Explainer
Is Buying a House a Bad Investment? The Maths
A viral reel says buying a house is a bad investment next to the S&P 500. The numbers partly agree — but the full maths is more complicated.

In this article
- The claim, graded: what the long-run numbers actually say
- The three things the raw comparison leaves out
- The costs the reel doesn't mention
- Rent and invest the difference: the honest test
- When buying wins — and when it doesn't
- The UK version: same debate, different numbers
- Frequently asked questions
- Key takeaways
A viral Instagram reel is telling millions of people that buying a house is a bad investment. The clip, from money creator @calltoleap (2.8 million followers) on 14 November, stitches a debate over the "dumbest investment people make" — and the guest's answer is blunt: a house, because the same money in the S&P 500 would historically have grown far faster. The comments split instantly: half agree, half point out the obvious — "you can't live in an S&P 500."
Both sides have a point, and the argument is landing at a live moment: US mortgage rates have just fallen for a fourth straight week to 7.11%, and the median existing-home price is $416,700. Buyers who sat out the 7.4% era are asking whether to jump back in. So let's grade the claim properly.
The claim, graded: what the long-run numbers actually say
On raw price growth alone, the reel's guest is right — and it isn't close. The S&P 500 has compounded at about 10.02% a year with dividends reinvested from 1928 through 2025, according to the historical dataset maintained by Professor Aswath Damodaran at NYU's Stern School of Business. After inflation, that is about 6.8% a year. US home prices, measured by the S&P CoreLogic Case-Shiller index, have risen about 4.3% a year in nominal terms since 1987 — and after inflation, about 1.4% a year over the long run. Robert Shiller's own analysis of 1890 to 1990 found inflation-adjusted home-price appreciation of approximately zero: over a century, American houses roughly kept pace with inflation and little more.
What that gap looks like in dollars — $10,000 left alone for 30 years at those long-run averages (our own calculation):
| Where the $10,000 goes | Assumed return | Value after 30 years |
|---|---|---|
| S&P 500, nominal | 10.02% a year | ~$175,000 |
| S&P 500, after inflation | 6.8% a year | ~$72,000 in today's money |
| House prices, nominal | 4.3% a year | ~$35,000 |
| House prices, after inflation | 1.4% a year | ~$15,200 in today's money |
The raw numbers are not wrong. A house has never been a great way to grow money — it has been a great way to live somewhere while your money grows slowly.
Two honest caveats. First, the S&P 500's 10% is an average almost nobody experiences as a smooth ride: the index fell in 26 of those 98 years, and only four years landed between 8% and 12%. Second, the last decade ran far above the average — about 14.7% a year from 2016 to 2025 — which argues for caution, not extrapolation.
The three things the raw comparison leaves out
Comparing house-price growth to stock returns is like comparing a salary to a lottery ticket: it ignores what each one actually pays you along the way. Three factors change the maths completely.
1. Leverage. With a 20% deposit on the median $416,700 home, you put down $83,340 and control a $416,700 asset. If prices rise 4.3%, that is about $17,900 of growth in year one on $83,340 of your own money — a 21% return on cash before costs. Leverage is the reason property can build wealth despite miserable price growth, and the reason it can destroy wealth fast when prices fall.
2. Imputed rent — the dividend your house pays you. A stock pays dividends; a house pays you by letting you live in it. Every month you own, you don't pay rent. Global research summarised by the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco found residential property returned around 7% a year in real terms over 145 years once rental income is included — comparable to equities. The catch: the US-only, price-only figure is far lower, and your "dividend" is consumed as housing, not banked. Still, any honest comparison has to count the rent you didn't pay.
3. Forced savings. This is the concession the reel itself makes: for the average person, a house's illiquidity is a feature. You can't panic-sell your kitchen during a market dip, and you can't quietly raid your home equity the way people raid accessible investment accounts. The renter who invests the difference beats the owner — but only if they actually invest the difference, every month, for decades. Most people don't.
