Skip to main content

Review

Pension Apps Compared: Track Retirement in One Place

Pension apps promise to find lost pots and show retirement in one place. We compared the UK main apps on fees, transfers and features — plus free US trackers.

By MoneyHabit Editorial Team

11 November 2026 · 12 min read

Several small gold coin stacks merging into one tall stack with a seedling, beside a phone showing a rising chart
In this article

Most people don't have one pension. They have several — a pot from the job they left in 2019, another from the one before that, a personal pension they opened and forgot about. The Association of British Insurers puts the number of lost pension pots in the UK at around 3.3 million, and every one of them belongs to someone who is probably still paying fees on it. Pension apps promise to fix this: find your old pots, pull them into one place, and show you, on your phone, whether retirement is actually on track. Some do it well. Some charge you a lot for the privilege. Here's how the main ones compare.

What pension apps actually do

There are three different jobs hiding under the label "pension app", and the right app depends on which job you need done:

  • Consolidators — PensionBee and Penfold find your old workplace pensions and transfer them into one personal pension they manage for you. You pick a ready-made plan; they do the paperwork.
  • SIPPs — Freetrade, InvestEngine, Vanguard and AJ Bell give you a self-invested personal pension: a pension wrapper you control, where you choose the funds, shares or ETFs inside it. More choice, more responsibility.
  • Trackers — Empower's free dashboard in the US (and, in the UK, the government's own Pension Tracing Service plus the apps above) simply shows all your accounts in one place without moving any money. Tracking costs nothing; consolidating costs a fee.

The distinction matters because the cheapest option is often doing nothing at all — if your old workplace pension is already in a low-cost default fund, moving it to an app that charges 0.50% a year makes you poorer, not richer. The app earns its fee when it finds a pot you'd forgotten, rescues you from a high-fee legacy scheme, or finally gets you contributing regularly.

The one question to ask first: what does your current pension charge? If you don't know, log into your old provider before downloading anything. A pension app is only a bargain if it beats the fee you're already paying.

The UK apps compared

Fees below were checked against providers' own pricing pages in October–November 2026 by independent comparison sites. They change, so confirm the current figure in the app before you transfer anything.

AppWhat it isAnnual feeMinimumBest for
PensionBeePersonal pension, ready-made plans0.50%–0.95% all-in (halved above £100,000)£0Combining old pots with zero effort
PenfoldSIPP, ready-made plans0.75% up to £100,000, 0.40% above (0.88%/0.53% Sharia)£0Self-employed savers
MoneyboxPersonal pension, own funds or open choice0.15% + 0.29% fund fee on own funds (capped at £150/yr service fee); 0.45% on other funds£0Beginners already using Moneybox
VanguardSIPP£4/month under £32,000, then 0.15% a year, capped at £375 across all Vanguard accounts£0Low-cost index investing
AJ BellSIPP0.25% on funds up to £250,000, 0.10% to £500,000, 0% above; shares capped at £10/month£500 lump sum or £25/monthSmall pots and DIY investors
FreetradeSIPP£0 platform fee on all plans, including free Basic, since January 2026£0Cost-conscious DIY investors
InvestEngineSIPP£0 DIY; 0.25% managed£0Free ETF investing, managed option

A few details behind the table. PensionBee is not really a SIPP: you pick one of seven ready-made plans — Tracker at 0.50%, Global Leaders at 0.70%, Climate at 0.75%, Shariah at 0.95% — rather than choosing individual investments. The fee includes fund costs, so there is nothing hidden on top, and it is halved on the part of your savings above £100,000. PensionBee is authorised and regulated by the FCA, and its funds are managed by firms including BlackRock, State Street and HSBC. Penfold is built for the self-employed, with the same ready-made approach and a higher headline fee. Moneybox is cheapest on its own funds — 0.15% service fee plus 0.29% fund fee, with the service fee capped at £150 a year — but jumps to 0.45% a year on the first £100,000 if you pick other funds.

The £0-fee SIPPs are the story of 2026: Freetrade now charges no platform fee on its SIPP on any plan, and InvestEngine charges nothing for its DIY SIPP. You still pay the fund or ETF running costs inside them, but the platform itself takes nothing. Vanguard's flat £4 a month under £32,000 works out at £48 a year — cheap on a £30,000 pot, less so on a £3,000 one.

