Skip to main content

Guide

Should You Walk Away From a Low Mortgage Rate?

A Virginia couple is giving up a 2.7% mortgage after Ramit Sethi showed them a $6.2m alternative. Here's how to run the same maths on your home.

By MoneyHabit Editorial Team

20 November 2026 ยท 12 min read

Brass house key at a fork in the road, with a balance scale weighing a small house against a gold coin
In this article

A Virginia couple with a 2.7% mortgage on a $595,000 house is about to give it up. Chloe, 32, and Jake, 30, told personal finance author Ramit Sethi on his November 3 podcast that the house they bought in late 2020 has become a burden: eight hours of yard work most weekends, a pool and 1.5 acres they never wanted, and a monthly cost closer to $4,500 once maintenance is counted. Sethi ran the numbers and told them that selling now and investing the roughly $250,000 of equity could leave them with about $6.2 million in 25 years, against about $4.8 million if they stay. They have talked to a real estate agent and plan to move to the West Coast.

The story has spread fast because it breaks a rule most homeowners treat as sacred: never give up a cheap mortgage. With the average 30-year fixed rate at 7.11% in Freddie Mac's November 12 survey, and just 19.2% of outstanding US mortgages carrying a rate below 3%, walking away from a 2.7% loan looks like financial self-harm. But the rate is only one line in a much longer bill.

The story in numbers

Chloe and Jake bought the four-bedroom Virginia house from Jake's parents in late 2020, skipping the home inspection and taking it as it was. Their budget had been $500,000; the house appraised at $595,000. They had been paying $2,400 a month in rent, and Jake believed rates that low would never return. The mortgage went in Jake's name alone, because averaging their two credit scores would have put them under the 760 cutoff they were aiming for.

FigureWhat it was
House appraised at$595,000 (budget was $500,000)
Mortgage rate locked in2.7% (average was near 2.65% in January 2021)
Monthly payment with escrow$2,990, later $3,072
True monthly cost, upkeep includedAbout $4,500
Home equity loan for Airbnb renovation$80,000 (about $45,000 still owed)
RV bought for $50,000, sold two years later$30,000 to $32,000
Household income$30,166 a month before tax ($361,992 a year)
Investments, savings, net worth$304,000 invested, $68,000 saved, $692,000 net worth
Equity if they sellRoughly $250,000
Sethi's 25-year projection, stay vs sell and investAbout $4.8 million vs about $6.2 million

The details matter because they show the trap. The couple did not buy the house because they wanted that house. As Sethi put it, they bought because they felt they were supposed to become homeowners, then spent money trying to force the lifestyle they actually wanted out of a property that did not fit it: an $80,000 home equity loan for an Airbnb conversion in an area with soft rental demand, and a 44-foot RV that never went on a single trip.

Why a cheap rate can still be a bad deal

A low mortgage rate saves you money on interest. It does not save you money on anything else a house costs, and those other costs are large. Chloe and Jake's payment with escrow is $3,072 a month, but they estimate the house costs them about $4,500 a month once maintenance and other ownership costs are added. That is roughly $1,400 a month, or nearly $17,000 a year, beyond the mortgage payment.

That gap is normal. Property taxes, insurance, maintenance, repairs, utilities on a larger home, and the value of your own time all sit outside the mortgage payment. A common planning rule is to budget about 1% of a home's value a year for maintenance alone, about $5,950 a year on a $595,000 house before a single repair. Add a pool, 1.5 acres of grounds, and a well and septic system, and the real number climbs fast. Sethi's point was blunt: without the house, the well and the septic system would not even be on their list of problems. Then there is the time cost: eight hours of yard work on a typical weekend is a part-time job the couple never applied for.

A 2.7% mortgage is a great deal on a loan. It is not, by itself, a reason to live somewhere that makes you unhappy.

The lock-in effect is real, and it is keeping millions of people in homes that no longer fit. Data from the Federal Housing Finance Agency's National Mortgage Database for the second quarter of 2026 shows 49.1% of outstanding US mortgages carry a rate below 4% and 77.6% are below 6%, while the average rate on all outstanding mortgages is 4.4%. A 2024 FHFA working paper found that for every percentage point by which market rates exceed a borrower's original rate, the probability of selling falls by 18.1%. Chloe spent eight months going back and forth for exactly this reason.

