Skip to main content

Guide

SAVE Is Over: RAP or IBR — Which Costs You Less?

SAVE is gone and 7.5 million borrowers must pick RAP or IBR. We ran the numbers at four incomes — the cheaper plan flips depending on your pay.

By MoneyHabit Editorial Team

22 November 2026 · 13 min read

Graduate at a fork in the road between two glowing paths, one with a shield and one with a calendar clock
In this article

SAVE is over, and the clock is now personal. A court approved the settlement ending the Saving on a Valuable Education plan in March 2026, leaving about 7.5 million enrolled borrowers to find a new plan, according to the U.S. Department of Education. Servicers began sending notices on July 1, 2026, and each borrower gets 90 days from their own notice to choose — miss it, and the system chooses for you. For most former SAVE borrowers, the decision is between two income-driven plans: the brand-new Repayment Assistance Plan (RAP) and the long-running Income-Based Repayment (IBR). Run the numbers, and the cheaper plan flips with your income, your family size, and how long you plan to carry the debt.

The two plans in 60 seconds

RAP launched on July 1, 2026, created by the 2025 budget reconciliation law (P.L. 119-21) as the replacement income-driven plan. IBR has been around for years and is staying. Both set your payment from your income, both count toward Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF), and both are free to switch into. But they measure your income in completely different ways — and that is where the money is won or lost.

Repayment Assistance Plan (RAP)Income-Based Repayment (IBR)
Payment based on1% to 10% of your total adjusted gross income (AGI)10% (new borrowers) or 15% (older borrowers) of discretionary income — AGI minus 150% of the poverty line
Dependents$50 less per month for each dependentA bigger family means more income is protected
Unpaid interestWaived each month you pay on time and in fullAccrues, and can be added to your balance later
ForgivenessAfter 30 yearsAfter 20 years (new borrowers) or 25 years (older borrowers)
Payment capNoneNever more than the 10-year Standard Plan payment
Who can use itFederal Direct Loans only; Parent PLUS loans excludedLoans made before July 1, 2026; needs a partial financial hardship to enter

How RAP actually works

RAP charges a percentage of your whole AGI — there is no poverty-line deduction. The percentage steps up one point for each $10,000 of income, under the formula published by the Department of Education: $10,000 or less pays a flat $120 a year ($10 a month); $10,001–$20,000 pays 1%; $20,001–$30,000 pays 2%; $30,001–$40,000 pays 3%; $40,001–$50,000 pays 4%; $50,001–$60,000 pays 5%; $60,001–$70,000 pays 6%; $70,001–$80,000 pays 7%; $80,001–$90,000 pays 8%; $90,001–$100,000 pays 9%; and more than $100,000 pays 10%. Then subtract $50 a month for each dependent you claim.

RAP also has two protections SAVE borrowers never had: the interest waiver, which wipes out any interest your payment does not cover (as long as you pay on time and in full), and the principal match, which ensures your balance falls by at least $50 a month. Together they mean your balance cannot grow while you are on RAP and paying as agreed. The trade-offs are the 30-year road to forgiveness and the missing cap: there is no ceiling on a RAP payment, so if your income doubles, your payment roughly doubles with it.

How IBR actually works

IBR only counts the income above a protected amount: your AGI minus 150% of the federal poverty guideline for your household size. For a single borrower in 2026, that protected amount is $23,940 (1.5 times the $15,960 poverty guideline). For a family of four, it is $49,500 (1.5 times $33,000). You pay 10% of that discretionary income if you first borrowed on or after July 1, 2014, or 15% if you borrowed earlier.

Two features make IBR different in practice. First, you need a partial financial hardship to enter — the standard 10-year payment on your loans must be higher than your income-driven payment, so a small balance next to a high income may not qualify at all. Second, your payment is capped at the 10-year Standard Plan amount: if your income jumps, your IBR payment can rise only as far as the standard payment, and no further. IBR forgives the balance after 20 years for new borrowers, or 25 years for older ones, and if your income is very low your payment can be $0 — something RAP, with its $10 floor, cannot match.

The one-line version: RAP counts all of your income and forgives after 30 years, but it stops your balance growing. IBR ignores your first ~$24,000 of income (single) and forgives after 20 years, but unpaid interest can pile up.

The numbers: four borrowers, side by side

The examples below are illustrations using the published formulas, with a 6% interest rate and the 2026 poverty guidelines. Run your own numbers in the official Loan Simulator at StudentAid.gov before you choose.

1. Single, $40,000 income, $35,000 balance

RAP: $100 a month — 3% of $40,000 is $1,200 a year. IBR: $134 a month — 10% of $16,060 in discretionary income ($40,000 minus $23,940). RAP wins by $34. Interest runs about $175 a month, so both payments fall short — but on RAP the $75 shortfall is waived and the balance still falls by at least $50 a month, while on IBR the $41 shortfall accrues. The catch: IBR forgives after 20 years, RAP after 30.