What the same pot costs at each app

Platform or service fee only, per year. Fund and ETF running costs are extra everywhere except PensionBee, whose fee includes them. Figures from TryAbel's October 2026 fee check:

App£20,000 pot£50,000 pot£150,000 pot
Freetrade (Basic)£0£0£0
InvestEngine (DIY)£0£0£0
Moneybox (own funds)£30£75£150
Vanguard£48£75£225
PensionBee (Tracker, 0.50%)£100£250£625
PensionBee (Global Leaders, 0.70%)£140£350£875
Penfold (0.75%)£150£375£950
AJ Bell (funds, 0.25%)£50£125£375

On a £50,000 pot, the gap between the cheapest and the most expensive ready-made option is £375 a year — every year, for decades. That is the number to hold in your head when an app's slick dashboard tempts you. Convenience is worth paying for, but it is worth knowing exactly what it costs.

On a £50,000 pot, the gap between a £0-fee SIPP and a 0.75% ready-made pension is £375 a year — every year, for decades. Convenience is worth paying for, but only if you know the price.

The 30-year cost of half a percent

A 0.50% annual fee sounds trivial. Over a working lifetime it is not. These are our own calculations, labelled as such: take a £50,000 pot growing at 5% a year before fees, with no further contributions, over 30 years. At 5% gross it reaches about £216,097. Shave 0.50% off the annual return — the Tracker plan's fee — and it reaches about £187,266. The gap is roughly £28,831. At a 0.75% fee, the pot reaches about £174,282, a gap of roughly £41,815 against the no-fee return. These are illustrations before inflation and tax, not predictions, and they ignore the fund costs inside the £0-fee SIPPs — but they show why the fee table above is the most important table in this article. Small percentages compound into life-changing sums.

The counter-argument is real, though: a fee you actually pay on a pot you actually contribute to beats a free account you never open. PensionBee's own pitch is that people who consolidate start contributing more, because they can finally see the number. If an app's simplicity gets you from £0 a month to £200 a month, the fee is the cheapest money you will ever spend. The maths only punishes you if the app changes nothing about your behaviour.

How long does a transfer actually take?

This is where pension apps earn their reputation — or lose it. According to Origo, whose transfer service handles most UK defined-contribution pension transfers, simple transfers averaged 10 days in the year to March 2026, and 11 days including more complex cases, across 1.8 million transfers worth £78.6 billion. Electronic transfers are the fast route: PensionBee completes its own transfers in an average of 10 days, and the fastest providers in its 2025 data managed five days.

The slow end is genuinely slow. PensionBee's analysis of 35 major providers found the slowest took between 47 and 90 days on average in 2025 — Cushon Master Trust, Creative Pension Trust, XPS Administration, the Local Government Pension Scheme and Capita among them — and the overall industry average was 23 days. MoneyHelper says a transfer often takes between two and six weeks, and providers legally have up to six months to act on a request. The delays are usually paper forms, wet-ink signatures and scam checks at the old provider, not the app you are moving to. If your transfer is stuck, the hold-up is almost always the provider losing the money, not the one receiving it.

Do not transfer blindly. Never move a defined-benefit (final salary) pension without regulated advice — you would be giving up a guaranteed income for life. Before any transfer, check for guaranteed annuity rates, exit fees, protected tax-free cash above 25%, and whether your employer is still contributing to the old scheme. If any of those apply, stop and get advice first.

Choosing in three questions

1. Do you want to choose your own investments? If yes, you want a SIPP — Freetrade or InvestEngine if cost is king, Vanguard if you want low-cost index funds with a big-brand wrapper, AJ Bell if you want the widest choice. If no, PensionBee, Penfold or Moneybox's ready-made plans do the choosing for you.

2. How big is the pot? Under £30,000, flat fees hurt: Vanguard's £48 a year is 1.6% of a £3,000 pot. Percentage fees hurt as pots grow: 0.75% on £150,000 is £950 a year. The £0-fee SIPPs and Vanguard's £375 cap are the ones that stay cheap at scale.

3. Are you self-employed? Penfold is built for you — it handles irregular contributions and lets you set contributions as a percentage of income. PensionBee and Moneybox also accept irregular payments, but Penfold's whole product is aimed at people without an employer scheme.

What about the US?

