Guide
Things That Aren't Savings: 8 Traps That Cost You More
A viral post lists eight things that feel like saving but aren't. We checked the maths — free shipping, BOGOs and '70% off' sales mostly cost you more.

In this article
- The one rule that settles every "deal"
- Trap 1: Paying extra for "free" shipping
- Trap 2: Buying two because the second is 30% off
- Trap 3: The discount code that makes you add things
- Trap 4: Buying it because the sale ends at midnight
- Trap 5: The upgrade that's "basically the same price"
- Trap 6: Buying backups of things you haven't finished
- Trap 7: Half price on something you never planned to buy
- Trap 8: "I saved $80" — after spending $120
- The 10-second test before you buy
- Frequently asked questions
- Key takeaways
A post from the Australian money account She's On The Money went viral this week with a blunt list: "Things that aren't savings." Eight everyday shopping moves that feel like saving money — paying extra to unlock free shipping, grabbing the second item at 30% off, buying something because the sale ends at midnight — and, the post argues, every one of them is spending dressed up as saving.
It landed at exactly the right moment. Black Friday falls on 27 November 2026, and the sales have already started stretching for weeks either side of it. So we checked the maths. The uncomfortable news is that the post is mostly right — and the research behind it is stronger than a social media list usually gets.
The one rule that settles every "deal"
Before the eight traps, one rule decides almost all of them: a discount only saves money on something you already intended to buy, at a price you would have paid anyway. Everything else is a feeling of saving, not a saving. Keep that sentence in your pocket for the rest of this guide — it is the test every trap below fails.
That is not a killjoy rule. Real deals exist. The UK consumer group Which? tracked 175 products for a full year around Black Friday 2024 and found some genuinely at their lowest price in the sale. The problem is that the same study found 83% of those products were the same price or cheaper at some point outside the four-week sale window, 42% were actually cheaper, and not one product was at its lowest price only on Black Friday. The deal is usually real. The urgency usually isn't.
Trap 1: Paying extra for "free" shipping
The post's first item is the classic: your cart is $38, shipping is $6.99, and shipping is free over $50 — so you add a $15 item you didn't want. Here is the maths, worked out in full:
- Pay the shipping: $38 + $6.99 = $44.99.
- Chase "free" shipping: $38 + $15 = $53.00.
- You paid $8.01 extra to "save" $6.99.
This is not a rare slip. Research from SellersCommerce, published in 2026, found 58% of shoppers add items specifically to reach a free-shipping threshold, the average threshold sits near $64, and shoppers say they are willing to spend about $43 more to qualify. A 2021 study of more than four million transactions found shoppers padded between 12.4% and 28.4% of orders that fell below the threshold — items researchers call "bubble purchases" because they are added to pop the threshold, not because anyone wanted them.
Behavioural economists have a name for why it works. Richard Thaler's mental accounting theory explains why $50 plus $5 shipping feels worse than $55 with free shipping, even though the total is identical. And the zero-price effect — demonstrated by Shampanier, Mazar and Ariely in the journal Marketing Science — shows that dropping a price from one cent to zero flips what people choose, because "free" carries an emotional charge no small price does. Retailers know this. The threshold is set deliberately, usually 20–30% above the average order, so that a normal basket falls just short.
The only time free shipping saves you money is when the filler item is something you were going to buy anyway, at the same price, in the same week.
Do the filler maths once a month at $8 a time and the habit costs roughly $96 a year — for items you chose to cross a line, not because you needed them.
Trap 2: Buying two because the second is 30% off
Two shirts at $40 each. The second is 30% off, so it costs $28, and the pair costs $68 instead of $80. You "saved" $12. But you came in for one shirt at $40. You spent $28 more than you planned, on a second shirt you had not chosen until the offer chose it for you.
Sometimes the second item genuinely is a bargain — if you would wear both, and $28 beats the rival price. Often it is not even the discount it claims to be. Hong Kong's Consumer Council surveyed 222 supermarket products between September 2025 and July 2026 and found that in several buy-one-get-one-free campaigns, the single-item price during the promotion was higher than before it. One bottle of sesame oil sold at HK$20–22 per item under a BOGO deal, against a pre-promotion price of HK$10–14. After accounting for the promotion, the real discount was at most about 29% — not the near-50% shoppers expect — and for some products the average price per item during the promotion was about 10% higher than the non-promotional price.
Closer to home, Which? analysed more than 70,000 supermarket prices in 2013 and found yoghurts priced at £1 each or "two for £2" — no saving at all. And Public Health England found that around 40% of food and drink spending was on promotion, and that promotions increased the amount people bought by around a fifth. The offer does not just cut the price. It increases the quantity, and the quantity is where your money goes.
The test for any multibuy: check the unit price on the shelf label, then ask — would I buy two of these if there were no offer? If the answer is no, the "saving" is a second purchase you didn't want.