The bottom line on the claim: as a pure investment, the guest is right — houses grow slowly. As a place to live that also builds equity, the comparison is rigged, because it counts the stock market's dividends and ignores the house's.
The costs the reel doesn't mention
If the return side of housing is overstated by the raw comparison, the cost side is understated by everyone. A house is the only "investment" that sends you a bill every month whether it goes up or not.
Mortgage interest is the big one. Borrow $333,360 — 80% of the median $416,700 home — at the current 7.11% 30-year fixed rate, and the principal-and-interest payment is about $2,242 a month (our own calculation). Over 30 years you will pay roughly $474,000 in interest alone — more than the loan itself. That interest is the price of leverage.
Then the running costs. Budget roughly 1% of the home's value a year for maintenance and repairs — about $4,200 a year on a median home, and lumpy: roofs and boilers don't fail on schedule. Property tax runs around 1% of value a year in the US, and home insurance is on top. All in, owning the median home costs closer to $3,100 a month than the $2,242 mortgage payment — before a single dollar of price growth.
And the exit costs. Buying and selling typically costs 8% to 10% of a home's value round-trip: agent commission, closing costs, moving, repairs to sell. Sell after three years and those costs can wipe out years of appreciation — which is why the standard advice is not to buy unless you'll stay five to seven years. It isn't snobbery, it's arithmetic.
The trap: buying at the top of your budget because "house prices always go up." At 7.11%, the payment on a median home is already about $2,242 a month. Stretch to a bigger house and the interest bill, not the appreciation, decides whether you build wealth.
Rent and invest the difference: the honest test
Here is the test the reel is really proposing. Suppose you rent a comparable place for $1,800 a month instead of owning at roughly $3,100 a month all-in. That frees about $1,300 a month. Invest every dollar of it at a 7% real return for 30 years and it grows to roughly $1.59 million in today's money (our own calculation, on generous assumptions: flat rent, no tax or fees, and not a single missed month).
Meanwhile the owner ends the same 30 years with a house worth about $640,000 in today's money (the $416,700 home appreciating at 1.4% real a year), mortgage-free.
Now the reality check. That $1.27 million assumes three things that almost never all hold: you invest the full difference every single month for 30 years; rent never rises; and you never raid the pot. Rent does rise, and the owner's mortgage payment is fixed. And most renters spend the difference, not invest it. The owner who "loses" on paper still ends up with a paid-off roof; the renter who spends the difference ends up with neither the portfolio nor the house.
When buying wins — and when it doesn't
| Your situation | Buying usually wins | Renting + investing usually wins |
|---|---|---|
| Time horizon | Staying 7+ years in one place | Moving within 5 years, or unsure where you'll live |
| Monthly comparison | Owning costs about the same as renting | Rent is far cheaper than owning in your city |
| Discipline | You want forced savings and stability | You reliably invest the difference every month |
| Rates and prices | Rates falling, prices flat in your area | Buying at peak prices with high rates and low yields |
| Life stage | Settled, kids in school, need the space | Career mobile, income uncertain, flexibility matters |
The single most useful question isn't "house or stocks?" — it's "what does owning cost me per month versus renting the same place?" If owning costs roughly the same as rent, buy: you get the leverage, the stability and the forced savings for free. If owning costs far more than renting, only rent if you'll truly invest the gap.
The UK version: same debate, different numbers
UK buyers face the same argument with different figures. The average UK home cost £273,000 in August 2026 (ONS), the average two-year fixed mortgage rate is close to 5.97%, and the Bank of England base rate is 4.00%. First-time buyers in England and Northern Ireland pay no stamp duty on the first £300,000 and 5% on the slice from £300,001 to £500,000 — on the average first-time buyer home of £228,000, that is £0 in stamp duty. The UK adds its own twist: with a 25-year mortgage term the norm rather than 30, monthly payments are higher and equity builds faster, and leasehold flats carry service charges and ground rent. The verdict is the same, though: UK house prices have historically grown faster in real terms than US ones, but still well below equity returns.
Frequently asked questions
Is a house a good investment or not?
