Review
Tax Software Compared: File Without an Accountant
TurboTax vs H&R Block vs FreeTaxUSA, TaxSlayer, TaxAct and Cash App Taxes — real prices, free routes and UK picks for filing without an accountant.

In this article
- What changed for this filing season
- Tax software compared at a glance
- The free routes, first
- 1. IRS Free File (AGI $89,000 or less)
- 2. Free File Fillable Forms (any income)
- 3. VITA and TCE (in-person help)
- 4. MilTax (military)
- 5. Cash App Taxes ($0, no income cap)
- TurboTax: the most polished, and the most expensive
- H&R Block: the free tier with a human behind it
- FreeTaxUSA: the value pick, by a distance
- TaxSlayer and TaxAct: the middle of the market
- What the same return actually costs
- Five traps to watch before you pay
- If you file in the UK
- Which one should you pick?
- Frequently asked questions
- Key takeaways
Filing your own tax return without an accountant is cheaper than most people think — and more expensive than it needs to be if you pick the wrong tool. The same federal return can cost $0 on one platform and more than $200 on another, with the only difference being how much hand-holding you want along the way. This comparison uses prices checked in October and November 2026, and it starts with the biggest change of the season: the IRS's own free filing tool is gone.
What changed for this filing season
Two things matter most. First, IRS Direct File is dead. The free government-run filing tool, which ran in 25 states for the 2025 filing season, will not operate for the 2026 season — the IRS told the 25 partner states on 3 November 2025 that there would be no launch date. If you used Direct File last year, you need a new route this year.
Second, the free route that survives got more generous. IRS Free File — the partnership between the IRS and eight commercial software companies — now covers adjusted gross income of $89,000 or less for tax year 2025, up from $84,000 the year before. The catch, and it is a real one: you must start your return from irs.gov/freefile. Arrive at the same company's site any other way and you can land in the paid product instead. For the season opening in January 2027, IRS.gov now lists $95,000 or less, so check the current cap before you start.
The one rule that saves the most money: check whether you qualify for a free route before you pay anything. Roughly 164 million individual returns were expected in 2026, yet Free File remains one of the least-used tools in the tax system — most people who could file free never try.
The third thing to know is that prices move through the season. Every figure below is a snapshot from October–November 2026. TurboTax, H&R Block, TaxSlayer and TaxAct all discount in the autumn and raise prices as the 15 April deadline approaches. Never budget from a review's screenshot — verify the live price at checkout.
Tax software compared at a glance
| Software | Free tier | Mid tier (federal) | Self-employed (federal) | State | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| TurboTax | $0, simple returns only | Deluxe $79 | $129 | $64 | Maximum guidance, best imports |
| H&R Block | $0, simple returns | Deluxe $65 | $130 | ~$37–$49 | Free tier plus in-person backup |
| FreeTaxUSA | $0 federal, every situation | $0 | $0 | $15.99 | Best value for confident filers |
| TaxSlayer | Simply Free $0, narrow rules | Classic $23–$45 | $53–$75 | $40–$48 | Budget self-employment filing |
| TaxAct | $0 federal, simple returns | Deluxe $59.99 | $109.99 | $64.99 | Mid-price mainstream option |
| Cash App Taxes | $0, all forms | $0 | $0 | $0 | Truly free, one state only |
Prices are US dollars, checked October–November 2026 from the providers' own pages and independent comparisons. Ranges reflect seasonal pricing and different check dates, not errors — this is exactly why you should re-check before paying.
The free routes, first
Before comparing paid tiers, work through the free options in this order — each one is genuinely $0, and together they cover most filers.
1. IRS Free File (AGI $89,000 or less)
Guided software from eight partner companies, including FreeTaxUSA, TaxAct and TaxSlayer, free if your adjusted gross income on the 2025 return is $89,000 or less. There is no age limit and no simplicity requirement — some partners cover Schedule C and investments. Start only at irs.gov/freefile, and note that state filing may still cost extra depending on the partner.
2. Free File Fillable Forms (any income)
The IRS's electronic versions of the paper 1040 forms. No income cap at all, but no guidance either — you do the maths and the form selection yourself. Right for confident filers who know exactly which forms they need; wrong for anyone who wants the software to ask questions.
3. VITA and TCE (in-person help)
Volunteer Income Tax Assistance generally serves people earning $69,000 or less, plus people with disabilities and those needing language help. Tax Counseling for the Elderly focuses on filers aged 60 and over. Trained volunteers prepare the return with you, free, in person or virtually.
4. MilTax (military)
Free for service members, spouses and eligible family through Military OneSource, with no income cap — the one free route that covers complex military situations well.
5. Cash App Taxes ($0, no income cap)
The only mainstream commercial product that is completely free: every form, federal and state, $0, with no paid tiers and no upsells. The trade-offs are real — it files one state only, brokerage imports are weaker than TurboTax's, and support is in-app only with no phone line. If your return is a single state and you are comfortable without a human to call, it is the cheapest honest option in the market.
Free does not mean worse. The IRS guarantees nothing about commercial software, but FreeTaxUSA and Cash App Taxes file the same forms, to the same IRS, as the $200 products — the price difference buys guidance and convenience, not a different return.
