Guide
Wrong Money in Your Account? Why You Can’t Keep It
A lawyer just returned ₹34 crore sent to him by mistake. Here’s what the law says in the US, UK and India — and what to do if it happens to you.

In this article
- The short answer: no, it is not yours
- What happened in India: ₹34 crore, returned in two days
- Two people who kept the money — and what it cost them
- 1. The $1.2 million that was meant to be $82.56
- 2. The $120,000 spending spree
- The one famous exception: Citibank's $900 million mistake
- What the law says where you live
- What to do if wrong money lands in your account
- What to do if you sent money to the wrong account
- Frequently asked questions
- Key takeaways
On 7 November 2026, senior advocate Ajay Bagaria of Indore checked his bank account and found ₹34.32 crore sitting in it — roughly $3.9 million — sent by the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) through NEFT. The money was meant for a Hyderabad-based contractor working on a highway project in Harda, Madhya Pradesh. It had landed in the wrong account. Two days later, Bagaria sent every rupee back. He did the right thing, and he did it fast — not everyone does. Every year, bank errors and mistyped account numbers put someone else's money into ordinary people's accounts, and every year some of those people decide to keep it. That decision has cost people their jobs, their freedom and, in one case, more than $100,000 in overdraft fees on money they never owned.
The short answer: no, it is not yours
There is a persistent folk belief — call it the Monopoly defence — that a bank error in your favour is free money. It is not. In almost every legal system in the world, money paid into your account by mistake still belongs to the person who sent it. You are holding it, not owning it. The legal term is unjust enrichment: you have been enriched at someone else's expense, without any legal basis, and the law gives the sender a claim to get it back.
That is the civil side. The criminal side is sharper. If you know the money is not yours and you spend it anyway, most countries treat that as theft or fraud. The amount does not matter — it can be ₹34 crore or $120 — and neither does the fact that the mistake was the bank's. A small payment that could plausibly be a refund is one thing; a seven-figure sum from a stranger is another, and courts are not sympathetic to the argument that you assumed a $1.2 million deposit was a surprise bonus.
What happened in India: ₹34 crore, returned in two days
According to News18, ₹34,32,94,346 was transferred to Bagaria's account on 7 November 2026 through NEFT. The payment was intended for a Hyderabad-based firm working on the Harda highway project, but reached an unrelated account instead, reportedly because of an error in how the beneficiary's bank details were entered and verified — despite a procedure that reportedly passes the file through six to seven levels of officers. The department reportedly took nearly 48 hours to realise the mistake.
Bagaria did not wait to be found. After a bank alert and a call about the unusually large transaction, he checked the details, worked out the money was not his, and contacted Manish Meena, the NHAI project manager in Harda, himself. On 9 November, two days after receiving it, he transferred the entire ₹34.32 crore back. One detail worth noting: Bagaria is empanelled as a senior advocate representing NHAI itself before the High Court — he was, in effect, returning his own client's money. But the legal position would have been the same for anyone: under Indian law, spending money mistakenly credited to your account can be treated as criminal breach of trust under Section 406 of the Indian Penal Code, punishable by up to three years in prison, a fine, or both.
The golden rule: if money appears in your account that you cannot explain, do not spend it, do not move it to another account, and do not invest it. Call your bank the same day and tell them. Everything that follows — the investigation, the reversal, the paperwork — is the bank's problem to solve. The moment you spend it, it becomes yours.
Two people who kept the money — and what it cost them
Bagaria's story ended well because he returned the money. These two did not, and the contrast is the whole lesson.
1. The $1.2 million that was meant to be $82.56
In February 2021, Charles Schwab meant to transfer $82.56 into the Fidelity brokerage account of Kelyn Spadoni, a 33-year-old 911 dispatcher from Harvey, Louisiana. A software error meant the transfer was $1,205,619 instead. When Schwab realised the mistake and tried to take the money back, it was gone — and Spadoni was not answering her phone. According to the Jefferson Parish Sheriff's Office, she moved a quarter of the money to another account, then bought a house and a 2021 Hyundai Genesis SUV. She was arrested on 7 April 2021, charged with bank fraud, illegal transmission of monetary funds and theft of more than $25,000, and fired from her job the same day. Schwab sued her in federal court, and about 75% of the money was eventually recovered.