2. Single, $30,000 income, $28,000 balance

RAP: $50 a month — 2% of $30,000 is $600 a year. IBR: about $51 a month — 10% of $6,060 in discretionary income. The payments are effectively identical, but the deal is not: on RAP, the $90 monthly interest shortfall ($140 of interest versus a $50 payment) is waived and the principal match keeps the balance shrinking. On IBR, the unpaid interest accrues. Same $50, very different ten years.

3. Single, $80,000 income, $60,000 balance

RAP: $467 a month — 7% of $80,000 is $5,600 a year. IBR: $467 a month — 10% of $56,060 in discretionary income. The same number, to the dollar. At this income the two formulas cross, and the tie-breakers decide it: IBR forgives ten years sooner, while RAP's interest waiver is worth nothing here because both payments cover the $300 monthly interest. But watch what happens next: if this borrower's income rises to $120,000, RAP takes 10% — $1,000 a month — while IBR cannot exceed the $666 standard payment on a $60,000 balance. The cap is IBR's quiet superpower for rising earners.

4. Family of four, $60,000 income, two children, $40,000 balance

RAP: $150 a month — 5% of $60,000 is $250 a month, minus $50 for each of the two dependents. IBR: about $88 a month — 10% of $10,500 in discretionary income ($60,000 minus the $49,500 protected for a family of four). IBR wins by a wide margin, because it ignores nearly $50,000 of this family's income while RAP counts all of it. For larger households and lower incomes, IBR is usually the cheaper plan.

BorrowerRAP / monthIBR / monthCheaper plan
Single, $40,000 income, $35,000 owed$100$134RAP
Single, $30,000 income, $28,000 owed$50$51Tie — but RAP protects the balance
Single, $80,000 income, $60,000 owed$467$467Tie — IBR forgives 10 years sooner
Family of 4, $60,000 income, $40,000 owed$150$88IBR

The income cliff: when a $1 raise costs you $500 a year

RAP's biggest quirk is that its percentage applies to your entire AGI, and it jumps in whole bands. Earn $50,000 and you pay 4% — $2,000 a year, or about $167 a month. Earn $50,001 and you cross into the 5% band, paying 5% of $50,001 — about $2,500 a year, or $208 a month. One extra dollar of income, roughly $500 a year more in loan payments. The same jump happens at every $10,000 boundary.

That does not mean turning down a raise — a raise is still a raise, and the extra pay dwarfs the extra loan bill in most cases. But it does mean timing matters: a bonus, overtime, or a second job that pushes your AGI just over a band boundary can cost more in loan payments than the extra income is worth in that year. Check your number in the Loan Simulator with your actual AGI, including income you expect this year, rather than last year's figure. The $50-per-dependent reduction softens the cliff for parents, but it does not remove it.

Do not let the deadline choose for you. If you do nothing, your servicer places you on a fixed-payment plan — the Standard Plan for loans from before July 1, 2026, or the new Tiered Standard Plan for newer loans. Those payments are based on what you owe, not what you earn, and they are usually higher than an income-driven payment. Worse, Tiered Standard payments do not count toward Public Service Loan Forgiveness at all. You can still switch to an income-driven plan afterwards, with no penalty — but until you do, you pay the higher bill, and those months do not move you toward forgiveness.

Three things that should decide it

1. Are you chasing Public Service Loan Forgiveness? Both RAP and IBR count toward the 120 qualifying payments, and earlier payments you made before the SAVE forbearance still count. But the months you spent in the SAVE forbearance do not count — although you may be able to buy them back. If PSLF is your path, pick the plan that gets you to 120 payments cheapest. The Tiered Standard Plan is not an option at all, since its payments do not count.

2. How much is the forgiveness horizon worth to you? IBR forgives after 20 years for new borrowers; RAP takes 30. Ten extra years of payments is a lot of money — but only if you expect a balance to still be there. If your income is high enough that either plan pays the loan off in full before forgiveness, the horizon does not matter. And remember the tax change: income-driven forgiveness became taxable again on January 1, 2026, when the American Rescue Plan exclusion expired, so a balance forgiven under either plan will generally count as income that year. PSLF forgiveness stays tax-free.

3. Is your income likely to rise? RAP has no cap, so a promotion or a career change can push your payment up without limit. IBR caps at the standard 10-year payment, which protects rising earners. On the other hand, if your income is low and your balance is large, RAP's interest waiver and principal match stop the balance from growing while you pay — something IBR cannot promise.

