Guide
Home Sales Hit a Record Low: Buy Now or Wait?
Pending home sales just hit their lowest level since 2001. Here is what the freeze means for buyers — and the maths that decides whether to buy now or wait.

In this article
Pending home sales in the United States just fell to the lowest level since records began: the National Association of Realtors reported on 18 November that its index dropped to 63.0 in October — down 4.7% in a month and 16.7% in a year. For would-be buyers, that number is more than a headline: almost nobody is signing contracts, and the reasons why matter more than the record itself.
This is not a crash. Prices are still rising, slowly. It is a freeze: buyers cannot afford the monthly payment at today's rates, and sellers will not give up the cheap mortgages they locked in years ago. The question is whether buying now or waiting is the better move. The answer is in the maths — and it is brutal at 7% mortgage rates.
What just happened
Pending home sales count contracts signed but not yet closed. Because a signed contract typically becomes a completed sale one or two months later, the index is the market's best early warning system. Here is what October showed:
| Measure | October 2026 | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| Pending Home Sales Index | 63.0 | Lowest since the series began in 2001 |
| Change from September | −4.7% | Second straight monthly record low |
| Change from a year ago | −16.7% | Every region fell, the West most (−20.3%) |
| Existing-home sales | 3.75 million annual rate | Weakest since August 2010 |
| Median existing-home price | $416,700 | Up 0.4% on the year — still rising |
| 30-year fixed mortgage rate | 7.33% average in October | Highest monthly average since 2000, bar one month in 2023 |
September was also a record low — 66, after a 7.3% monthly fall — so this is the second consecutive month the index has set a new floor. Yet prices have not followed sales down: the median price rose for the 40th consecutive month. Record-low activity, still-rising prices — that is what makes this market so difficult.
Why the market froze
Two causes reinforce each other. The first is the rate: the average 30-year fixed mortgage ran at 7.33% across October, peaking at 7.40% on 8 October before easing to 7.11% by 12 November, against 6.25% a year earlier. The second is the lock-in effect: most homeowners hold mortgages far cheaper than anything available today, so selling means giving up a bargain loan and borrowing again at more than 7%.
Federal Housing Finance Agency data shows 49.1% of outstanding US mortgages carry a rate under 4%, two-thirds sit under 5%, and the average rate on all outstanding mortgages is just 4.4%. Little wonder sellers stayed in their homes a median of 12 years, a record.
On the October median price of $416,700 with 20% down, the loan is $333,360:
| Mortgage rate | Monthly principal & interest | Total interest over 30 years |
|---|---|---|
| 3.5% (typical locked-in rate) | $1,497 | $205,537 |
| 6.25% (a year ago) | $2,053 | $405,560 |
| 7.33% (October 2026 average) | $2,292 | $491,839 |
Buying the same median home today costs $240 a month more than a year ago — and $795 a month more than a homeowner locked in at 3.5% pays. Over 30 years, the gap between borrowing at 7.33% and 3.5% is more than $286,000 in interest alone. Those are our own calculations on the NAR median price, excluding taxes, insurance and maintenance.
"October could mark the low point in contract signings for this housing cycle, as mortgage rates appear to have topped out." — Lawrence Yun, chief economist, National Association of Realtors
Yun also warned annual sales could be the lowest since the mid-1990s. The Fed is not riding to the rescue: minutes from its October meeting, released 18 November, show almost all policymakers considered further rate increases likely appropriate, and governor Christopher Waller has floated a half-point rise in December.
What the record low actually tells you
A record-low index is a signal, not a verdict. First, it is a leading indicator, not a price forecast. Contracts signed in October become closings in November and December, so expect very weak completed-sales figures for the rest of the year. It says nothing about where prices go next: so far they have refused to fall, because supply is even thinner than demand. Inventory stood at 1.59 million homes at the end of October, and distressed sales were just 2% of transactions — nobody is being forced to sell.
Second, the freeze is worst where prices are highest. The West posted the largest declines — down 20.3% on the year and 6.9% in a month, to an index value of 45.8. Expensive markets feel high rates first: the same rise adds far more dollars to a large loan.
Third, buyers who can still transact have leverage they have not had in years. First-time buyers made up just 29% of October sales, down from 32% a year earlier. Sellers are sitting longer, and a buyer with financing in place can negotiate on price, repairs and closing costs in a way that was impossible in the bidding wars of 2021 and 2022.
Buy now or wait? Run these three numbers
Forget headlines. Three calculations decide the question for most buyers.
1. The payment versus rent. Principal and interest on the median home at October's rate is $2,292 a month, against typical asking rent of $1,965 (Zillow, June 2026). The mortgage payment alone already exceeds typical rent by $327 a month — before property tax, insurance and maintenance, which a renter never pays. If the all-in cost of owning is far above renting a comparable home, waiting is usually cheaper.
2. The total interest. At 7.33%, that $333,360 loan costs $491,839 in interest over 30 years — more than the amount borrowed. At 6.25% it costs $405,560. Every percentage point of rate is worth roughly $80,000 over the life of this loan. If you believe rates will fall materially and you can refinance, buy now. If you believe rates stay high, wait — but refinancing is never guaranteed, and it costs thousands in fees each time.
3. The break-even horizon. Buying carries large one-off costs — closing costs when you buy, commission and more closing costs when you sell, typically 8–10% of the price across both transactions. You need to stay roughly five to seven years for buying to beat renting; a move within three years means renting almost always wins.