Trap 3: The discount code that makes you add things
A code gives you 20% off — but only on orders over $75. Your cart is $60, so you add a $25 item you don't need. With the code you pay $68 ($85 × 0.8). Without it you would have paid $60. The code "saved" you $17 and cost you $8.
Codes and vouchers are designed this way on purpose: the minimum spend sits just above the average basket, and the discount is the bait that pulls you over it. The same logic applies to "spend $100, get $20 off" offers and to loyalty points that only unlock at a threshold. The saving is real only if the extra item was already on your list. If it wasn't, you have paid money to earn the right to pay less money — and come out behind.
Trap 4: Buying it because the sale ends at midnight
Countdown timers, "only 3 left", "offer ends tonight" — urgency is the oldest trick in retail, and it works by removing the one thing that protects you: time to think. The Which? research is the antidote. Of the 175 products it tracked for a year around Black Friday 2024, 68% were the same price or cheaper after the sales period ended, and 35% were actually cheaper. Waiting was rarely punished.
The pattern repeats in every year Which? has run the study. In 2023 it tracked 227 products and found 92% were the same price or cheaper at some other point; in 2020, of 201 deals tracked, 99.5% were the same price or cheaper elsewhere in the year, and only one product was at its cheapest on Black Friday alone. A deadline that returns next month was never a deadline. It was a timer designed to stop you checking.
If a deal is only good until midnight, treat that as information about the seller, not about the price. A genuine bargain will still be a bargain after you have slept on it — and if it isn't, the price history will tell you.
Trap 5: The upgrade that's "basically the same price"
The standard model is $899. The pro model is $1,099 — "only $200 more". Two hundred dollars is not a rounding error: it is 22% more than the price you had already decided was right. The word "only" does the heavy lifting, shrinking the gap by comparing it with the total instead of with your budget.
This trap works because of anchoring. Once $899 is in your head as the reference point, $1,099 feels close to it. But $200 is 22% more than the price you had already decided was right. Ask what the upgrade actually does that you will use weekly. If you cannot name a specific use, you are paying $200 for a spec sheet.
Trap 6: Buying backups of things you haven't finished
Three bottles of shampoo at $8 each because they were on offer — while two full bottles already sit in the cupboard. That is $24 of cash converted into bathroom inventory. If one bottle expires, gets discontinued in your routine, or simply never gets used, $8 is gone. If all three get used eventually, you saved nothing except a future trip to the shop — and you paid for the privilege months early, with money that could have sat in a savings account instead.
Stockpiling only saves money when four things are all true: the item is one you use constantly, it does not expire before you use it, you have somewhere sensible to store it, and the price really is lower than its usual price. Check the unit price first — the Hong Kong watchdog found larger packs cost 2–35% more per unit than smaller ones in seven of fifteen product groups it compared. "Bigger pack, better value" is a claim, not a fact.
Trap 7: Half price on something you never planned to buy
A $60 jacket at 50% off costs $30. The tag says you saved $30. Your bank account says you spent $30. Both are true, and only one of them matters. Compared with not buying the jacket at all, you are $30 worse off — the "saving" exists only in a parallel world where you were definitely going to pay $60 for it.
This is the trap that does the most damage during sale season, because it feels the most virtuous. A 50% discount sounds like a financial win, and sale events are engineered to produce exactly that feeling: Adobe Analytics expects discounts to peak at up to 30% off listed price during the 2026 Cyber Week — but "listed price" is the key phrase. Discounts are advertised off the listed price, not off the price the item actually sold for most of the year. The EU and UK Omnibus rules require the "was" price to be the lowest price charged in the previous 30 days, and the US Federal Trade Commission's pricing guides say a former price must be a genuine price the item was regularly offered at — but the listed price can still be a price almost nobody paid.
Trap 8: "I saved $80" — after spending $120
The final item on the viral list is the summary of all the others: spending $120 on a $200 item and announcing an $80 saving. The $80 is measured against a "was" price. The $120 is measured against your bank balance. Only the second number is real money.
Run the same logic over a year and the scale becomes clear. The table below adds up the traps using the worked examples in this guide — modest, once-a-month habits, not extravagance.
| Trap | How often | Extra spent each time* | Cost per year* |
|---|---|---|---|
| Free-shipping filler | Monthly | $8 | $96 |
| Second item at 30% off | 4× a year | $28 | $112 |
| Discount-code top-up | 6× a year | $8 | $48 |
| Unplanned half-price buy | 6× a year | $30 | $180 |
| Backup that expires unused | 3× a year | $8 | $24 |
| The "only $200 more" upgrade | Once a year | $200 | $200 |
| Total | $660 |
*Own calculations from the worked examples above; an illustration, not a survey average. Your number depends on how often each trap catches you.
Six hundred and sixty dollars is not a fortune. It is also not nothing: it is roughly two months of the average American household's food-away-from-home spending, and it is money that left your account while you felt like you were saving it. That is what makes these traps different from ordinary overspending. Ordinary overspending feels like spending. These feel like winning.
