Skip to main content

Explainer

Visa–Mastercard Settlement: Why Your Card May Cost 3% More

A judge decides on 16 November whether shops can refuse premium cards and add up to 3% at checkout. Here is what changes, when, and how to avoid paying it.

By MoneyHabit Editorial Team

13 November 2026 · 10 min read

Premium credit card on a brass card reader with a surcharge tag and a seedling growing from gold coins
In this article

On Monday 16 November, a federal judge in Brooklyn will decide whether the biggest change to American checkout in twenty years goes ahead. If he approves the Visa and Mastercard settlement, shops will soon be able to refuse your premium rewards card outright and add a surcharge of up to 3% when you pay with the most expensive cards. Nothing changes on the day itself — but the new rules could reach your checkout by February 2027.

First, the warning that matters most: this settlement pays you nothing. There is no claim form and no cheque in the post. If anyone contacts you offering settlement money, it is a scam. What the deal changes is the rules behind every card swipe — and those rules decide what you pay at the till.

Two settlements, one case — do not mix them up

The confusion starts because two different settlements came out of the same lawsuit, known as MDL 1720, which merchants have been fighting since 2005. The first was a cash settlement of about $5.5 billion, paying damages to merchants that accepted Visa or Mastercard between 1 January 2004 and 25 January 2019. That one has its own claims administrator.

The one in the news now is the rules settlement. Signed on 10 November 2025, it covers more than 12 million US merchants and pays no cash at all. Instead, it rewrites the network rules: which cards a shop must accept, how it may surcharge, and how much interchange the networks may charge for the next five to eight years. The often-quoted $38 billion figure is an estimate of merchant savings over time — not a fund, and not a payout.

The road here was long. An earlier version was rejected by Judge Margo Brodie in June 2024. The revised deal won preliminary approval from Judge Brian Cogan on 9 June 2026, when he called it "fair, reasonable, and adequate", according to Reuters. Around 978 merchants and trade groups filed objections in September, including Walmart and the National Retail Federation. The 16 November hearing is their last chance to stop it at district-court level — and an appeal is widely expected whatever the judge decides.

The one-line version: the deal does not cut your card bill. It gives shops new tools to push the cost of expensive cards back onto the people who use them — and premium rewards cards are the most expensive cards in the till.

The five changes that reach your checkout

Here is what the settlement would actually do, based on the agreement text Visa filed with the US Securities and Exchange Commission on 10 November 2025. Mastercard's commitments mirror Visa's.

1. Swipe fees fall — by a little, for a while

Visa and Mastercard would lower average credit interchange rates by 10 basis points — 0.10 percentage points — for five years, and posted rates cannot rise above their 31 March 2025 levels for five years. The Merchants Payments Coalition called the cut "minuscule": on $10,000 of monthly card volume, 0.10% saves about $10 a month.

2. Standard cards get a hard cap

Rates on standard consumer credit cards — the basic, non-premium cards — would be capped at no more than 1.25% for eight years. This is the bigger saving for online sellers. Visa's posted card-not-present rate for a Traditional card was 1.89% plus $0.10, and 2.04% plus $0.10 for Traditional Rewards. Capped at 1.25%, a $100 online sale on a standard card costs about $0.64 to $0.79 less in interchange.

3. Shops can refuse whole categories of cards

This is the structural change. For the entire life of the Visa and Mastercard networks, the "Honor All Cards" rule has meant that a shop accepting one Visa credit card accepts every Visa credit card. The settlement splits cards into three categories, and a merchant can accept or decline each one. The choice is all-or-nothing within a category — a shop cannot take one bank's Signature cards and refuse another's — and it applies to every location under the same trade name. Debit cards stay a separate decision.

CategoryVisa productsMastercard products
Standard consumerTraditional, Traditional RewardsCore, Enhanced Value
Premium consumerSignature, Signature Preferred, InfiniteWorld, World High Value, World Legend, World Elite
CommercialBusiness, Small Business, Corporate, Purchasing, FleetBusiness, Corporate, Purchasing, Fleet

4. Surcharges up to 3% — on the expensive cards only

Merchants would gain the right to surcharge only the card types that cost them the most, in one of two ways — but not both. A brand-level surcharge applies the same percentage to every Visa credit card. A product-level surcharge applies a different percentage per card type — nothing on a Visa Traditional card, say, but 2% on a Visa Infinite. Either way, the surcharge cannot exceed 3% or the actual cost of accepting that card, whichever is lower. If a shop cannot work out its cost, the agreement lets it treat it as 3%.

The rules around it are strict: 30 days' written notice to the payment processor, the surcharge explained at checkout, and the dollar amount shown on the receipt. This is about credit cards only — debit cards still cannot be surcharged. The agreement also explicitly allows a shop to ask you at checkout to use a lower-cost card.

Rewards are not free. The points and cashback on a premium card are funded by the interchange the shop pays — and this settlement is the first time shops have been given real tools to push that cost back to the cardholder.

5. Shops can choose their digital wallets

Merchants will be able to accept some digital wallets and not others, in store and online. The choice is per wallet, not per card inside the wallet.