2. The $120,000 spending spree
In May 2019, a BB&T Bank teller in Georgia entered the wrong account number while processing a customer's $120,000 deposit. The money landed in the joint account of Robert and Tiffany Williams of Montoursville, Pennsylvania, whose balance before the error was $1,121. Instead of calling the bank, the couple spent about $107,000 of it in roughly two and a half weeks — on an SUV, a camper, a race car, two four-wheelers and a car trailer. When the bank discovered the error, it credited the correct account and debited the Williamses' account, leaving them with a $107,416 overdraft. Both were charged with felony theft and receiving stolen property, and each posted $25,000 bail. Both later admitted to investigators that they had known the money did not belong to them.
“If a sum is put into your account, it doesn't mean it is actually yours.” — British Bankers' Association
The one famous exception: Citibank's $900 million mistake
There is exactly one case that people cite to argue that keeping mistaken money can work out — and it is the exception that proves the rule. On 11 August 2020, Citibank, acting as the administrative agent for a syndicated loan to the cosmetics company Revlon, intended to wire about $7.8 million in interest payments to Revlon's lenders. Instead, it accidentally paid off the entire loan — almost $900 million of its own money. Some lenders returned the money; ten asset managers refused, and Citibank sued.
On 16 February 2021, US District Judge Jesse M. Furman ruled that the lenders could keep the roughly $500 million they had held on to, under a New York doctrine called "discharge for value": when a beneficiary receives money that discharges a debt genuinely owed to them, and they had no notice the payment was a mistake, they can treat the transfer as final. The lenders reasonably believed the payment was an intentional early repayment — and, as Judge Furman wrote, to believe Citibank had made a mistake "to the tune of nearly $1 billion would have been borderline irrational". Notice what made the difference: the recipients were owed the money. You, receiving a random credit from a stranger, are owed nothing — so the defence does not help you. Citibank also appealed, and the funds stayed frozen. Even the winners could not spend their windfall.
What the law says where you live
| Country | Can you keep it? | What can happen if you spend it | How recovery works |
|---|---|---|---|
| United States | No | Theft, bank fraud and wire-fraud charges; civil lawsuit for the full sum | The bank or sender sues for restitution and unjust enrichment; the bank can reverse the credit while the funds are still there |
| United Kingdom | No | Retaining a wrongful credit, Theft Act 1968 s.24A — up to 10 years in prison | Banks follow the Best Practice Code on Misdirected Payments: recovery must start within 2 working days, outcome within 20 working days; small-claims court up to £10,000 in England and Wales |
| India | No | Criminal breach of trust, IPC Section 406 — up to 3 years in prison, a fine, or both | The bank must act within 48 hours of a complaint, per Reserve Bank of India rules; recovery through the courts, including attachment of property |
| Nigeria | No | The Central Bank of Nigeria warned in October 2026 that keeping mistakenly deposited funds is a financial offence carrying 5–10 years' imprisonment | Receiving banks must reverse the funds within 1 business day if the money is still in the account; spent funds lead to watch-listing and referral to law enforcement |
The pattern is the same everywhere: the money is not yours, the bank or sender can demand it back, and spending it turns a civil problem into a criminal one.
What to do if wrong money lands in your account
- Do nothing with it. Do not spend it, transfer it or invest it. Do not even move it into a savings account "to keep it safe" — moving it can look like concealment.
- Call your bank the same day. Report the unexplained credit and ask them to investigate. Get a reference number and the name of the person you spoke to.
- Leave the money alone until the bank confirms the reversal. Check your account every few days until the deposit has been reversed. If the bank is slow, follow up in writing so there is a paper trail.
- Do not contact the sender directly. A stranger asking you to return money is a classic scam setup. Let the banks handle the return. Keep records — screenshots, the reference number, copies of emails — so you can prove you reported it immediately.
- Watch for the follow-up scam. Fraudsters sometimes send a small "mistaken" payment, then ask you to send it back to a different account. A genuine mistaken payment is always returned through the bank.
Do not assume a small amount is safe to keep. A payment of $50 or £20 could be a genuine refund — but if you cannot identify what it is for, report it anyway. The reporting costs you a phone call. Keeping money you know is not yours, even a small sum, is the same offence in principle, and banks log unexplained credits.
