Skip to main content

Guide

Still Paying for Last Christmas? Clear Holiday Debt Fast

38% of Americans are still paying off last year's gifts — and half of them plan to charge this year's too. Here's the payoff plan that breaks the cycle.

By MoneyHabit Editorial Team

11 November 2026 · 10 min read

Gift box with a long receipt curling into a calendar page, gold coins and a seedling on a navy background
In this article

Last Christmas is eleven months behind you. For 38% of Americans, the bill is not. A new survey from The College Investor, published this week, found that more than a third of US adults are still paying off something they bought last holiday season — 28% on a credit card and 21% on a buy now, pay later plan. And the cycle is about to repeat: 49% of the people still paying off last year plan to put this year's gifts on a credit card too.

This is the quiet trap of holiday debt. It does not arrive as one big bill. It arrives as a $60 card minimum here, a $50 BNPL instalment there, and a balance that barely moves — while a new season of spending starts on top of it. The good news is that leftover holiday debt is usually small enough to kill before Christmas, if you treat it as a six-week project instead of background noise.

The numbers: who is still paying for last Christmas

The College Investor surveyed 600 US adults through Pollfish on 8 November 2026. The headline figure is 38% still paying off last year's gifts, but the breakdown shows who carries it hardest:

GroupStill paying off last yearOn a credit cardOn buy now, pay later
All adults38%28%21%
Ages 18 to 2944%28%29%
Parents of children under 1843%32%24%
Ages 30 to 4442%32%22%
Income under $50,00038%27%25%
Income $100,000 and up41%38%14%
Ages 60 and up21%21%7%

Two things stand out. First, younger adults carry it most: 44% of 18- to 29-year-olds are still paying, and 29% of them are still on a BNPL plan. Second, this is not a low-income problem. Households earning $100,000 or more are slightly more likely to still owe (41%) than households earning under $50,000 (38%) — the difference is the type of debt. Higher earners lean on credit cards; lower earners lean on BNPL.

LendingTree's survey after last season tells the same story from a different angle: 37% of consumers took on holiday debt, averaging $1,223, and 63% expected to need three months or longer to pay it off. Worse, 41% of people who took on holiday debt were already still paying off the previous year's Christmas when they did it. That is the cycle in one number: paying for two Christmases at once.

Why a $1,223 balance is still there a year later

The average holiday debt is not large. What keeps it alive is the interest rate it sits at. The Federal Reserve's G.19 release puts the average rate on credit card accounts that are actually charged interest at 22.36% (August 2026). At that rate, the speed of your payment matters far more than the size of the balance. Here is what happens to the average $1,223 holiday debt at 22.36% APR:

Monthly paymentTime to clearInterest paid
Minimum payments onlyAbout 90 monthsAbout $1,191
$50 a monthAbout 33 monthsAbout $425
$100 a monthAbout 15 monthsAbout $178
$150 a monthAbout 9 monthsAbout $116
$200 a monthAbout 7 monthsAbout $88

These are our own calculations, assuming no new charges and a fixed monthly payment. The minimum-payment row is the one to stare at: paying only the minimum turns $1,223 into roughly $2,414 over seven and a half years. Doubling the payment from $50 to $100 cuts the interest by more than half and the time by more than half. That is why the plan below starts with the payment, not the budget.

The fastest way to stop paying for last Christmas is to pick a fixed monthly number that clears it in weeks, not years — and then protect that number from this year's shopping.

The six-week clear-it plan

You have about six weeks until Christmas. That is enough to clear most leftover holiday balances outright, or to cut them down so far that January starts clean. Work the steps in order.

1. List every leftover balance, including the BNPL ones

Open every card statement and every BNPL app — Klarna, Afterpay, Affirm, PayPal Pay in 4, Zip — and write down each remaining balance, its interest rate or fee structure, and its next due date. BNPL plans are the ones people forget, because each instalment looks small. Four plans at $50 a month is a $200 monthly bill wearing a disguise.

2. Pay the highest-rate balance first

This is the debt avalanche: put every spare dollar at the balance with the highest interest rate while paying the minimum on the rest. The College Investor's own worked example makes the point — a $1,000 balance at 24% APR takes 26 months and about $290 of interest at $50 a month, but 6 months and about $65 at $200 a month. The rate does the damage; attack it first.

3. Set one fixed payment and automate it

Pick the monthly number from the table above that fits your budget, then set it as an automatic payment for a date just after payday. A fixed payment beats a "pay what I can" intention because interest is charged on the balance every single month — every month you pay less, the balance costs more. Set autopay for at least the minimum on every other account at the same time, so nothing slips while your attention is on the main target.

4. Put every BNPL instalment on your calendar

A pay-in-four plan is four bills, not a discount. Add each instalment date to your calendar and check the money will be in your account on that date. If you already have a plan running, finish it before starting another. Missed BNPL payments carry late fees — Klarna charges up to $7 and Afterpay up to $8 per missed payment, with total late fees capped at 25% of the order — and a missed payment can freeze your account in the middle of December, exactly when you need it least.

5. Find the money in the next six weeks, not in January

Most people wait until January to deal with holiday debt, which is why it is still there in November. The survey found 57% of Americans plan to pay for gifts with cash or side-hustle earnings this year — the same energy, applied to last year's balance first, clears it. A few weeks of extra income, a cancelled subscription or two, and the money you would have spent on early Black Friday deals can cover a $1,223 balance before the season starts.