What it costs you: the worked maths

Why does the category of your card matter so much? Because the gap is wide. On Visa's posted March 2025 schedule, a card-present retail sale cost 1.43% to 1.65% plus $0.10 on a standard card, 2.10% plus $0.10 on Visa Signature Preferred, and up to 2.30% plus $0.10 on Visa Infinite. Online, Infinite ran 2.60% plus $0.10. That gap of roughly half to nine-tenths of a point is what the new rules let shops push back on.

For you as a shopper, the maths is simple — and these are our own calculations, labelled as such. A 3% surcharge on a $100 shop is $3. On a $1,000 purchase it is $30. On a $2,500 holiday booking it is $75. If the surcharge lands only on premium cards, the cheapest way to dodge it is usually to pay with a standard credit card or a debit card instead.

There is a catch that limits how much of the interchange cut ever reaches prices. On interchange-plus pricing, interchange is passed through line by line, so a lower rate shows up on the next statement. On flat-rate pricing — for example 2.9% plus $0.30 online — the processor pays the interchange and keeps the difference. If interchange falls, the shop's price stays the same unless the processor decides to lower it, and nothing in the settlement makes it.

Do not change anything yet. The settlement terms are not in force, and a surcharge that breaks your state's rules can cost more than it collects. State law still applies: Massachusetts prohibits credit card surcharges outright, several other states cap or restrict them, and some require the surcharge to be built into the advertised price. A debit-card surcharge is off the table everywhere.

When it would actually happen

Nothing changes on 16 November itself. The agreement sets the clock from the day the court enters final judgment — and the rule changes run from the approval date, not from the end of any appeal. Treat the dates below as the best case: the judge can refuse final approval, and an appeal is widely expected.

ChangeDeadline in the agreementEarliest realistic date
Card category choice, product-level surcharging, wallet choiceWithin 90 days of final judgmentAbout February 2027
The 0.10 point cut in average interchangeNo earlier than 4 months after final judgment, timed to Visa's April or October rate releaseApril 2027

Treat those dates as the best case. The judge can refuse final approval, and an appeal is widely expected. Until the court rules and any appeals end, today's card network rules still apply.

A note for UK readers: this is a US case and it does not change UK rules. UK interchange has been capped since 2015 — 0.3% for credit cards and 0.2% for debit — and surcharging on consumer cards has been banned in the UK since January 2018.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need to file a claim for the Visa and Mastercard settlement?

No — not for this rules settlement. It pays no cash, so there is nothing to claim and you cannot opt out. The earlier $5.5 billion cash settlement covered merchants that accepted Visa or Mastercard between 1 January 2004 and 25 January 2019, and it runs through its own administrator.

Will my rewards card stop working at some shops?

Possibly, from early 2027. A shop could decline all premium consumer cards — Visa Signature, Signature Preferred and Infinite, or Mastercard World, World High Value, World Legend and World Elite — at every location under the same trade name. It cannot refuse one bank's premium cards while taking another's. Carry a backup: a debit card or a standard credit card.

How much can a shop surcharge me?

Up to the lower of 3% or what that card actually costs the shop to accept, on credit cards only. The shop must give its processor 30 days' notice, disclose the surcharge at checkout, and show the dollar amount on the receipt. State law still applies, and debit cards cannot be surcharged.

Will prices fall because swipe fees are being cut?

Probably not much, and not quickly. The interchange cut is 0.10 percentage points — about $10 a month for a shop taking $10,000 in cards — and on flat-rate pricing the saving stays with the processor unless it chooses to lower its price. The bigger consumer effect is the surcharge and card-refusal rules, not the fee cut.

Key takeaways

  • A judge decides on 16 November 2026 whether to give final approval to the Visa and Mastercard rules settlement — but nothing changes that day.
  • If approved, shops could refuse whole categories of premium rewards cards and add surcharges of up to 3% on the most expensive cards, from about February 2027.
  • The $38 billion figure is estimated merchant savings over time, not a payout. There is no claim form and no money coming to you.
  • A 3% surcharge is $3 on a $100 shop and $30 on a $1,000 purchase — paying with a standard card or debit card is usually the cheapest dodge.
  • State law still applies, debit cards can never be surcharged, and the UK is unaffected: surcharging has been banned here since 2018.

The settlement is not really about the 0.10 point fee cut. It is about who pays for the rewards on your premium card. For twenty years, the Honor All Cards rule meant shops had no choice but to absorb the cost of the most expensive cards in the till. From February 2027, if the judge approves, they will have a choice — and some will hand that cost straight back to you at the checkout. Know which of your cards is premium, carry a standard card or debit card as a backup, and check the receipt before you tap.

Sources

Share this article

MoneyHabit Editorial Team

The MoneyHabit editorial desk researches, writes and reviews every article against our editorial policy.

More from MoneyHabit Editorial Team

The Sunday Habit

One useful money idea, every week.

A short, practical email every Sunday — no spam, no selling your address, unsubscribe anytime.

Advertisement

More in Smart Spending