The maths that actually decide it

Forget the rate for a moment and compare the two futures properly. The right comparison is not 2.7% versus 7.11%. It is the total cost of staying against the total cost of leaving, including everything you pay, everything you earn, and what your time is worth.

Start with the rate gap in cash terms. Take a $300,000 loan over 30 years. At 3% the monthly principal and interest payment is about $1,265. At 7.1% it is about $2,016. That is a difference of roughly $750 a month, or about $9,000 a year, on the same loan balance. That is the real price of giving up a low rate, and it is large.

But now put the other side of the ledger next to it. Chloe and Jake's house costs them about $1,400 a month beyond the mortgage payment. If they sell, rent somewhere that fits their life, and invest the equity, the question becomes whether the extra ownership costs they escape are bigger than the extra interest they would pay if they ever borrow again. Sethi's answer for them was yes, by a wide margin: about $6.2 million versus about $4.8 million over 25 years, even after allowing for rent eating into some of the gain.

Do the comparison on total monthly cost, not on the interest rate. Add taxes, insurance, maintenance and a realistic value for your time to the mortgage payment before you decide the rate is worth staying for.

What selling actually costs

Selling is expensive, and the bill is the part of the decision most people underestimate. The equity figure Sethi quoted, roughly $250,000, is the sale price minus the mortgage balance. The money the couple would actually have to invest is smaller, because selling costs come out first.

Cost of sellingTypical rangeOn a $595,000 sale
Agent commissions4.7% to 5.7% of sale priceAbout $28,000 to $34,000
Seller closing costs1% to 3% of sale priceAbout $6,000 to $18,000
Repairs and preparation1% to 3% of sale priceAbout $6,000 to $18,000
MovingVaries widelySeveral thousand dollars
Total selling costsAbout 8% to 10% of sale priceAbout $48,000 to $60,000

Commission is the largest single line. Since the 2024 National Association of Realtors settlement, buyer agent commission is no longer included in MLS listings, so the split is negotiated deal by deal; a July 2026 survey of 500 recent sellers found they actually paid closer to 4.7% in total commission. On a $595,000 sale the couple should expect roughly $48,000 to $60,000 of total selling costs, cutting their investable equity from about $250,000 to roughly $190,000 to $200,000.

One piece of good news on tax: in the US, if you have owned and lived in the home as your main residence for at least two of the last five years, you can generally exclude up to $250,000 of capital gain if single, or $500,000 if married filing jointly, from federal tax. Chloe and Jake bought in late 2020 and lived there throughout, so their gain is likely to fall inside the exclusion.

Do not count your full equity as investable cash. Selling costs of 8% to 10% of the sale price come out first, and on a $595,000 home that is roughly $48,000 to $60,000. Get a net sheet from your agent before you run any investment projection.

When keeping the low rate wins

Walking away is not the default answer. For many owners, the low rate genuinely is worth keeping, and the maths says so.

Keep the low rate ifโ€ฆWalk away ifโ€ฆ
The house still fits your life and locationThe house no longer fits, and moving would fix that
Your true monthly ownership cost is close to your mortgage paymentMaintenance, taxes and upkeep add $1,000+ a month beyond the payment
You would have to buy again immediately at 7%+You can rent happily for a while, or buy much cheaper
Your equity is small, so selling costs eat most of itYour equity is large enough to invest meaningfully after selling costs
You plan to stay for many yearsA move is coming anyway for work, family or health

The strongest reason to stay is that you would have to buy again straight away at today's rates. If you sell a $595,000 house and buy a similar one at 7.11%, the higher payment wipes out most of the benefit of escaping the upkeep. Chloe and Jake's plan works because they are not buying again immediately. They plan to move to the West Coast and rent while their invested equity compounds. The second reason to stay is a small equity balance: selling costs are charged on the sale price, not on your equity, so if you owe $500,000 on a $550,000 house, your $50,000 of equity can be consumed almost entirely by commission and closing costs.