TurboTax: the most polished, and the most expensive
TurboTax remains the platform to beat on experience. Its W-2 photo capture, brokerage 1099 imports from Fidelity, Schwab, Vanguard and Robinhood, and conversational interview flow are still the smoothest in the category. Deluxe ($79 federal) covers itemised deductions, HSA contributions and student-loan interest; Premier ($139) adds capital gains, rental income and crypto; Self-Employed ($129) covers Schedule C with QuickBooks integration. State is a flat $64 per state.
Two warnings. First, TurboTax is under an FTC order since January 2024 that bars it from advertising its product as "free" — the Free Edition covers simple Form 1040 returns only, and investments, rentals or self-employment push you to a paid tier. Second, it is the priciest route for complex returns: a self-employed filer in one state pays $129 + $64 = $193 at the prices checked. If you value the interview flow and the import quality, that can be worth it. If you know your return, it rarely is.
H&R Block: the free tier with a human behind it
H&R Block's Free Online tier is the most generous of the big two — $0 federal and state for simple returns — and its paid tiers run roughly 10–15% below TurboTax: Deluxe $65, Premium $105, Self-Employed $130 federal, with state around $37–$49. Its real advantage is the hybrid model: you can start online and finish in one of its offices, or pay extra for a tax professional to review the return. For first-time filers who want a safety net they can walk into, that is worth more than any feature list.
FreeTaxUSA: the value pick, by a distance
FreeTaxUSA charges $0 for any federal return — Schedule C, Schedule D, Schedule E, K-1s, crypto, the lot — and $15.99 per state. An optional Deluxe upgrade at $7.99 adds priority support, live chat, audit assistance and unlimited amendments. A typical year therefore costs about $24 in total. The interface is plainer than TurboTax's and the guidance is thinner, but the maths is the same and the accuracy guarantee covers up to $10,000. For confident DIY filers, this is the default recommendation: it is the cheapest way to file a complex return without giving anything up on form coverage.
TaxSlayer and TaxAct: the middle of the market
TaxSlayer's Classic tier, at $22.95–$44.99 federal depending on when you check, covers most situations, and its Self-Employed tier at $52.99–$74.99 is one of the cheapest Schedule C options from a major brand. State runs $39.99–$47.99. Active-duty military file federal free. The trade-off is a more basic interface and less hand-holding than TurboTax — fine for experienced filers, less forgiving for first-timers.
TaxAct positions itself directly against TurboTax at roughly a quarter less: Deluxe $59.99, Premier $99.99, Self-Employed $109.99 federal, with state at $64.99 — a state fee high enough to narrow the savings for multi-state filers. Its genuine strength is business returns: it handles K-1s and pass-through income cleanly, and a separate Business line files partnership and S-corporation returns. Watch the free tier: federal is free, but state costs extra even there.
What the same return actually costs
Our own calculations from the prices above, one state, federal plus state:
| Your situation | Cash App Taxes | FreeTaxUSA | TaxSlayer | TaxAct | H&R Block | TurboTax |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Simple W-2 only | $0 | $15.99 | $0* | State fee only | $0 | $0 |
| Itemised + investments | $0 | $15.99 | ~$104 | ~$165 | ~$154 | ~$203 |
| Self-employed (Schedule C) | $0 | $15.99 | ~$93–$123 | ~$175 | ~$179 | ~$193 |
*TaxSlayer Simply Free has narrow eligibility rules — most filers with anything beyond a W-2 will not qualify. The lesson of the table is not that one product is "best": it is that the gap between the cheapest and the most expensive route for the same return is nearly $200, and the expensive end buys guidance, not accuracy.
Five traps to watch before you pay
1. The seasonal price rise. Prices checked in autumn are not April prices. File early if you can — the same tier can cost 30–50% more near the deadline.
2. The state fee ambush. A "$0 federal" headline says nothing about state. Cash App Taxes is the only major product with state included at $0; everywhere else, state is a separate line item of $16 to $65 per state.
3. The free-tier funnel. Most free tiers cover simple W-2 returns only. Add investments, a rental or a side business and you are bumped to a paid tier — sometimes after you have already entered all your data. Check the tier rules before you start typing.
4. Refund advances and audit defence. Refund advance "loans" are marketed as free money; they are loans against your own refund, and the fees sit in the fine print. Audit defence is usually an add-on — FreeTaxUSA includes it in the $7.99 Deluxe upgrade, others charge $30 or more. Decide whether you need it before checkout, not during it.
5. The 2025 standard deduction. For tax year 2025 the standard deduction is $15,750 single and $31,500 married filing jointly. If your itemised deductions do not beat those figures, you do not need the Deluxe tier's itemisation features at all — the free tier will do.
If you file in the UK
UK Self Assessment works differently, and the free option is stronger. HMRC's own online service is free and files straight to HMRC through the Government Gateway — it covers the full SA100 with standard supplementary pages, but not partnerships, trusts, non-residents or a handful of edge cases. The online deadline for the 2025/26 tax year is 31 January 2027.
