Skip to main content

Guide

The 4% Rule in 2026: Does It Still Work?

Morningstar now puts the safe retirement withdrawal rate at 3.9%, while the rule's own creator says 4.7%. Here's what the 2026 numbers mean for your plan.

By MoneyHabit Editorial Team

14 November 2026 ยท 9 min read

Brass balance scale weighing gold coins against a seedling, with a timeline stretching to the horizon
In this article

For thirty years, retirement planning had a single magic number: 4%. Withdraw 4% of your savings in your first year of retirement, raise it with inflation each year after, and your money should last 30 years. Simple, memorable โ€” and, according to the newest research, slightly out of date. Morningstar's latest retirement-income research puts the safe starting rate for a 2026 retiree at 3.9%. Meanwhile Bill Bengen, the planner who invented the rule, now says his own updated figure is 4.7%. Two serious researchers, two different answers. Here is what the 2026 numbers mean, and how to pick a rate for your own plan.

Where the 4% rule came from

In October 1994, financial planner William Bengen published a study in the Journal of Financial Planning. He tested every 30-year retirement window in US market history back to 1926 and asked how much a retiree could withdraw in year one, then raise with inflation each year, without running out โ€” even if they retired in the worst year on record. The worst starting year was 1968, and the rate that survived it was 4.15%. The industry rounded it to 4%.

Four years later, the Trinity Study confirmed it: on a 50/50 stock-and-bond portfolio, a 4% withdrawal lasted 30 years in 95% of historical periods; on 75/25, in 98%. From the rule came the 25x rule โ€” at 4%, you need 25 times your annual spending invested. Spending $40,000 a year means a $1,000,000 target.

The 4% rule was never a promise. It was the rate that survived the worst 30-year stretch in US market history โ€” a floor, not a forecast.

Bengen himself has said the 4% figure is "actually the safe withdrawal rate for a worst-case scenario in history. If you're willing to be flexible, it's probably too conservative." Across all the start years he tested, the average safe rate was closer to 7%.

What the 2026 research actually says

Morningstar recalculates its safe starting withdrawal rate every year, using forward-looking assumptions about stock returns, bond yields and inflation rather than replaying history. Its latest State of Retirement Income research (published December 2025, for 2026 retirees) puts the base case at 3.9% โ€” $39,000 in year one on a $1 million portfolio, rising with inflation after that, with a 90% chance the money lasts 30 years, assuming 30% to 50% in stocks and excluding Social Security.

The number has moved every year with conditions: 3.3% for 2021 retirees, 3.8% for 2022, 4.0% for 2023, 3.7% for 2025, and now 3.9%. It rose slightly this year because Morningstar lifted its expected returns โ€” its long-term inflation assumption went from 2.29% to 2.46%. Even so, it sits below the classic 4%, and the gap is real money: on $1 million, 3.9% versus 4% is $1,000 a year, every year, for 30 years.

Why Morningstar and Bengen disagree

They answer different questions. Bengen replays actual US market history using 55% stocks, 40% bonds and 5% cash. His 2025 book, A Richer Retirement, raised his historical SAFEMAX from 4.15% to 4.7% after adding small-company and international stocks โ€” $47,000 a year on $1 million. He told Money.com he would "probably recommend something around 5.25% to 5.5%" for today's retirees.

Morningstar simulates thousands of possible futures from today's conditions. One reason its answer is lower is valuation: the Shiller CAPE ratio stood at 41.04 on 28 October 2026, against a long-run average of 17.44. Starting retirement when shares are expensive has historically meant lower returns ahead, and a forward-looking model prices that in.

The honest summary: for a 30-year retirement starting in 2026, the range runs from 3.9% to 4.7%. A retiree who wants fixed, inflation-adjusted income and will not cut spending can treat 3.9% to 4% as the safe starting rate. A retiree who trusts the historical record and holds a diversified portfolio can start at 4.7%. Anything above 4.7% depends on cutting spending in bad years.

How long your retirement lasts changes everything

The 4% rule was built for 30 years โ€” retire at 65, live to 95. Retire at 50 and you are funding 40-plus years, and every extra decade lowers the sustainable rate. Morningstar's figures: 35 years supports 3.5%, 40 years about 3.2%. Researcher Michael Kitces has noted that 3.5% "effectively forms a safe withdrawal rate floor" in the historical data at a 45-year horizon. In practice, an early retiree should plan on 3.2% to 3.5% โ€” roughly 29 to 31 times annual spending โ€” rather than the classic 25x.

Watch the first five years. Morningstar found retirees who hit poor returns in the first five years and did not adjust spending were far more likely to run out than those whose first five years were positive. Withdrawing $40,000 from a portfolio that has fallen from $1,000,000 to $600,000 is a 6.67% draw, and selling shares at those prices early on breaks plans that look fine on average returns. High inflation early in retirement does the same damage.

The flexible route: guardrails

There is a way to start higher โ€” but it costs certainty. Flexible strategies tie spending to the portfolio's value, cutting after bad years and raising after good ones. Morningstar's guardrails strategy supports a 5.2% starting rate on a 40/60 portfolio, and its most flexible methods reach 5.7%. The best-known version, Guyton and Klinger's 2006 decision rules, starts at 5%: cut the withdrawal by 10% if it climbs to more than 20% above the starting rate, raise it 10% if it falls more than 20% below, and skip the inflation raise after a negative market year.