A quick check: the 5% rule. One rule of thumb, popularised by financial planner Ben Felix, puts the unrecoverable costs of owning — interest, tax, insurance, maintenance and the return you give up on your deposit — at about 5% of a home's value a year. On the $416,700 median home that is $20,835 a year, or about $1,736 a month. Rent well under that and renting is cheaper on pure cost; above it, owning starts to look better. A rough guide, not a verdict.
When buying now makes sense
- You plan to stay put. Seven years or more in the same home lets the one-off costs fade.
- You can afford the payment at today's rate, not a hoped-for rate. If the payment only works if rates fall to 5% next year, you cannot afford the house.
- You have found the right home at the right price. If the home fits your life for a decade and the seller will negotiate, the market average matters less than your specific deal.
When waiting wins
- The payment would stretch you. If the mortgage, tax and insurance would take more than roughly 30% of your gross income, waiting is protecting yourself.
- Your life is unsettled. A job change, a possible move or a growing family all argue for the flexibility of renting.
- Your deposit is small. Less than 10% down usually means private mortgage insurance on top of a 7% rate. A bigger deposit changes the maths more than a small rate move.
If you buy now, do it like this
Buying into a 7% market demands more discipline than buying into a 3% one. Get pre-approved, not just pre-qualified, so sellers take your offer seriously. Negotiate hard: ask for a price cut, seller-paid closing costs, or a seller-funded temporary rate buydown. Check total cost, not just the rate: a slightly higher rate with no points can beat a lower rate bought with thousands in fees. And think twice about adjustable-rate mortgages: if rates rise further, your payment rises with them. Keep three to six months of expenses in savings after the deposit and closing costs — a new home always costs more than the spreadsheet says.
Do not try to time the bottom. Nobody knows whether October was the low point or whether sales fall further if the Fed raises rates in December. Buying because you think you have called the bottom is speculation, not planning. Buy because the home fits your life and the payment fits your budget.
If you wait, use the time well
Waiting only works if you use it. Automate a deposit top-up into a high-yield savings account every payday. Work on your credit score: a higher score can be worth a quarter-point or more on your rate, saving roughly $60 a month on a $333,360 loan. Watch two numbers — the 30-year rate and the pending sales index — not house-price headlines: those tell you when the freeze is thawing.
For UK readers, the picture rhymes. The Lloyds House Price Index — formerly the Halifax index — put the average UK home at £296,285 in October, down 1.2% on the year, with London down 3.1% to £524,892. The Bank of England raised Bank Rate to 4% on 5 November, and the average two-year fixed rate was about 5.5%.
Frequently asked questions
Does record-low pending home sales mean house prices will fall?
Not necessarily. Pending sales measure activity, not prices: in October, sales hit a record low while the median price still rose 0.4% on the year, because supply is even tighter than demand. Prices fall only when forced sellers appear in numbers — and distressed sales were just 2% of October transactions.
Should I wait for mortgage rates to fall below 6%?
Only if you can afford to wait and your rent is reasonable. Rates have eased from 7.40% in early October to 7.11% by mid-November, but the Fed's minutes point to further increases. A fall to 6% is possible, not promised — and if it happens, waiting buyers will return at once and push prices up again.
Is renting really cheaper than buying right now?
On monthly cash flow, often yes: principal and interest on the median home at 7.33% is $2,292, against typical asking rent of $1,965 — and the owner still pays tax, insurance and maintenance on top. Over the long term, buying can still win if you stay put for years, because rent rises while a fixed mortgage payment does not.
What does the lock-in effect mean for first-time buyers?
Less choice: owners with 3% mortgages are not listing, so the homes that do come to market are fewer and priced by sellers who do not need to sell. First-time buyers made up only 29% of October sales, down from 32% a year earlier. New builds are one partial escape — housing starts rose 9.9% in October, though that rise is within the Census margin of error — but builders pulled back on permits.
Key takeaways
- Pending home sales hit 63.0 in October — the lowest since the NAR index began in 2001, and the second straight monthly record low.
- Existing-home sales fell to a 3.75 million annual rate, the weakest since August 2010 — yet the median price still rose to $416,700.
- At 7.33%, the monthly payment on the median home is $2,292 — $240 more than a year ago, $795 more than a locked-in 3.5% mortgage.
- The lock-in effect is the other half of the freeze: nearly half of outstanding mortgages are under 4%.
- Buy now only if the payment fits at today's rate and you will stay put for years; otherwise, use the wait to build your deposit and credit.
The frozen market is frustrating, but also clarifying. When almost nobody is buying, the decision stops being about what the market will do and starts being about what you can afford and how long you will stay. Run the three numbers and let them decide. If they say buy, negotiate hard and keep a buffer; if they say wait, make the wait count. The worst move is the one made in a panic.
Sources
The MoneyHabit editorial desk researches, writes and reviews every article against our editorial policy.
The Sunday Habit
One useful money idea, every week.
A short, practical email every Sunday — no spam, no selling your address, unsubscribe anytime.
Advertisement
More in Smart Spending

Smart Spending · Guide
The 1% Rule for Home Maintenance: Does It Still Work?
The 1% rule says budget 1% of your home's value a year for upkeep. In 2026, that number is too low for most owners — here's what the data says instead.
19 November 2026 · 11 min read

Smart Spending · Guide
Borrow, Don't Buy: The Library of Things Guide
Why buy a drill you'll use for 13 minutes in its lifetime? Borrow tools, cleaners and party gear for a few pounds a week — here's the maths.
15 November 2026 · 10 min read

Smart Spending · Guide
How to Spot a Fake Review Before You Buy
Fake reviews are now illegal in the US and UK — but enforcement is slow. Here's how to spot them before you buy.
15 November 2026 · 10 min read