As a pure investment, no — long-run real house-price growth is about 1.4% a year, against about 7% for stocks. As a home that also builds equity through leverage, rent saved and forced saving, it can be a good financial decision. The two statements describe different things.
Should I rent and invest in the S&P 500 instead of buying?
Only if you will genuinely invest the difference every month for decades. The maths works; the behaviour usually doesn't. If the money would be spent instead, owning's forced savings will likely leave you wealthier.
Does the 7.11% mortgage rate change the answer?
It changes the monthly cost, not the principle. Rates have fallen four weeks in a row from a 7.40% peak in early October, and the typical payment on a median home is about $2,242 a month. A lower rate makes owning cheaper relative to renting — run your own local numbers rather than deciding on the national rate.
What about buying a house as a rental investment?
That is a different asset: a rental combines price growth with rental income, and total returns before leverage can reach 8–9% a year. It also brings tenants, voids, repairs and tax. Don't confuse the returns on a well-run rental with the returns on the home you live in.
Key takeaways
- On price growth alone, stocks win decisively: the S&P 500 returned about 10% a year nominally (6.8% after inflation) since 1928; US house prices about 4.3% nominally (1.4% after inflation).
- Leverage changes the maths: a 20% deposit means 4.3% price growth is about 21% on your cash in year one — before interest and costs.
- A house pays you in rent you don't pay. Ignore that "dividend" and the comparison is rigged against owning.
- At 7.11%, a median-home mortgage costs about $474,000 in interest over 30 years — the price of leverage.
- Renting and investing the difference wins on paper (~$1.59m vs a ~$640k house over 30 years in our illustration) — but only with 30 years of perfect discipline most people don't have.
- Decide on your monthly numbers, not the national debate: if owning costs about the same as renting where you live, buy; if it costs far more, only rent if you'll truly invest the gap.
The reel is right about the numbers and wrong about the conclusion. A house is a poor investment and a good home — and the difference between those two sentences is where most people's wealth is actually made or lost. If you're deciding now, with rates falling and the median home at $416,700, compare the all-in monthly cost of owning with the rent on the same place, be honest about whether you'd invest the difference, and buy the house for the life it gives you — not for the return it won't.
Sources
- QuantFlowLab — S&P 500 Average Return (Damodaran/NYU Stern data)
- Motley Fool — What Is the Average Stock Market Return?
- Real Cost Report — Real Estate vs. Stock Market Long-Term Returns
- PortfolioPilot — Real Estate Returns: How Homeownership Stacks Up
- CYO Finance — Real Estate vs Stock Market: 0.8% or 6% Real Return?
- Calculatorian — Rental Property vs Index Funds: 30-Year Comparison
- Real Estate News — Existing home sales haven’t been this slow since 2010 (NAR, 12 Nov 2026)
- FLIQ — First-Time Buyer Guide UK 2026
- Instagram — @calltoleap reel: house vs S&P 500 debate (14 Nov 2026)
The MoneyHabit editorial desk researches, writes and reviews every article against our editorial policy.
The Sunday Habit
One useful money idea, every week.
A short, practical email every Sunday — no spam, no selling your address, unsubscribe anytime.
Advertisement
More in Financial Literacy

Financial Literacy · Explainer
Is Social Security a Scam? The Maths Behind the Claim
A viral post says investing your $7,500 a year beats Social Security’s $3,000 a month. We recomputed the maths — and the real numbers tell a different story.
13 November 2026 · 9 min read

Financial Literacy · Guide
What Is a REIT? Property Investing Without a House
A REIT lets you own a slice of offices, warehouses and flats without a deposit or tenants. Here is how the 90% payout rule works - and the risks.
12 November 2026 · 14 min read

Financial Literacy · Guide
Retire at 40 on $2 Million: The FIRE Maths, Checked
A viral post says $2 million buys retirement at 40 on $80,000 a year. The maths is real — but the 4% rule, taxes and healthcare change the answer.
11 November 2026 · 16 min read