tax refunds. The UK system's rising balances look absurd on a statement, but its income link and write-off are a safety net the US system does not offer by default.

What to do this week

  1. Find your plan. Check your Student Loans Company statement or GOV.UK — Plan 2 is the one most affected, but Plan 5 and postgraduate loans have different thresholds and write-off periods.
  2. Compare your repayment with your interest. Multiply your balance by your interest rate. If the interest is bigger than your yearly repayment, your balance is growing — normal for Plan 2, and usually harmless.
  3. Estimate whether you will repay in full. If your salary is under £45,000 and your balance is over £40,000, the odds are strongly against it. Free repayment calculators can give you a personalised projection in minutes.
  4. Do not overpay on autopilot. Only overpay if the projection shows you clearing the loan — and only with money you do not need for higher-interest debt, an emergency fund, or pension contributions.
  5. Check your statement for the SLC correction. If your balance moved oddly in late 2026, the 71,000-account interest correction may be the cause.
  6. If you move abroad, tell the SLC. Repayment amounts change, and silence can lead to arrears.

Frequently asked questions

Why does my student loan balance go up when I pay every month?

Because your repayment is 9% of your income above £29,385, while interest of 4.1% to 6% is charged on your whole balance. On a typical graduate salary, the yearly interest is larger than the yearly repayment, so the balance grows even though you never miss a payment.

Will a growing student loan balance hurt my credit score?

No. UK student loans do not appear on your credit file, so the balance itself cannot affect your credit score. What lenders see is the 9% deduction from your take-home pay when they assess affordability.

Should I overpay to stop my balance growing?

Usually not. Overpaying only saves money if you would have repaid the loan in full before the 30-year write-off — the Department for Education expects only about 32% of the final Plan 2 cohort to do so.

What is the Plan 2 interest rate in 2026/27?

Between 4.1% and 6%, depending on income: 4.1% (RPI) at £29,385 or below, rising on a sliding scale to 6% at £52,885 and above. The 6% cap was announced in April 2026 and applies for the year from 1 September 2026 to 31 August 2027. Rates reset every September.

What happens to my student loan after 30 years?

Any outstanding balance — including all accrued interest — is written off, with no detriment to the borrower. For Plan 2 that is 30 years after the April you were first due to repay. Plan 5 loans are written off after 40 years instead.

Does the 6% interest cap last?

Only for this academic year, as announced. Without it, the formula would have produced up to 7.1% (RPI + 3%) for the highest earners. Whether the cap is renewed for 2027/28 will be announced before next September.

Key takeaways

  • 1.59 million Plan 2 graduates saw their loan balance grow in 2025/26 despite making regular repayments — up from 628,000 four years earlier.
  • It happens because repayments are 9% of income above £29,385, while interest of 4.1%–6% is charged on the whole balance. On a £35,000 salary with a £50,000 balance, interest adds £2,408 a year while repayments total just £505.
  • For most Plan 2 borrowers the rising balance is financially meaningless: only about 32% of the final cohort are expected to repay in full, and the rest is written off after 30 years.
  • Overpaying only saves money if you would repay in full anyway. Otherwise it reduces the amount that would have been cancelled.
  • Check your statement: an SLC interest error affected 71,000 accounts in 2026, and the 6% cap applies for this academic year only.

The viral fury is understandable — a loan that grows while you pay it offends every instinct about debt. But the UK student loan was never designed to behave like a debt. It is an income-linked contribution with an expiry date, and for most graduates the balance on the statement is a ghost: it grows, it looms, and then, after 30 years, it disappears. The number worth watching is not your balance. It is your salary, your plan, and whether you sit on the side of the line where overpaying actually pays.

Sources

Share this article

MoneyHabit Editorial Team

The MoneyHabit editorial desk researches, writes and reviews every article against our editorial policy.

More from MoneyHabit Editorial Team

The Sunday Habit

One useful money idea, every week.

A short, practical email every Sunday — no spam, no selling your address, unsubscribe anytime.

Advertisement

More in Debt & Credit Education