How to switch in four steps

Switching is free, and your servicer will help — there is no reason to pay a company to do it. The Federal Trade Commission obtained a court order in April stopping an alleged scam operation that collected at least $8.8 million in illegal upfront fees from borrowers. Never share your FSA ID, and never pay anyone to switch your plan.

  1. Check whether you got a notice. Look in your servicer's message center and your email for "You Have 90 Days to Select a New Repayment Plan" or "Final Notice – You will be Placed into a New Repayment Plan in 30 Days." Update your contact details with your servicer and on StudentAid.gov so nothing goes missing.
  2. Run your numbers. Log in to StudentAid.gov and use the official Loan Simulator to compare RAP, IBR, and the Standard Plan on your actual loans, income, and family size. Use your current AGI, not last year's, and remember the $50-per-dependent RAP reduction.
  3. Apply. Income-driven plan applications are at StudentAid.gov/idr, or through your servicer. Let the Department of Education pull your tax information directly from the IRS — it speeds up the application and lets your plan renew automatically each year.
  4. Watch for confirmation. Your servicer will tell you when you have been moved and what your new payment is, at least 21 days before the first payment is due. If you use autopay, the new amount will be withdrawn automatically, so check the notice as soon as it arrives.

If you cannot afford the new payment on any plan, ask your servicer about a short-term deferment or forbearance. Those can bridge a gap, but interest may still accrue, so they are not a long-term fix. And if you have already missed your deadline, it is a setback, not a dead end: you can still apply for an income-driven plan at any time, without penalty, and switch as soon as it is processed.

Frequently asked questions

Is RAP better than IBR?

It depends on your income and household. RAP is often cheaper for single, middle-income borrowers, and its interest waiver and principal match protect your balance. IBR is often cheaper for low earners and larger families, forgives ten years sooner, and caps your payment. Run both in the Loan Simulator — the answer flips at different incomes, as the examples above show.

Do the months I spent in SAVE forbearance count toward forgiveness?

No. Payments you made before the forbearance still count toward PSLF and income-driven forgiveness, and switching plans does not erase them — but the forbearance months themselves do not count. You may be able to buy back some of those months if they would get you to forgiveness; the cost is based on another income-driven plan, so it may be higher than you expect.

What if I borrowed after July 1, 2026?

Then RAP is your only income-driven option. Loans first disbursed on or after July 1, 2026, are limited to RAP or the Tiered Standard Plan. IBR, PAYE, and ICR are closed to new loans, and PAYE and ICR end entirely on July 1, 2028.

Will my forgiven balance be taxed?

For income-driven forgiveness reached in 2026 or later, generally yes — the forgiven amount counts as taxable income, because the American Rescue Plan exclusion expired on December 31, 2025, and Congress has not extended it. Forgiveness under Public Service Loan Forgiveness, and discharges for death or disability, stay tax-free. State rules vary, so check your own state's treatment too.

Key takeaways

  • SAVE ended in March 2026. About 7.5 million borrowers must pick a new plan within 90 days of their servicer's notice — and notices are still going out, with all borrowers due to be notified by the end of 2026.
  • RAP charges 1% to 10% of your total AGI, minus $50 a month per dependent, with an interest waiver and a principal match — but no payment cap and forgiveness only after 30 years.
  • IBR charges 10% or 15% of the income above 150% of the poverty line, forgives after 20 or 25 years, and caps your payment at the standard amount — but unpaid interest can accrue.
  • At $40,000 of income, RAP is cheaper; at $30,000 the payments tie; for a family of four on $60,000, IBR wins by a wide margin. Your income and household size decide it.
  • Watch the bands: crossing a $10,000 AGI boundary raises RAP's percentage on your whole income — a $1 raise at $50,000 can add about $500 a year to your bill.
  • Doing nothing is the most expensive option. You will be auto-enrolled in a fixed-payment plan that ignores your income, and Tiered Standard payments do not count toward PSLF.

SAVE's ending is disruptive, but it is also a genuine choice — the first time in years that most borrowers have had to pick a plan deliberately rather than stay on the default. The borrowers who come out of this transition best are the ones who open the notice, run their own numbers in the Loan Simulator, and choose before the deadline chooses for them. If that notice is sitting in your inbox right now, today is the day to open it: check the date on it, run RAP against IBR on your actual income, and file the application while you still have the full 90 days to think.

Sources

Share this article

MoneyHabit Editorial Team

The MoneyHabit editorial desk researches, writes and reviews every article against our editorial policy.

More from MoneyHabit Editorial Team

The Sunday Habit

One useful money idea, every week.

A short, practical email every Sunday — no spam, no selling your address, unsubscribe anytime.

Advertisement

More in Debt & Credit Education