Explainer
Variable Recurring Payments: The Direct Debit Replacement
Commercial variable recurring payments went live in the UK in June 2026. Here is how they work, what they replace, and when to switch your bills over.

In this article
Your energy bill, your broadband, your pension top-up: in the UK, most of them leave your account the same way they have for decades — by direct debit. Bacs, the network behind it, has run since 1968, and a payment still takes three working days to clear. In June 2026, the UK got its first new payment scheme since Faster Payments in 2008: commercial variable recurring payments, or cVRP. It is direct debit's first serious challenger, and if you pay bills from a UK bank account, it will reach you soon.
This is not a product you buy. It is a new way for businesses to collect money from your bank account, built on open banking. When your energy supplier or pension provider offers you the choice, should you switch? Here is how it works, what it does better than direct debit, and where it is still weaker.
What variable recurring payments actually are
A variable recurring payment (VRP) is an open-banking payment instruction. You authorise a business — once — to take payments of varying amounts from your bank account, within limits you agree upfront. The business can then collect money automatically.
There are two kinds, and the distinction matters:
- Sweeping VRP (sVRP): money moving between two accounts that both belong to you — for example, an app that sweeps spare cash into savings or pays your credit card automatically. This has existed for several years under a framework dating to 2021.
- Commercial VRP (cVRP): money moving from you to a business. This is the new part. Until June 2026 there was no agreed commercial model for it — no way for banks and payment providers to be paid for serving third-party payees.
The fix was organisational as much as technical. In December 2025, 31 firms — including Barclays, HSBC, NatWest, Monzo, Revolut and TrueLayer — agreed to fund a new industry-owned company, the UK Payments Initiative (UKPI), to own and operate the scheme. UKPI launched commercial VRP on 2 June 2026.
Commercial VRP is effectively the recurring version of Pay by Bank: link your account once, then payments happen automatically — but with caps you set and the power to cancel instantly from your banking app.
How a commercial VRP works in practice
Setting one up takes a few minutes, and the first payment can happen in the same flow:
- You choose the new payment method at checkout or in the provider's app — it may be labelled "Pay by Bank" rather than VRP.
- You set the mandate parameters: the maximum amount of a single payment, the maximum total per period (usually per month), and how long the consent lasts.
- You pick your bank and log in with your usual biometric authentication.
- You review and approve the mandate inside your own banking app.
- You are sent back to the merchant's site, where the payment and the linked account are confirmed instantly.
After that, merchant-initiated payments — your energy bill, for example — are collected automatically and you are notified. A payment outside the limits you set cannot be taken.
The control sits with you. You can view the mandate, change the limits or cancel it entirely from your banking app at any time — unlike a direct debit, where the mandate lives with the company collecting the money.
What you can already pay with it
The rollout is happening in phases called "waves". Wave 1 went live in June 2026 and covers lower-risk, regulated sectors:
| Wave 1 — live now | What it covers |
|---|---|
| Regulated financial services | Investing and trading platforms, pension providers, FCA-regulated mortgage providers |
| Utilities and telecoms | Electricity and gas, water, broadband and mobile |
| Government | Taxes, fines, council tax; Transport for London |
| Housing | Regulated rent, ground rent, tenancy deposits, service charges |
| Charities and e-money | Repeat donations to UK-registered charities; payments into e-money accounts |
| Rail | Train tickets and season ticket renewals |
The first live examples are in investing: TrueLayer's cVRP product, called Bank on File, is already used by InvestEngine and Trading 212 for recurring deposits. InvestEngine reports that 98% of its Bank on File payments complete successfully — a merchant-reported figure, not an independent audit.
A Wave 1 extension expected in late 2026 or early 2027 adds car finance, personal loan repayments and fundraising platforms. Wave 2, expected in 2027, changes everyday spending: subscriptions, one-click e-commerce checkout, food delivery, supermarkets, EV charging and marketplaces. Unlike direct debit, a subscription provider will be able to collect a payment at the point you subscribe.
