Explainer
She Turned Down $1M for $1,000 a Week: Was She Right?
A 20-year-old turned down $1 million for $1,000 a week for life — and the internet erupted. We ran the numbers on who was right.

In this article
A 20-year-old from Montreal won a million dollars — and turned it down. Brenda Aubin-Vega scratched a Gagnant à vie ticket on her lunch break in July 2025 and faced a choice most of us will only ever daydream about: take $1,000,000 in one go, or collect $1,000 every week for the rest of her life. She chose the weekly cheque. More than a year later, her decision is going viral all over again — a Facebook post about it drew 14,000 likes and 2,800 comments in a day, and Binance founder Changpeng Zhao said she "threw away generational wealth."
So was she wrong? On pure spreadsheet maths, the lump sum usually wins — but only if you actually invest it and leave it alone for decades. The research on real lottery winners says that "if" does a lot of heavy lifting.
The choice she faced
According to Loto-Québec's press release of 3 July 2025, Aubin-Vega discovered she had won the Gagnant à vie top prize during her break at work, after scratching three piggy-bank symbols on a $4 ticket. "I couldn't believe my eyes! I checked my ticket over and over again," she told lottery officials.
The game offered two ways to collect the same top prize: $1,000,000 as a single lump sum, or $1,000 a week for life. She chose the annuity, and said she plans to buy a house with it. In Canada, lottery winnings are tax-free, so she would have kept the entire $1,000,000. The comparison was clean: $1 million now, or $52,000 a year, every year, for life.
The maths: what $1,000 a week is actually worth
How long until the weekly payments add up to a million dollars? Just over 19 years — she passes $1 million at about age 39. By 50 she will have collected $1.56 million, by 65 about $2.34 million, and if she lives to the Canadian female average of about 84, roughly $3.3 million in total.
But totals are not the whole story, because a dollar today is worth more than a dollar in 2055. Financial planners compare payment streams using present value: what a future stream is worth in today's money, discounted at the return you could earn elsewhere. Here is the present value of $52,000 a year, forever (our own arithmetic):
| Discount rate | What it represents | Present value of the annuity |
|---|---|---|
| 3.4% | Canada's 10-year government bond yield | about $1,529,000 |
| 5% | A cautious balanced portfolio | about $1,040,000 |
| 7% | A long-run stock-market return | about $743,000 |
That table contains the whole debate. Compared with a safe government bond, her annuity is worth more than $1 million — she locked in a 5.2% annual yield backed by the province of Quebec, higher than the roughly 3.4% a 10-year Canadian government bond pays. Compared with the stock market at 7%, the lump sum is worth about $300,000 more. The "correct" answer depends on what return you assume — and whether you would actually earn it.
The key insight: the annuity pays a guaranteed 5.2% a year for life. The lump sum only beats it if you invest the full $1 million, earn more than 5.2% a year after tax and fees, and never touch the principal for decades. That is a test most real people fail — including, as we will see, most lottery winners.
The case for the lump sum
The critics have a strong argument, and it starts with compounding. If Aubin-Vega had taken the $1 million, invested it all, and left it untouched, at 7% a year it would grow to about $3.9 million by age 40 and roughly $15 million by age 60 (our own arithmetic, before tax and fees). At 5% it would reach about $7 million by 60. Even the weekly payments, if she invested every one at 7%, would only reach about $10.4 million by 60. With perfect discipline, the lump sum wins by millions.
Binance founder Changpeng Zhao said Brenda "threw away generational wealth" — arguing $1 million invested at 7% could exceed $15 million by retirement age.
There are two more arguments for taking the cash. First, inflation. Her $1,000 a week never rises. At 2% annual inflation, its buying power halves in about 35 years — by the time she is 56, that weekly cheque will buy roughly what $490 buys today. Second, control. A lump sum can be passed to heirs or used to start a business. A weekly cheque cannot be borrowed against or accelerated; if she ever needed $200,000 at once, the annuity could not provide it.