American readers don't have SIPPs, but the same split — track for free, or pay to have it managed — applies. Empower's Personal Dashboard is free: link your accounts and it shows net worth, a retirement planner and a fee analyser, with no upsell wall on the planning tools. The paid Empower advisory service starts at a $100,000 minimum and 0.89% a year. Fidelity's free Retirement Score takes a few minutes and measures your plan against its yardstick — at least 1x your salary saved by 30, 3x by 40, 6x by 50, 8x by 60 and 10x by 67. Boldin builds a full retirement plan free, with PlannerPlus adding tax projections and Monte Carlo simulation for $168 a year after a 14-day trial. Vanguard's Digital Advisor manages for about 0.16% net with a $100 minimum. For 2026, the 401(k) contribution limit is $24,500 and the IRA limit is $7,500. The pattern is the same on both sides of the Atlantic: the tracking is free, the management costs, and the best app is the one you actually open.

Five mistakes people make with pension apps

  1. Paying to consolidate a pot that was already cheap. Check your existing fee first. If your old workplace pension charges 0.30%, moving it to a 0.75% app is a pay rise for the app, not for you.
  2. Transferring a defined-benefit pension. A guaranteed income for life is almost never worth swapping for a pot you have to manage yourself. Get regulated advice, always.
  3. Forgetting the fund fee. A "£0 platform fee" SIPP still charges fund costs inside the investments — typically 0.06% to 0.30% for index funds. Compare total cost, not headline cost.
  4. Ignoring drawdown. The app that is cheapest while you save may not be cheapest when you start taking money out. Check withdrawal and drawdown charges before you commit for 30 years.
  5. Consolidating and then stopping. The app did its job; now you have to do yours. Set a monthly contribution — even £50 — the day the transfer lands, or the tidy dashboard is just a prettier way of watching a small pot stay small.

Frequently asked questions

Is it safe to put my pension in an app?

PensionBee, Penfold, Moneybox, Vanguard, AJ Bell, Freetrade and InvestEngine are all authorised and regulated by the FCA, and your pension assets are held separately from the company's own money. If the app company failed, your investments would still be yours. The FSCS covers up to £85,000 if a regulated firm fails and your money is lost through its fault — but that does not cover investments falling in value, which is a normal market risk.

Will transferring my pension cost me anything?

Most of the apps charge nothing to transfer in. Your old provider may charge an exit fee, and selling out of some older funds can trigger costs. Ask both sides in writing before you start.

Can I transfer a pension and keep my employer's contributions?

No. Employer contributions only go into your current workplace scheme. If you transfer an old pot out, future employer contributions go to your current scheme, not the app. Never transfer out of an active workplace pension that your employer is still paying into.

What is the minimum pension age?

Currently 55 in the UK, rising to 57 from April 2028. You cannot normally access pension money before then, whatever the app shows you. In the US, 59½ is the age for penalty-free 401(k) and IRA withdrawals.

Do pension apps find lost pensions for me?

They try: you give them your old employers' names and they trace the schemes. If they can't find one, the government's free Pension Tracing Service can help, and it costs nothing. Around 3.3 million pots are currently lost, according to the Association of British Insurers, so it is worth the ten minutes.

Key takeaways

  • Check what your current pension charges before downloading anything — an app only saves you money if it beats your existing fee.
  • On a £50,000 pot, annual platform fees range from £0 (Freetrade, InvestEngine DIY) to £375 (Penfold) — and a 0.50% fee costs roughly £28,831 over 30 years on our illustrative calculation.
  • Simple pension transfers average 10 days, but the slowest providers take 47–90 days; the delay is usually at the old provider, not the app.
  • Never transfer a defined-benefit pension, or one with guaranteed benefits, without regulated advice.
  • In the US, Empower's dashboard and Fidelity's Retirement Score are free — the tracking costs nothing, the management is what you pay for.

The best pension app is not the one with the prettiest dashboard. It is the one whose fee you understand, whose transfer actually completed, and whose monthly contribution you set up the day your old pots landed in one place. Pick it with the tables above, check the current fees in the app itself, and then — this is the part the app can't do for you — start paying in.

Sources

Share this article

MoneyHabit Editorial Team

The MoneyHabit editorial desk researches, writes and reviews every article against our editorial policy.

More from MoneyHabit Editorial Team

The Sunday Habit

One useful money idea, every week.

A short, practical email every Sunday — no spam, no selling your address, unsubscribe anytime.

Advertisement

More in Apps & Software Reviews