The one rule that breaks the cycle: clear last year's balance before you add a single new charge. More than half of the people who plan to use BNPL for gifts this year (54%) are still paying off something from last holiday season — and 40% of people still paying off a BNPL plan from last year plan to use one again. Stacking new debt on old debt is how one Christmas becomes two.

Watch the BNPL stack. An Omni Calculator survey found 53% of buy now, pay later users expect to still be making Black Friday payments after January 2027, compared with 16% of other shoppers. If you have three or more plans running, add up the monthly instalments before you open another one — the total is usually the surprise.

If you cannot clear it before Christmas

Sometimes the balance is bigger than six weeks of spare cash. That is still fixable — it just needs a different order of operations.

  • Do not skip the minimums. A missed card payment can mean a late fee, a penalty interest rate and a mark on your credit file. Autopay the minimum on everything, then attack one balance with whatever is left.
  • Consider a 0% balance-transfer card only if you can clear it inside the intro period. A transfer fee of 3–5% is cheaper than 22% interest, but only if the balance is gone before the promotional rate ends. If it is not, you have moved the problem, not solved it.
  • Ask your card issuer about a hardship programme. Many issuers will temporarily lower your rate or waive fees if you call and explain the situation. It costs nothing to ask, and the worst answer is no.
  • Cap this year's spending at cash. If last year's balance survives into December, this year's gifts should be paid for with money you already have. The survey found 27% of Americans plan to spend less on gifts this year — joining them is not deprivation, it is arithmetic.

The UK picture: new rules, same maths

UK shoppers face the same leftover-debt problem with a new set of protections. Since 15 July 2026, buy now, pay later in the UK has been regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority: lenders must run affordability checks before approving a plan, and you can take a complaint to the Financial Ombudsman Service if the lender will not put things right. Section 75 of the Consumer Credit Act now applies to eligible BNPL purchases of a single item costing £100 to £30,000, giving you the same refund route you would have had on a credit card.

Two catches matter. First, the rules only cover agreements taken out on or after 15 July 2026 — a plan you opened last Christmas is still unregulated, and the new protections do not apply to it. Second, the rules do not make the debt cheaper: an interest-free plan is only free if every instalment lands on time. The payoff maths above applies in pounds exactly as it does in dollars — a fixed monthly payment clears a balance in months; minimum payments stretch it into years.

Frequently asked questions

How many people are still paying off last Christmas?

38% of US adults, according to The College Investor's November 2026 survey of 600 adults — 28% on a credit card and 21% on a buy now, pay later plan. Younger adults (44% of 18- to 29-year-olds) and parents of children under 18 (43%) are the most likely to still owe.

How much holiday debt do people take on?

LendingTree's December 2025 survey found 37% of consumers took on holiday debt averaging $1,223, the highest since 2022. Parents of children under 18 averaged $1,324. Most borrowers (63%) expected to need three months or longer to pay it off.

Is buy now, pay later better than a credit card for gifts?

For a single planned purchase that you pay on time, yes — most pay-in-four plans charge no interest. The risk is stacking: several plans across different apps, each with its own due dates, add up to a monthly bill that is easy to lose track of, and missed payments bring late fees. Treat each plan as a bill, and finish one before starting another.

What is the fastest way to clear a $1,223 holiday balance?

At the average 22.36% card rate, $200 a month clears it in about 7 months for roughly $88 of interest. At $100 a month it takes about 15 months and $178 of interest. Minimum payments alone stretch it to about 90 months and roughly $1,191 of interest — nearly doubling what you borrowed.

Does the UK's new BNPL regulation help with old plans?

No. The FCA's rules, in force since 15 July 2026, apply only to agreements taken out on or after that date. Older plans stay unregulated, so the old advice still applies: pay them off, keep the instalment dates on your calendar, and do not stack new plans on top.

Key takeaways

  • 38% of Americans are still paying off last year's holiday gifts — 28% on a card, 21% on BNPL — and 49% of them plan to charge this year's gifts too.
  • The average holiday debt is $1,223. At the average 22.36% card rate, $200 a month clears it in about 7 months; minimum payments take about 90 months and roughly $1,191 of interest.
  • List every leftover balance, including BNPL plans, and attack the highest rate first with one fixed, automated monthly payment.
  • Treat each BNPL plan as a bill: calendar every instalment, finish one plan before starting another, and never stack new debt on an unpaid balance.
  • In the UK, BNPL has been FCA-regulated since 15 July 2026 — but only for new agreements. Last Christmas's plans are still unregulated.

Last Christmas's gifts are long unwrapped. The debt does not have to outlive the memory of them. List the balances tonight, pick the fixed payment that clears the biggest one before spring, and make this the last year you pay for two Christmases at once.

Sources

Share this article

MoneyHabit Editorial Team

The MoneyHabit editorial desk researches, writes and reviews every article against our editorial policy.

More from MoneyHabit Editorial Team

The Sunday Habit

One useful money idea, every week.

A short, practical email every Sunday — no spam, no selling your address, unsubscribe anytime.

Advertisement

More in Debt & Credit Education