The case for the weekly cheque
Now the other side — stronger than the internet's mockery allows. Every argument for the lump sum contains the same hidden word: if. If she invests it all. If she earns 7%. If she never touches it. If she does not panic in a crash, lend it to relatives, or buy a depreciating fleet of cars.
The research on windfall winners is sobering. The most quoted statistic — that 70% of lottery winners go broke — is not real: the National Endowment for Financial Education said in 2018 that it "is not backed by research from NEFE, nor can it be confirmed by the organization." The genuine research is not much more comforting. A 2011 study by Scott Hankins, Mark Hoekstra and Paige Marta Skiba, published in the Review of Economics and Statistics, matched nearly 35,000 Florida lottery winners to bankruptcy records. Winners of $50,000 to $150,000 were 50% less likely to file for bankruptcy in the two years after winning — but equally more likely to file three to five years later.
That is the real risk the lump sum carries. A $1 million cheque at 20, with no financial experience, no adviser, and every relative and friend suddenly in need, is a test of discipline most people would struggle to pass. The annuity removes the test entirely: it cannot be blown in a year or lent away, and it pays $52,000 a year — roughly the median individual income in Canada — guaranteed for life by a provincial government. Aubin-Vega said she wanted stability, and she plans to buy a house. She chose security over maximising wealth, knowingly, at a price she could see.
Don't copy the headline, copy the thinking: Brenda's choice worked partly because her winnings were tax-free and the annuity was guaranteed for life by a government. In the United States, taxes and a 30-year payment cap change the maths completely.
The same choice in the US and the UK looks very different
If you play Powerball or Mega Millions in the United States, the decision is not the clean one Aubin-Vega faced. The advertised jackpot is the annuity total: 30 graduated payments over 29 years, each 5% larger than the last. The cash value is the money actually sitting in the prize pool, recently around 42% to 49% of the headline figure — so a $1 billion jackpot might offer roughly $450 million in cash.
Then tax arrives. Winnings are ordinary income: the lottery withholds 24% immediately, but the top federal rate for 2026 is 37%, so a big winner owes roughly another 13 cents on every dollar at tax time, before state taxes. That is why more than 93% of Powerball winners chose the lump sum in a 2011 study of winners from 2003 to 2009: with the annuity capped at 30 years and every payment taxed, taking the cash is usually the better financial move — again, if you actually invest it.
In the UK, the position is simpler and closer to Canada's: National Lottery winnings are tax-free and paid as a lump sum, with no annuity option. The debate there is what to do with a sudden lump sum — exactly the discipline problem the research warns about.
How to decide if it were you
There is no single right answer, but there is a right way to think about it. Work through these questions first:
- What return would you realistically earn? If you would park the money in a savings account at 3–4%, the annuity's guaranteed 5.2% wins. Only a disciplined portfolio earning 6–7% over decades beats it.
- Would you actually leave it alone? If you know you would spend it or lend it, the annuity's forced discipline is worth more than the extra return on paper.
- How long will you live? The annuity is a bet on longevity. A 20-year-old collecting for 60+ years comes out far ahead; a 70-year-old winner would not.
- Do you need a lump sum for something specific? A house deposit, a business, clearing expensive debt — legitimate reasons to take the cash.
- What does the taxman take? In Canada and the UK, winnings are tax-free. In the US, the lump sum is taxed in one year at the top rate.
- What happens when you die? Some annuities stop at death; others pass remaining payments to heirs. Check the terms.
Whatever you choose, get professional advice before claiming a prize — a tax adviser and a fee-only financial planner, paid by the hour, before you tell anyone beyond your closest family. The biggest cost of a windfall is rarely tax. It is haste.
Frequently asked questions
Was Brenda Aubin-Vega wrong to take $1,000 a week instead of $1 million?