But the cuts can be brutal โ€” researchers found retirees starting in October 1965 ended up spending 54% below plan in real terms, and a 1966 example bottomed out at $16,400 a year on a $40,000 plan. Guardrails work best when Social Security, a pension or an annuity already covers the essentials, so a big cut lands on travel and gifts rather than rent and food. Holding one to two years of spending in cash or short bonds also means a cut year does not force stock sales at the bottom.

What about the UK?

The maths travels. Morningstar's UK edition puts the 2026 base case for a British retiree at 4.1% โ€” slightly higher than the US figure, reflecting different bond yields and inflation expectations. UK retirees drawing down a pension face the same trade-offs, but there is no UK equivalent of a guaranteed safe rate, and drawdown income is not protected by the FSCS the way deposits are โ€” the pot itself is invested, so its value can fall.

How to pick your own withdrawal rate

  1. Retirement length. 30 years: start at 3.9% to 4% (25x your spending). 35 to 45 years: 3.2% to 3.5% (about 29x to 31x). Beyond that, stay near the 3.5% historical floor.
  2. Portfolio mix. Morningstar's best fixed-spending results came from 30% to 50% in stocks; Bengen's 4.7% assumes 55% stocks, 40% bonds and 5% cash, with small-cap and international holdings. Mostly cash, or one single stock, supports less than either.
  3. Guaranteed income. If Social Security, a pension or an annuity covers housing, food, insurance and healthcare, the portfolio only funds the discretionary gap โ€” and that part can run higher. Morningstar found delaying Social Security pairs especially well with flexible withdrawals: in its base case, a $39,000 withdrawal plus a $36,000 Social Security benefit gives $75,000 of first-year spending.
  4. Spending flexibility. If you could live through a cut of 40% or more in a bad decade, guardrails justify starting around 5%. If your budget has no slack, stay at 3.9% to 4%.
  5. Taxes and fees. Every rate here is before tax and fees. If 20% of each withdrawal goes to tax, a 4% draw from a pre-tax account leaves 3.2% to spend โ€” and a 1% annual advisory fee on a 4% plan leaves roughly 3% for you.

One more reason not to panic: the 4% rule protects against running out, and in most historical periods it underspent badly. Kitces found that with a 4% start on a rebalanced 60/40 portfolio, the median wealth left after 30 years was almost 2.8 times the starting principal. And David Blanchett's "retirement spending smile" shows real spending typically falls about 1% a year early in retirement and closer to 2% a year in the slow-go years โ€” so holding real spending flat for 30 years, as the rule assumes, overstates what many households actually spend.

Frequently asked questions

Is the 4% rule dead?

No โ€” but it is no longer the single answer. For a 2026 retiree, Morningstar's forward-looking base case is 3.9%, Bengen's updated historical figure is 4.7%, and flexible strategies can start at 5% or more. The rule survives as a starting point and a worst-case benchmark, not as a law.

What if I retire early, at 50 or 55?

Plan on a lower rate. A 40-year retirement supports roughly 3.2% to 3.5% starting withdrawals, and a 45-year horizon about 3.5% on the historical record โ€” 29 to 31 times your annual spending rather than 25 times.

Does the 4% rule work in the UK?

The maths is the same, and Morningstar's UK model puts the 2026 base case at 4.1%. The differences are practical: UK retirees draw down pensions under different tax rules, the State Pension is flat-rate rather than earnings-linked, and there is no FSCS protection on invested drawdown pots.

Should I just withdraw 3.9% and never think about it again?

That is the safest simple option, but also the most likely to leave a large surplus. Most retirees are better off starting at 3.9% to 4%, checking the plan once a year, and adjusting. A February 2026 MetLife survey found 51% of retirees with money still in a workplace plan worry about running out, up from 30% less than a decade earlier. A written plan, reviewed annually, is the cheapest cure for that worry.

Key takeaways

  • Morningstar's 2026 base case is a 3.9% starting withdrawal rate for a 30-year retirement โ€” up from 3.7%, still below the classic 4%.
  • Bengen, who created the rule, now puts his updated historical figure at 4.7% โ€” and suggests 5.25% to 5.5% for retirees not starting in a worst-case year.
  • The right rate depends on your horizon: 30 years supports 3.9% to 4%, while 40 to 45 years needs 3.2% to 3.5%.
  • Flexible guardrail strategies can start at 5% or more, but the cuts can reach 50% in bad decades โ€” only use them if guaranteed income covers the essentials.
  • The first five years matter most: poor early returns or high early inflation are what break retirement plans.

So does the 4% rule still work? Yes โ€” as a starting point. For a 30-year retirement beginning in 2026, 3.9% to 4% is the defensible fixed-spending range, 4.7% is the historical worst-case figure, and anything above that is a flexibility bargain, not a guarantee. Your next step is simple: multiply your annual spending by 25, compare it with what you have saved, and if the gap is wide, decide whether you will save more, retire later, or build in the flexibility to spend less in bad years. That decision โ€” not the decimal point โ€” is what makes a retirement plan last.

Sources

Share this article

MoneyHabit Editorial Team

The MoneyHabit editorial desk researches, writes and reviews every article against our editorial policy.

More from MoneyHabit Editorial Team

The Sunday Habit

One useful money idea, every week.

A short, practical email every Sunday โ€” no spam, no selling your address, unsubscribe anytime.

Advertisement

More in Financial Literacy