What to do if you sent money to the wrong account
The other side of the same mistake is more common: you typed one wrong digit and your rent money went to a stranger. Here you are the victim — and the system is built to help you, if you act fast. In all three countries, speed is everything: once the money is spent, recovery becomes a legal process instead of a phone call.
| Country | First step | Deadline | If the recipient refuses |
|---|---|---|---|
| UK | Report it; your bank contacts the receiving bank, which is asked to freeze the funds | Recovery must start within 2 working days; outcome within 20 working days | Sue in the small claims court for unjust enrichment; mentioning Theft Act 1968 s.24A in your letter tends to focus minds. Your bank cannot pull money from another bank's customer's account without consent. |
| US | Ask for a wire recall or an ACH reversal | ACH reversals typically within 5 business days; wire recalls only work while the funds are still there | Civil claim; a police report for theft if they refuse after being told of the error |
| India | Report it to your bank | Bank must act within 48 hours of the complaint; same-bank errors return quickly, other banks 7–15 days | Bank can file a police complaint; sender can pursue a case under IPC Section 406 |
Frequently asked questions
Can the bank take the money back without my permission?
Yes, in most cases. If your own bank made the error, it can correct its own mistake and reverse the credit — your deposit agreement almost certainly allows this. If the money came from another bank, your bank will usually freeze the funds and ask for your consent to return them, but refusing consent does not make the money yours.
Does the "finders keepers" rule ever apply to bank errors?
Essentially never for ordinary account holders. The one real exception is the Citibank–Revlon case, where the recipients were creditors who were genuinely owed the money the bank sent them. If nobody owes you the money, there is no version of the law that lets you keep it.
What if someone sends me money "by mistake" and then asks me to send it back to a different account?
Do not do it. That is a known scam: the original payment is often made from a stolen account or a fraudulent cheque, and it will be reversed — leaving you out of pocket for the "refund" you sent. Tell your bank, and let the bank return the money through its own channels.
Key takeaways
- Money paid into your account by mistake is not yours — in the US, UK, India and Nigeria alike, you must return it.
- Spending it can mean theft or fraud charges: the Schwab case cost a woman her job and her freedom over $1.2 million; a Pennsylvania couple ended up with felony charges and a $107,416 overdraft over $120,000.
- The only famous exception, Citibank's $900 million Revlon error, worked because the recipients were genuinely owed the money — a defence that does not apply to a random credit.
- If wrong money lands in your account: do not spend or move it, call your bank the same day, and keep records of the report.
- If you sent money to the wrong account: report it immediately — in the UK your bank must start recovery within 2 working days, in India within 48 hours, and in the US a wire recall only works while the funds are still there.
Ajay Bagaria's two-day turnaround is the model: notice the money, check what it is, call the right people, send it back. He kept his reputation, his client relationship and his freedom — all worth far more than ₹34 crore that was never his.
Sources
- News18 — NHAI wrongly transfers ₹34 crore to lawyer's account
- Al Jazeera — Schwab mistakenly deposits $1.2M into US woman's account
- Gulf News — Bank accidentally puts $120,000 in couple's account
- Legal 500 — A One-in-a-Billion (-Dollar) Mistake (Citibank/Revlon)
- Write My Legal Letter — Sent money to the wrong bank account? (UK)
- GoCompare — Guide to misdirected payments
- Pulse Nigeria — CBN warns: retaining mistaken bank transfers risks 10 years prison
- The Ladders — Bank deposits $1m in your account, can you keep it?
The MoneyHabit editorial desk researches, writes and reviews every article against our editorial policy.
The Sunday Habit
One useful money idea, every week.
A short, practical email every Sunday — no spam, no selling your address, unsubscribe anytime.
Advertisement
More in Financial Literacy

Financial Literacy · Explainer
What Is a Money Market Fund? The Plain-English Guide
Money market funds pay close to 3.9% while the average savings account pays 0.38%. What they are, how they differ from savings accounts, and the risks to know.
18 November 2026 · 10 min read

Financial Literacy · Guide
The Employer Match: Free Money Most Workers Miss
One in four workers misses part of their employer match — about $1,336 a year. Here is how the match works, and the 10-minute check that captures it.
16 November 2026 · 10 min read

Financial Literacy · Explainer
The $900 Billion Riddle: Why Most People Pick Wrong
A viral riddle offers $900 billion today or $1.2 million an hour. The maths has a clear winner — and it explains how lottery jackpots work.
12 November 2026 · 6 min read