VRP vs direct debit vs card-on-file
Here is the honest comparison, using TrueLayer's at-a-glance table as the starting point:
| Commercial VRP | Direct debit | Card-on-file | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Time to first payment | Instant | 6–10 days | Instant |
| Setup authentication | Biometrics (strong customer authentication) | Paper or online form | Manual card entry |
| Settlement speed | Instant | 1–3 business days (Bacs cycle) | Up to 3 business days |
| Limits you set | Yes — per payment and per period | Limited | None |
| Cancellation | Instant, in your banking app | Through your bank | Depends on the merchant |
| Confirmation of funds | Yes | No | No |
| Breaks when… | Your bank doesn't support it yet | Rarely — accounts don't expire | Your card expires or is replaced |
Two features change your day-to-day experience. Confirmation of funds: before collecting, a business can silently check whether you have enough in your account. If you don't, it can reduce the amount collected or warn you to top up, instead of the payment bouncing. That matters: the FCA's own research, cited by TrueLayer, found 7.4 million UK consumers feel burdened by bills and credit commitments, and 5.5 million had missed a payment in the previous six months. Instant settlement: direct debit runs on the Bacs three-day cycle and does not process at weekends or on bank holidays, so a payment submitted on Friday can settle the following Tuesday. VRP runs on Faster Payments, so money moves immediately.
The catch: what VRP does not give you
None of this makes direct debit obsolete. There are three honest reasons to pause before switching a bill.
1. You lose the Direct Debit Guarantee. This is the big one. The Guarantee — offered by all banks and building societies that accept direct debits — entitles you to a full and immediate refund from your own bank if an error is made in the payment, with no time limit on the claim. You must also be told in advance, normally 10 working days, if the amount, date or frequency changes. That guarantee is specific to direct debit; it does not travel with you to VRP. UKPI operates its own dispute framework for the cVRP scheme, but it is new and untested at scale.
2. Coverage is not universal yet. The main UK banks support cVRP today, but smaller banks and neo-banks are still being added. If your bank is not on board, the option simply will not appear for you.
3. The everyday use cases are not here yet. Subscriptions and one-click shopping — the places where VRP would actually change how you pay — are Wave 2, expected in 2027, and the protection model for that wave is still being defined. What is live today is mostly bills and financial-services top-ups.
Do not switch a bill you cannot afford to have go wrong. For a mortgage, a large energy bill or anything with a hard deadline, the Direct Debit Guarantee is worth more than instant settlement. Try VRP first on a small, low-stakes payment — a charity donation or a modest investment top-up.
Should you switch when you are offered it?
- Say yes if the payment is small or flexible, your bank supports VRP, and you have been burned by failed direct debits or expired cards breaking a subscription.
- Wait if the bill is large or time-critical, if you rely on the Direct Debit Guarantee, or if your bank does not support VRP yet. There is no penalty for waiting.
- Check first what happens when a payment fails: how the provider handles insufficient funds, how it notifies you, and how you cancel. The answers should be visible in your banking app, not buried in a PDF.
One more scope note: this is a UK scheme. There is no equivalent in the United States, where recurring payments still run on card-on-file or ACH debits.
One practical habit transfers directly from direct debit: keep a list of your live mandates. VRP mandates are visible in your banking app, which makes the audit easier than it ever was. Review them when you review your subscriptions, and cancel anything you no longer use.
How big is it already?
All forms of VRP together now account for 7.7 million payments a month in the UK, up from 4.9 million twelve months earlier, according to Open Banking Limited figures cited by TrueLayer. An earlier December 2025 report put VRP at 16% of all open-banking transactions. Growth so far is driven mostly by sweeping between your own accounts. The commercial wave is the part to watch.
Frequently asked questions
Is a variable recurring payment the same as a direct debit?