On pure investment maths, the lump sum would likely have been worth more — about $15 million by age 60 at 7%, versus roughly $10.4 million if she invested every weekly payment. But that assumes perfect discipline for 40 years. The annuity guarantees her $52,000 a year for life at 5.2%, tax-free. For someone who values security over maximising wealth, it was defensible, not foolish.
How much will she collect in total?
If she lives to the Canadian female average of about 84, she will collect roughly $3.3 million over 64 years. But at 2% inflation, a $1,000 weekly payment will buy about half as much by the time she is 56.
Do most lottery winners really go broke?
The famous "70% of winners go broke" figure has no research behind it — the organisation it is credited to has publicly disowned it. A 2011 study of Florida winners found medium-sized wins delayed bankruptcy rather than preventing it, and a Swedish study found large-prize winners stayed more satisfied with their lives for over a decade. A windfall amplifies your existing habits; it does not fix them.
Should I take the lump sum or the annuity on a US lottery win?
Most American winners take the lump sum — over 93% in one study — because the annuity only lasts 30 years, payments are taxed as they arrive, and the cash value can be invested. But the lump sum only wins if you invest it and leave it alone.
Key takeaways
- Brenda Aubin-Vega, 20, chose $1,000 a week for life over a $1,000,000 lump sum — and the internet has been arguing about it ever since.
- Her annuity pays $52,000 a year, a guaranteed 5.2% yield — better than a government bond, worse than a long-run stock-market return.
- At 7% a year, the lump sum would grow to about $15 million by age 60; invested weekly payments would reach about $10.4 million. The lump sum wins on paper — if untouched for 40 years.
- Inflation is the annuity's quiet enemy: at 2% a year, $1,000 a week buys about half as much by the time she is 56.
- Real research says windfalls postpone financial trouble rather than cure it — the "70% go broke" stat is a myth, but the discipline problem behind it is real.
- The right choice depends on your realistic return, your discipline, your age, and your country's tax rules.
Brenda Aubin-Vega did not make the choice that maximises her wealth. She made the choice that maximises her sleep. The best payout option is the one you will actually stick to: if that is a lump sum you invest and ignore for decades, take the cash. If it is a cheque that arrives whether or not you have the discipline to save, take the annuity — and invest what you do not spend, so the weekly payments build wealth instead of just covering bills.
Sources
- Loto-Québec press release — Brenda Aubin-Vega wins $1,000 a week for life
- Moneywise — 20-year-old lotto winner refused $1M, chose $1K/week for life
- Webull — Binance founder says lottery winner threw away generational wealth
- World Manual — 20-year-old lottery winner rejects $1,000,000 lump sum
- ScratchCheck — Do most lottery winners go broke? The 70 percent myth
- The Money Pocket — Powerball payout after taxes, cash vs annuity
- UN World Population Prospects — Canada female life expectancy 2023
- Facebook — 20-year-old lottery winner rejects $1 million for $1,000 weekly payments
The MoneyHabit editorial desk researches, writes and reviews every article against our editorial policy.
The Sunday Habit
One useful money idea, every week.
A short, practical email every Sunday — no spam, no selling your address, unsubscribe anytime.
Advertisement
More in Financial Literacy

Financial Literacy · Explainer
How Long Will $300,000 Last in Retirement?
A viral reel says $300,000 can fund retirement at 4.7% a year. We ran the numbers — dividends, Social Security, bad markets — to see how long it really lasts.
19 November 2026 · 10 min read

Financial Literacy · Guide
Earns ₹85,000, Invests ₹35,000 — and Had ₹3,200 Left
He put 41% of his ₹85,000 salary into SIPs — then a cracked laptop and an insurance bill left him borrowing ₹10,000 from a colleague.
6 November 2026 · 9 min read

Financial Literacy · Explainer
Cash ISA U-Turn Explained: Your £20,000 Allowance Stays
The planned cash ISA cut is scrapped: your £20,000 allowance stays. Here is what changes on savings tax, what the new starter ISA means, and what to do next.
29 October 2026 · 7 min read