If HMRC's interface puts you off, commercial software starts cheap: DTax Filer at £14.50 per return and TaxCalc from £42 (up to six returns). GoSimpleTax is the guided DIY option at £69.99 a year on subscription or £113.99 one-off, including VAT, with tax-saving suggestions and email support from a team of former HMRC staff. Taxd offers guided filing at £99 including VAT per return.
If you would rather an accountant did it, Taxfix (formerly TaxScouts) charges £97 for new customers on an annual plan against a £169 standard price, £129 with deduction optimisation, a tax-planning call and HMRC letter support, and £324 for a year-round accountant — prices checked October 2026. One change to note: Making Tax Digital for Income Tax began on 6 April 2026 for those with qualifying income over £50,000, so some landlords and sole traders now need compatible software rather than a once-a-year form.
Which one should you pick?
- Simple W-2, one state, comfortable on your own: Cash App Taxes ($0) or H&R Block Free ($0).
- AGI $89,000 or less: start at irs.gov/freefile and take the guided software free.
- Investments, rentals or self-employment, and you know your return: FreeTaxUSA — about $16–$24 all-in.
- Self-employed and want the cheapest guided Schedule C: TaxSlayer Self-Employed, roughly $93–$123 with state.
- First return, nervous, or want a human to call: TurboTax if you will pay for polish, H&R Block if you want an office to walk into.
- UK Self Assessment: HMRC's free service first; GoSimpleTax if you want guidance; Taxfix if you want an accountant.
Frequently asked questions
Can I really file my taxes for free?
Yes, in several ways: IRS Free File if your AGI is $89,000 or less, Free File Fillable Forms at any income, VITA if you earn $69,000 or less, MilTax if you are military, and Cash App Taxes with no income cap at all. The free options file the same forms as the paid ones.
Is IRS Direct File coming back?
Not for the 2026 filing season. The IRS told the 25 partner states in November 2025 that Direct File would not operate and no future launch date has been set. Use IRS Free File instead.
Why does TurboTax cost so much more than FreeTaxUSA?
Guidance and imports, not accuracy. TurboTax's interview flow, W-2 photo capture and brokerage imports are the best in the category, and its brand carries a maximum-refund guarantee. FreeTaxUSA files the same forms for $0 federal — you supply more of the knowledge yourself.
Do I need to pay for state filing?
Almost everywhere, yes — state is a separate fee of roughly $16 to $65 per state. Cash App Taxes is the exception: federal and state are both $0, though it files only one state.
When should I file to get the cheapest price?
Early. Tax software prices rise through the season and peak near the 15 April deadline, so the same tier can cost 30–50% more in April than it did in the autumn. If your documents are ready, file in January or February.
Key takeaways
- IRS Direct File is gone for the 2026 season; IRS Free File (AGI $89,000 or less, via irs.gov/freefile) is the free guided replacement.
- The same return costs $0 to about $203 depending on the tool — the gap buys guidance, not a different return.
- FreeTaxUSA ($0 federal + $15.99 state) is the best value for complex returns; Cash App Taxes is the only fully free option, federal and state.
- TurboTax is the most polished and the most expensive; H&R Block is the best free tier with in-person backup.
- Prices rise toward the 15 April deadline — verify the live price at checkout and file early when you can.
- In the UK, HMRC's own online service is free; GoSimpleTax (£69.99/yr) adds guidance and Taxfix (£97 new-customer) adds an accountant.
The cheapest correct return is the one you file through a free route you actually qualify for. Before you pay for software, spend five minutes checking IRS Free File — and if you do pay, pay for the guidance you need, not the brand you recognise. Check the live price at checkout, file early, and keep the $200 difference.
Sources
- Rankite — Best Tax Software in 2026
- The GuideX — 8 Best Tax Software in 2026
- Beancount — IRS Free File 2026: $89,000 AGI Cap & Schedule C
- Tax47 — IRS Free File 2026: Where to File Now
- SmashingApps — Best Tax Software for Self-Employed in 2026
- Elvex Finance — Best Tax Software 2026
- Generation Money — Best Tax Return Service (UK)
- DTax Filer — Self Assessment Software Prices Compared (UK)
The MoneyHabit editorial desk researches, writes and reviews every article against our editorial policy.
The Sunday Habit
One useful money idea, every week.
A short, practical email every Sunday — no spam, no selling your address, unsubscribe anytime.
Advertisement
More in Apps & Software Reviews

Apps & Software Reviews · Review
Bill-Splitting Apps Compared: Split Rent, Meals and Trips
Splitwise, Tricount, Settle Up, Splid and Venmo Groups compared on price, free limits and features — so rent, meals and trips split fairly.
15 November 2026 · 10 min read

Apps & Software Reviews · Review
Budgeting Apps for Irregular Income Compared
Freelance pay arrives in lumps, not a salary. Seven budgeting apps compared on variable-income handling, prices and free tiers.
12 November 2026 · 12 min read

Apps & Software Reviews · Review
Pension Apps Compared: Track Retirement in One Place
Pension apps promise to find lost pots and show retirement in one place. We compared the UK main apps on fees, transfers and features — plus free US trackers.
11 November 2026 · 12 min read