No. Both let a business collect money from your bank account automatically, but they run on different rails. Direct debit runs on Bacs, takes up to three working days to settle, and comes with the Direct Debit Guarantee. VRP runs on open banking and Faster Payments, settles instantly, lets you set your own caps, and can be cancelled instantly from your banking app — but it does not carry the Direct Debit Guarantee.
Can a company take more than I agreed?
Not within the scheme's rules. A VRP mandate has consent parameters: a maximum amount per payment, a maximum total per period, and an expiry date. A collection outside those parameters should not go through. Read the caps before you approve the mandate.
What happens if I don't have enough money in my account?
Unlike direct debit, the collector can check your balance before attempting the payment. It can reduce the amount, delay the collection, or warn you to top up — rather than the payment bouncing and triggering a failed-payment fee. The exact behaviour depends on the provider, so ask before you switch a bill that must be paid on time.
How do I cancel a VRP?
From your banking app, where the mandate is listed alongside your direct debits and standing orders. Cancellation is instant. You can also amend the limits rather than cancelling outright.
Will VRP replace direct debit?
Not soon. Direct debit's guarantee and near-universal coverage are hard to beat, and VRP's everyday use cases — subscriptions and e-commerce — are not expected until Wave 2 in 2027. The realistic outcome is that the two run side by side: VRP where speed, control and variable amounts matter, direct debit where the guarantee matters most.
Key takeaways
- Commercial variable recurring payments went live in the UK in June 2026 — the first new UK payment scheme since Faster Payments in 2008.
- You authorise a business once, with caps you set (maximum per payment, maximum per period, expiry), and it can then collect varying amounts automatically.
- Wave 1 covers utilities, government, financial services, rent and charities; subscriptions and one-click shopping arrive in Wave 2, expected in 2027.
- VRP settles instantly, cancels instantly from your banking app, and can check your balance before collecting.
- VRP does not carry the Direct Debit Guarantee, so for large or time-critical bills, direct debit still has the stronger safety net.
- Try it first on a small payment, and review your live mandates whenever you review your subscriptions.
Direct debit has survived for nearly sixty years because it is simple and its guarantee is genuinely strong. VRP is the first challenger that beats it on speed and control without asking you to hand over card details — but it is still young, its everyday use cases are a year away, and its protections are unproven. Do not switch everything, and do not ignore it either. Take the next bill that offers you the choice, check the caps, and try it on something small.
Sources
- TrueLayer — The complete guide to commercial variable recurring payments (cVRP)
- Trustly — What are commercial variable recurring payments (cVRPs)?
- MENA Advisory — UK Commercial VRPs Are Live
- Movimo — The Direct Debit Guarantee
- Business Expert — Direct Debit and Recurring Payments: A UK Business Guide (2026)
- Skydo — Bacs Direct Debit: Meaning, How It Works & Use Cases (2026)
- UK Parliament — Written questions on Direct Debit protections
The MoneyHabit editorial desk researches, writes and reviews every article against our editorial policy.
The Sunday Habit
One useful money idea, every week.
A short, practical email every Sunday — no spam, no selling your address, unsubscribe anytime.
Advertisement
More in Financial Technology

Financial Technology · Explainer
Direct Debit vs Standing Order: Which to Use When
Direct debits and standing orders both automate your bills, but they work in opposite directions — and the wrong choice can cost you fees and protection.
11 November 2026 · 15 min read

Financial Technology · Explainer
Kraken's Recurring ACH Deposits, Explained
Kraken's recurring ACH deposits auto-fund your account — free, from $1. How it works, what buying costs, and the catches to check first.
15 November 2026 · 10 min read

Financial Technology · Explainer
The Fed Repriced US Payments for 2027: What It Costs You
The Fed set its 2027 prices for the payment rails your bank uses. The gap between its 4.5-cent instant fee and your $25 wire charge is the real story.
13 November 2026 · 9 min read