The 10-second test before you buy
You do not need a spreadsheet. You need one question, asked before checkout, every time a discount is involved:
"Would I buy this, at this price, if there were no discount, no deadline and no free-shipping line to cross?"
If the answer is yes, buy it — the discount is a genuine bonus. If the answer is no, close the tab. Five checks make the question sharper:
- Check the price history. Free tools such as CamelCamelCamel or Keepa (for Amazon) and PriceSpy show what an item actually cost over the past few months. If the "was" price only existed for a week, the discount is theatre.
- Check the unit price. The shelf label tells you the cost per 100g, per wash or per item. Multibuys and larger packs often lose on unit price — that is the number that matters.
- Compare it elsewhere. A BOGO at one shop can still be dearer than a single item at another. The second item is only free if the first one was fairly priced.
- Count the total, not the saving. Read the checkout total, not the "you saved" line. The total is the only number your bank will ever see.
- Sleep on anything over $50. Which? found most sale prices return. If it is gone tomorrow, it was never your bargain — it was a deadline.
Frequently asked questions
Is buy-one-get-one-free ever worth it?
Yes — when you would genuinely buy two anyway, and the unit price beats the rival's single-item price. Check the shelf-edge unit price, not the headline. If the "free" item is something you will use, and the pair costs less than two singles elsewhere, take it. If you only wanted one, you paid extra for a spare.
Does free shipping ever save money?
Yes, when the filler item is something you were going to buy anyway at the same price, in the same week. Then the shipping really is free. But if you add an item to cross the line, compare the two totals: basket plus shipping versus basket plus filler. The smaller total wins, whatever the banner says.
Are Black Friday deals ever real?
Some are. Which? found products genuinely at their lowest price during the sale — but also found 83% of the products it tracked were the same price or cheaper outside the sale window. The way to tell is price history: check what the item cost over the past few months before you believe the "was" price.
What about cashback and loyalty points — are those savings?
Only on purchases you had already decided to make. Cashback of 5% on a $100 item you didn't need is $5 back and $95 gone. Points and cashback are a small rebate on spending, not a reason to spend. The same rule applies: planned purchase first, reward second.
Do the rules differ in the UK?
Yes, in useful ways. In the UK and EU, the Omnibus rules require a "was" price to be the lowest price charged in the previous 30 days. Since 1 October 2025, larger shops in England cannot offer volume promotions such as buy-one-get-one-free on food and drink high in fat, sugar or salt. In the US, the Federal Trade Commission's pricing guides require a former price to be a genuine regular price — but enforcement relies on shoppers spotting the trick, so the price-history check matters even more.
Key takeaways
- A discount only saves money on something you already intended to buy, at a price you would have paid anyway.
- Free shipping is the most expensive "free" in retail: 58% of shoppers add items to reach the threshold, and the filler usually costs more than the delivery it replaces.
- Which? found 83% of Black Friday products were the same price or cheaper outside the sale window — urgency is usually manufactured.
- Check the unit price on multibuys: watchdog studies have found BOGOs worth far less than 50% off, and larger packs that cost more per unit.
- Before checkout, ask: "Would I buy this at this price with no discount, no deadline and no free-shipping line?" If not, close the tab.
The viral post's list is not an attack on sales. Sales are fine. What it attacks is the feeling — the small rush of having "saved" money while spending it. That feeling is the product being sold, and it is the most profitable item in the shop. The defence is cheap and it fits in one sentence: count what leaves your account, not what the tag says you saved. Black Friday is just over a week away. You still have time to make a list, check the prices, and let the countdown timers run out without you.
Sources
- She's On The Money — 'Things that aren't savings' (Instagram, 6 Nov 2026)
- Which? Black Friday price tracking (via Lifoholic)
- Hong Kong Consumer Council BOGO survey (via SCMP)
- Omniconvert — Free Shipping Threshold (SellersCommerce 2026 data)
- The Evergreen Edit — The Zero-Price Effect
- Dealizard — Are Black Friday deals real? (Which? data + FTC guidance)
The MoneyHabit editorial desk researches, writes and reviews every article against our editorial policy.
The Sunday Habit
One useful money idea, every week.
A short, practical email every Sunday — no spam, no selling your address, unsubscribe anytime.
Advertisement
More in Smart Spending

Smart Spending · Explainer
Visa–Mastercard Settlement: Why Your Card May Cost 3% More
A judge decides on 16 November whether shops can refuse premium cards and add up to 3% at checkout. Here is what changes, when, and how to avoid paying it.
13 November 2026 · 10 min read

Smart Spending · Guide
Borrow, Don't Buy: The Library of Things Guide
Why buy a drill you'll use for 13 minutes in its lifetime? Borrow tools, cleaners and party gear for a few pounds a week — here's the maths.
15 November 2026 · 10 min read

Smart Spending · Guide
How to Haggle at a Car Dealership: The Numbers That Matter
The average new-car payment just hit a record $787 a month. Here is how to haggle the price down — the numbers, the scripts, and the traps to avoid.
14 November 2026 · 9 min read