The middle options most people miss

Selling and staying are not the only two choices. Renting it out is the one Chloe floated, and Sethi pushed back. A house with a pool, 1.5 acres, a well and a septic system still needs all of that maintenance, and now you are also a landlord. It can work if the rent comfortably covers the payment, taxes, insurance, maintenance and a vacancy allowance, and if you pay a property manager. It rarely works as a way to avoid dealing with a house you already dislike. Fix the house, not the address. Sometimes the problem is the costs around the house, not the house itself. Hiring out the yard work converts eight hours of your weekend into a bill you can see clearly; if that bill is $400 a month and the house otherwise works, it is far cheaper than selling. Wait, but on purpose. If you are not ready to sell, set the conditions that would change your mind and a date to revisit them. The mistake is drifting: staying because deciding feels hard, while the house keeps costing $4,500 a month. A deliberate pause with a review date is a decision. An indefinite one is not.

In the UK the picture is different, and in one way kinder. Many UK fixed-rate mortgages can be ported to a new property, so you can often keep your rate when you move, subject to the lender's approval, with any extra borrowing priced at current rates. The cost to watch is the early repayment charge if you leave a fixed deal early, typically 1% to 5% of the outstanding balance in the early years.

Frequently asked questions

Is it ever sensible to give up a mortgage under 3%?

Yes, when the total cost of staying is higher than the total cost of leaving. A 2.7% rate saves roughly $750 a month in interest on a $300,000 loan compared with 7.1%, but if the house costs $1,400 a month beyond the mortgage payment in taxes, insurance, maintenance and your time, the rate saving is not covering the ownership bill. Run the full comparison, not just the rate gap.

How much does it actually cost to sell a house?

Budget 8% to 10% of the sale price in total. Agent commissions are the largest piece at roughly 4.7% to 5.7%, seller closing costs run 1% to 3%, and repairs and preparation add another 1% to 3%, plus moving. On a $595,000 sale that is roughly $48,000 to $60,000 before your mortgage is paid off.

Will I pay tax on the gain if I sell?

In the US, usually not on a main home. If you owned and lived in the home for at least two of the last five years, you can generally exclude up to $250,000 of gain if single, or $500,000 if married filing jointly, from federal tax. Gains above the exclusion, and gains on homes that were not your main residence, are taxed.

Key takeaways

  • A low mortgage rate saves interest, but it does not pay your taxes, insurance, maintenance or your time. Chloe and Jake's house cost about $4,500 a month against a $3,072 mortgage payment.
  • Compare total cost of staying against total cost of leaving, not 2.7% against 7.11%. On a $300,000 loan the rate gap is worth roughly $750 a month; ownership costs beyond the payment can easily exceed that.
  • Selling costs run 8% to 10% of the sale price. On a $595,000 sale that is roughly $48,000 to $60,000, so the investable equity is far less than the headline equity figure.
  • Walking away works best when you can rent happily for a while, your equity is large after selling costs, and the house itself is the problem. It works worst when you must buy again immediately at a much higher rate.
  • In the US, the capital gains exclusion of up to $250,000 single or $500,000 married on a main home often means no federal tax on the gain. In the UK, check whether your mortgage is portable before assuming you are locked in.

Chloe and Jake's story went viral because it feels wrong. A 2.7% mortgage in a 7.11% world is the kind of financial asset people dream about, and giving it up looks reckless. But a mortgage rate is not a prize to protect at any cost. It is one line in the bill for a home, and if the rest of the bill, the upkeep, the land, the weekends lost to yard work, costs more than the rate saves, then the rate is keeping you in a house you do not want. That is not a good deal. It is golden handcuffs.

If you are in the same position, do the exercise Sethi did with them. Add up your true monthly cost of ownership, every line of it, and get a net sheet from a local agent so you know what selling would actually leave you. Then compare staying against leaving on total cost, not on the rate. If the numbers say stay, stay gladly. If they say go, go, and stop letting a number on a loan statement decide where you live.

Sources

Share this article

MoneyHabit Editorial Team

The MoneyHabit editorial desk researches, writes and reviews every article against our editorial policy.

More from MoneyHabit Editorial Team

The Sunday Habit

One useful money idea, every week.

A short, practical email every Sunday โ€” no spam, no selling your address, unsubscribe anytime.

Advertisement

More in Money Habits